Smallcakes of Fort Myers: Gourmet Cupcakes, Custom Cakes, and Specialty Ice Cream for Florida Events

Smallcakes of Fort Myers Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Florida locals with a serious sweet tooth, **Smallcakes of Fort Myers** is much more than just an ice cream shop—it is a renowned destination for gourmet desserts. While the name suggests a focus on small treats, this establishment serves as a full-fledged Cupcake Shop, Bakery, Dessert shop, and Ice cream shop, specializing in creations that have gained national recognition, including multiple appearances on the Food Network’s “Cupcake Wars.”

Located conveniently in the heart of Fort Myers, Smallcakes is celebrated for baking and frosting its signature cupcakes **fresh from scratch every morning**. The core mission is to provide the finest dessert experience through creative flavors, high-quality ingredients, and friendly service. The menu extends far beyond their famous cupcakes, featuring stunning custom cakes for birthdays and weddings, delectable cheesecakes, and, notably, a unique line of **specialty ice cream** inspired by their best-selling cupcake flavors. This fusion of premium cupcakes and small-batch ice cream makes Smallcakes the perfect spot to cool down with a rich, unique treat in the Florida heat. Owned and operated by a local couple, the business is also proud to be identified as women-owned and fosters a welcoming atmosphere as an **LGBTQ+ friendly and Transgender safespace**, reinforcing its role as a warm, inclusive member of the Southwest Florida community.

Location and Accessibility

Smallcakes of Fort Myers is situated in a highly accessible and central location, making it easy for residents of Fort Myers and surrounding areas to stop by for a quick treat or to pick up a special order.

The physical address is:

**11150 S Cleveland Ave #140, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA**

This prime spot on **South Cleveland Avenue (US-41)** is crucial for local access, positioned in a busy commercial corridor near major shopping and residential areas. The shop has prioritized customer comfort and convenience, offering several key accessibility features:

**Wheelchair Accessible Entrance:** Ensures smooth entry for all patrons.
**Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot:** Dedicated parking spaces are available for easy access.
**Wheelchair Accessible Restroom:** Provides comfortable, accessible facilities inside the shop.
**Wheelchair Accessible Seating:** Ensures all customers can comfortably enjoy their treats inside the venue.

Additionally, the location provides a **Free parking lot** and is structured for a **Quick visit**, ideal for grabbing a coffee or a cupcake on the go.

Services Offered

Smallcakes of Fort Myers provides a comprehensive suite of services that cover everything from a single scoop of ice cream to complete wedding cake coordination.

**Daily Fresh Gourmet Cupcakes:** Baking and frosting at least 12 signature flavors every morning, including classics like **Famous Red Velvet** and **Wedding Cake** ($5.25), along with daily specials. Mini Dozen cupcakes are also available ($26.00).
**Specialty Ice Cream & Creamery:** Offering various unique, small-batch ice cream flavors often inspired by their signature cupcakes, perfect for cooling off in the Florida heat.
**Custom Cake and Bakery Services:** Specializing in custom cakes for major life events, including elaborate **Wedding Bakery** services (e.g., Rustic Birch Tree Wedding Cake) and themed **Birthday Cakes** (e.g., Unicorn Cake, Chocoholic Cake), starting from $45.00.
**Cheesecakes and Cookie Cakes:** A wide variety of decadent specialty desserts, such as **S'Mores Cheesecake** ($65.00) and **Gluten Free Cookie Cake** ($50.00).
**Coffee and Drinks:** Serving a selection of gourmet coffee, including local-themed **Jimmy Java Coffee** options like Cold Brew Espresso ($5.00) and flavored coffee blends ($13.00), perfectly paired with their desserts.
**Creative DIY Kits:** Providing interactive, fun options like the **Decorate Your Own Cupcake Kit** ($30.00) and **Decorate Your Own Cookie Kit** ($25.00), great for local parties or family fun at home.
**Flexible Ordering & Pickup:** Offering multiple convenient service options: **Dine-in**, **Takeout**, **Delivery**, **Curbside pickup**, **In-store pickup**, and a **Drive-through** option for maximum convenience.
**Pet-Friendly Treats:** Even the family dog is included with dedicated **Dog Treats** ($7.00).

Features / Highlights

Smallcakes of Fort Myers has established its reputation through several standout features that resonate strongly with the local Florida dessert community.

**Award-Winning Cupcakes:** The brand's national acclaim, including multiple appearances on Food Network's “Cupcake Wars,” is a huge highlight, providing customers with confidence in the quality and creativity of the gourmet cupcakes.
**Exceptional Customer Service for Custom Orders:** The staff is frequently praised for being "very helpful and thoughtful," with testimonials specifically highlighting seamless coordination for complex custom orders, even from customers ordering remotely for weddings.
**Unique and Decadent Flavors:** The bakery is renowned for its intense flavor profiles, with customer favorites including the **Lemon Drop** (lemon cake filled with lemon curd), **Cannoli Cupcake** (vanilla bean with cream cheese buttercream and a real cannoli piece), and the seasonal **Italian Rainbow Cookie** cupcake.
**Full-Service Event Bakery:** Functioning as a specialized **Wedding Bakery**, Smallcakes offers beautiful, high-quality tiered cakes (like the Rustic Birch Tree) and large cupcake orders, positioning it as a top choice for Florida wedding planning.
**Inclusive and Welcoming Environment:** The official declaration as a **women-owned** business and an **LGBTQ+ friendly / Transgender safespace** makes Smallcakes a culturally vital and safe place for a diverse range of local customers to gather and enjoy a treat.

Contact Information

For Fort Myers residents planning a special occasion, craving a gourmet cupcake, or simply needing a cool ice cream break, here is the direct contact information for Smallcakes of Fort Myers.

**Address:**

11150 S Cleveland Ave #140, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA

**Phone (Primary and Mobile):**

(239) 313-5008

**Best Contact Method for Locals:**

Given the specialization in custom orders (including wedding cakes and large birthday cakes), Florida customers are advised to contact the shop directly via the provided phone number. The staff is noted for being highly responsive, making the phone an excellent tool for discussing custom designs, large group orders, or checking the daily availability of seasonal items and specialty ice cream flavors. The shop also accepts major electronic payments, including **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**, ensuring a fast and modern checkout process.

What is Worth Choosing

For us Floridians seeking the ultimate sweet treat, **Smallcakes of Fort Myers** is worth choosing because it masterfully combines **national acclaim with local, personalized service**. This isn't just an average ice cream shop; it’s a high-caliber gourmet bakery that happens to sell fantastic ice cream.

The first key reason is the **unmatched quality and flavor of their baked goods**. Customers consistently call their cupcakes "the best we have ever had," praising creative and classic options alike. The specialty ice cream, infused with their famous cupcake recipes, offers a unique and decadent way to beat the heat, making it a truly elevated dessert experience.

Secondly, Smallcakes is the ideal choice for **life’s biggest celebrations**. From a sophisticated **Rustic Wedding Cake** to a fun **Fortnite Cake** for a child's birthday, their expertise as a full-service bakery means locals never have to compromise on the appearance or the taste of their centerpiece dessert. The ability to handle complex custom orders with professionalism and warmth sets them apart in the event planning industry.

Finally, the **convenience and community focus**—from the drive-through and curbside pickup options to their welcoming, inclusive environment—ensure that whether you’re stopping by for a **Quick visit** or coordinating a massive event, the experience is seamless and pleasant. Choosing Smallcakes means supporting a local, women-owned business that delivers world-class desserts with a neighborly touch.

Smallcakes of Fort Myers Food & drink

Jimmy Java Coffee
Cold Brew Espresso $5.00
The unique blend of coffee is curated from around the world. Full balanced smooth cold brew.
Nitro Cold Brew $5.00
Captiva Calm $13.00
Matlacha Midnight $13.00
Sanibel Sunrise $13.00

Individual Cupcakes
Cannoli Cupcake $6.50
Pink Vanilla $5.25
Vanilla bean cake topped with our signature pink vanilla buttercream and garnished with pink sugar.
PInk Chocolate $5.25
Chocolate cake topped with our signature pink vanilla buttercream and garnished with pink sugar.
Chocoholic $5.25
A chocolate lover's favorite chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream frosting and garnished with chocolate shavings.
Vanilla & Chocolate $5.25
Vanilla cake topped with our signature chocolate buttercream and garnished with chocolate shavings.
Chocolate Cream $5.25
Chocolate cake filled with our signature buttercream topped with our rich fudge frosting and garnished with a dollop of buttercream.
Peanut Butter Cup $5.25
Chocolate cake topped with peanut butter, cream cheese buttercream and garnished with peanut butter cups, peanut butter, and fudge drizzle.
Cookies & Cream $5.25
Chocolate cake topped with our signature cookie buttercream topped with chocolate cookie crumbles.
Hot Fudge Sundae $5.25
Chocolate cake filled with fudge topped with our signature buttercream frosting and garnished with fudge drizzle chopped nuts and a cherry on top.
Famous Red Velvet $5.25
Our "Famous Red Velvet" cake is topped with cream cheese buttercream and garnished with red velvet crumbles.
Lemon Drop $5.25
Lemon cake filled with lemon curd, topped with lemon buttercream, and garnished with lemon curd.
Wedding Cake $5.25
An almond cake topped with our signature almond buttercream topped with candy pearls.
Birthday Cake $5.25
Vanilla bean cake topped with our signature vanilla buttercream and garnished with rainbow nonpareils.
Carrot Cake $5.25
Carrot cake with coconut and pecans topped with signature cream cheese buttercream garnished with crushed pecans.

Build Your Own Box
Build Your Box $10.00
2 Cupcakes (2 Flavors) $9.00 | 4 Cupcakes (4 Flavors) $20.00 | 6 Cupcakes (6 Flavors) $30.00 | 12 Cupcakes (12 Flavors) $54.00 • Flavors: Pink Vanilla | Pink Chocolate | Chocoholic | Vanilla N Chocolate | Cookies-N-Cream | Lemon Drop | Famous Red Velvet | Wedding Cake | Hot Fudge Sundae | Peanut Butter Cup | Chocolate Cream | Birthday Cake | Daily Special | Carrot Cake | Poop Emoji | Toilet Paper
Decorate Your Own Cookie Kit $25.00
Holiday-inspired cookie kit includes 6 cookies, icing, and sprinkles. All the ingredients for a fun project and a gift to celebrate family.
Decorate Your Own Cupcake Kit $30.00
6 Pieces $28.00 | 12 Pieces $48.00 • Fun for the kids, easy for you. Each kit includes 6 or 12 cupcakes, icing, and sprinkles.

Mini Cupcakes
Mini Dozen $26.00
Regular $24.00 | Gluten-free $26.00 | Vegan $28.00 • Box of 12 mini cupcakes.

For Dogs
Dog Treats $7.00

Birthday
Dusty Blush $62.00
5 inches $62.00 | 6 inches $76.00 | 7 inches $100.00 | 8 inches $145.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Simply elegant, Dusty Blush pink cake, 3 layers tall. Layered strokes of buttercream. Cream-colored, fresh roses and macarons on top. Can be color-customized.
Peanut Butter Drip Cake $65.00
5 inches $65.00 | 6 inches $81.00 | 7 inches $105.00 | 8 inches $160.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • If you love chocolate and peanut butter, then you'll love this cake. Layers of chocolate cake, filled with peanut butter buttercream. Topped with a chocolate and peanut butter drip and peanut butter cups.
Red Velvet Cake $65.00
5 inches $65.00 | 6 inches $81.00 | 7 inches $105.00 | 8 inches $160.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Our customers’ all-time favorite. Deep red velvet cake with a light taste of chocolate, and cream cheese filling. Topped with cream cheese buttercream frosting and red velvet crumbs. These cakes contain 2 layers.
Chocoholic Cake $65.00
5 inches $65.00 | 6 inches $81.00 | 7 inches $105.00 | 8 inches $160.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • The ultimate chocolate lover’s cake, moist layers of chocolate devil’s food, iced with our decadent chocolate buttercream frosting. It will be topped with tasty chocolate shavings.
Sprinkle Birthday Cake $65.00
5 inches $65.00 | 6 inches $81.00 | 7 inches $105.00 | 8 inches $160.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Our most popular vanilla cupcake turned into a birthday cake. Vanilla cake filled with vanilla buttercream and rolled in rainbow nonpareils. Little vanilla clouds of buttercream on top.
Slutty Brownie Cake $62.00
5 inches $62.00 | 6 inches $76.00 | 7 inches $100.00 | 8 inches $145.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Slutty Brownie cake is a combination of three favorite desserts. 1st layer is gooey chocolate chip cookie dough. 2nd layer is double stuffed Oreos. 3rd layer is warm, fudgy chocolate cake. Chocolate drip, more cookies, and brownies on top.
Carrot Cake $65.00
5 inches $65.00 | 6 inches $81.00 | 7 inches $105.00 | 8 inches $160.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Carrot cake with pecans and coconut, cream cheese filling and topped with cream cheese buttercream frosting. Topped with pecans. This decadent layer cake is sure to please. The round carrot cake contains 2 layers of cake.
Fruit Tartlet Cake $45.00
5 inches $45.00 | 6 inches $60.00 | 7 inches $75.00 | 8 inches $115.00 | 9 inches $145.00 | 10 inches $199.00 | 12 inches $240.00 • Vanilla cake with a Bavarian cream filling. Topped with fresh berries and a naked finish.
Milk Bar Inspired Birthday Cake $65.00
5 inches $65.00 | 6 inches $81.00 | 7 inches $105.00 | 8 inches $160.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Three tiers of sprinkled cake with all of the colors of the rainbow. Layers with vanilla bean signature buttercream, crunchy birthday crumbs, and more sprinkles.
Unicorn Cake $62.00
5 inches $62.00 | 6 inches $76.00 | 7 inches $100.00 | 8 inches $145.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • Soar over pastel rainbows into a world of wonder with our irresistible Unicorn Rainbow Cake. Colorful moist layers of rainbow vanilla cake, smooth vanilla buttercream and fondant decorations create a magical cake as enchanting as it is edible. Baked fresh to order from the finest ingredients for flavor beyond belief.
Fortnite Cake $62.00
5 inches $62.00 | 6 inches $76.00 | 7 inches $100.00 | 8 inches $145.00 | 9 inches $190.00
Rainbow Candy Cake $62.00
5 inches $62.00 | 6 inches $76.00 | 7 inches $100.00 | 8 inches $145.00 | 9 inches $190.00 • If you thought we couldn’t possibly surpass the magic of our Rainbow Cake, our brightest bake just got even more colorful. Every slice of this supercharged Rainbow Frosting Cake is a technicolor journey of deliciousness thanks to layers of freshly baked rainbow-colored vanilla cake wrapped in rainbow frosting. Add a name on the front for extra magic. Colorful lollipops and skittles waterfalls too. Our Rainbow Cakes contain 4 layers of cake.

Wedding
Rustic Birch Tree Wedding Cake $45.00
For each layer: 5 inches (5-6 Servings) $45.00 | 6 inches (8 Servings) $60.00 | 7 inches (10 Servings) $75.00 | 8 inches (12-15 Servings) $115.00 | 9 inches (15-20 Servings) $145.00 | 10 inches (22-28 Servings) $199.00 |12 inches (30-40 Servings) $240.00 • Rustic Birch Tree wedding cake with couple's initials. Florals and toppers of your choice can be added at an additional cost.
Naked Wedding Cake $45.00
For each layer: 5 inches (5-6 Servings) $65.00 | 6 inches (8 Servings) $81.00 | 7 inches (10 Servings) $105.00 | 8 inches (12-15 Servings) $160.00 | 9 inches (15-20 Servings) $140.00 | 10 inches (22-28 Servings) $190.00 |12 inches (30-40 Servings) $240.00 • Layers of light cake frosted with a rustic, textured finish
Ruffled Wedding Cake $45.00
For each layer: 5 inches (5-6 Servings) $75.00 | 6 inches (8 Servings) $91.00 | 7 inches (10 Servings) $115.00 | 8 inches (12-15 Servings) $160.00 | 9 inches (15-20 Servings) $200.00 | 10 inches (22-28 Servings) $240.00 |12 inches (30-40 Servings) $300.00
Naked Cake with Fresh Berries $45.00
For each layer: 5 inches (5-6 Servings) $65.00 | 6 inches (8 Servings) $81.00 | 7 inches (10 Servings) $105.00 | 8 inches (12-15 Servings) $160.00 | 9 inches (15-20 Servings) $190.00 | 10 inches (22-28 Servings) $240.00 |12 inches (30-40 Servings) $300.00 • Semi-naked cake with your choice of cake flavor, with fresh berries and baby's breath.
Rustic Wedding Cake $45.00
For each layer: 5 inches (5-6 Servings) $65.00 | 6 inches (8 Servings) $81.00 | 7 inches (10 Servings) $105.00 | 8 inches (12-15 Servings) $160.00 | 9 inches (15-20 Servings) $240.00 | 10 inches (22-28 Servings) |12 inches (30-40 Servings) $300.00 • Your choice of flavors. Florals and toppers are extra.

Cheesecakes
Strawberry Dream Bar $65.00
White Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake $65.00
The most delicious raspberry cheesecake ever. My rich and creamy white chocolate raspberry cheesecake is what dessert dreams are made of. This velvety cheesecake is made with a simple Graham Cracker crust and a creamy white chocolate cheesecake batter dotted with whole raspberries.
Red Velvet Cheesecake $65.00
Can’t decide between red velvet cake and cheesecake. Why not both? This dreamy dessert is made with layers of moist red velvet cake and rich cheesecake, topped with a luscious cream cheese frosting.
S'Mores Cheesecake $65.00
Amazing S’Mores cheesecake. Smooth cheesecake made with a layer of chocolate and marshmallows on the bottom and topped with hot fudge sauce and toasted marshmallows.
Reese's Peanut Butter Cheesecake $65.00
This truly decadent Reese's peanut butter cup cheesecake combines a buttery, Oreo cookie crust with a peanut butter cheesecake filling that's mixed with chopped pieces of miniature Reese's peanut butter cups. It's the perfect dessert to share with those who love cheesecake or a really good chocolate-peanut butter treat.
Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake $65.00
This lemon blueberry cheesecake is creamy and bursting with lemon flavors and fresh blueberries. It's made with a simple Graham Cracker crust, a lemon cheesecake base filling with juicy blueberries floating through the thick, rich, creamy, lemony batter, and a delicious simple homemade blueberry sauce to top this irresistible dessert.
Pumpkin Cheesecake $65.00
This smooth and creamy pumpkin cheesecake features a buttery Biscoff crust and swirls of whipped cream cheese frosting.

Baby Shower
White Baby Shower Mini Cupcake Box $30.00
This beautiful white baby shower mini cupcake box comes with a white vanilla frosting.
Blue Baby Shower Mini Cupcake Box $30.00
This beautiful blue baby shower mini cupcake box comes with a blue vanilla frosting.
Pink Baby Shower Mini Cupcake Box $30.00
This beautiful pink baby shower mini cupcake box comes with a pink vanilla frosting.
Baby Shower Custom Cookies $65.00
Basic Design $48.00 | Deluxe Design $54.00 | Elaborate Design $60.00

Cookie Cakes
Gluten Free Cookie Cake $50.00
Chocolate Chip or Peanut Butter.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake $35.00
10 inches $75.00 | 12 inches $95.00 | 14 inches $55.00
Peanut Butter Cookie Cake $35.00
10 inches $75.00 | 12 inches $95.00 | 14 inches $115.00

Smallcakes of Fort Myers Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Drive-through
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Smallcakes of Fort Myers Photos

Smallcakes of Fort Myers Location

Smallcakes of Fort Myers

Florida Lee County Fort Myers South Cleveland Avenue

11150 S Cleveland Ave #140, Fort Myers, FL 33907, USA

Smallcakes of Fort Myers Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 763 user reviews.

wedding cakedeliverypicturebaby showercreativealmondpeanut butter cupgraduationcustomsurprise

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Exceptional cake and experience!!! We ordered a gluten free wedding cake for one of our children. It was the birch bark w carved initials cake pictured on the SmallCakes website, with a lemon cake and strawberry buttercream filling. It was absolutely delicious and everyone loved it!! Allison, who helped me order from over 2000 miles away, was very helpful and thoughtful. She responded instantaneously to my notes and the cake was ready for pickup on time. Perfect! Highly, highly recommended.
July 21 · TK
Don't sleep on trying Smallcakes of Fort Myers!! Their flavors are spot on. It will take a couple of days to try these, but today's cupcake picks are Lemon Blueberry, Pink Chocolate, Hot Fudge Sunday & Salted Caramel. My daughter picked the Almond Crossaint Cheesecake. She also got a French Silk parfait.This weekend picks. Wedding Cake, Pink Vanilla, and Chocolate Covered Strawberry. Chocolate Covered Strawberry went to my dad. I tried a small piece of the other two. So good!I've been following the Smallcakes of Fort Myers Facebook page for a couple of weeks now. I believe in supporting small businesses, even if it's just sharing posts. I was scrolling a couple of days and came across one of their posts, with the cupcake specials of the day. My daughter and I love Italian rainbow cookies. They had a rainbow cookie cupcake as a special of the day. We decided to finally stop by the shop and take home a few different types. I'm going to have to say these are probably some of the best cupcakes that we have ever had.*The Italian Rainbow Cake is 3 layers of almond sponge cake, filled with raspberry jam, topped with chocolate ganache, Italian rainbow cookie, and sprinkles.*The Cannoli is a vanilla bean cupcake with chocolate chips, topped with cream cheese buttercream, chocolate, and a cannoli.*The Chocolate Cream is a chocolate cake filled with buttercream topped with fudge frosting and buttercream. *The Lemon Drop is a lemon cake filled with lemon curd, topped with lemon buttercream and lemon curd.If I could give them more stars for their rating, I would in a heartbeat!!
September 04 · Kelly Peluso
We Ordered a carrot cake for my son’s 18th Birthday. We googled where to get it from because we are from NY. It was definitely risky not knowing how it would be but with the great reviews we figured we would just order it. We were pleasantly surprised! It was amazing! The quality and the taste were exceptional. I would tell anyone get a cake from Small cakes!! We will definitely be using them again when we come back to Florida.
November 18 · Cortney Crisafulli
thank you very much for this wonderful cake! the guys completed the order in 24 hours, while I received many refusals from other confectioners. the cake turned out to be very tasty, in fact it was a little sweet for me, but a cake is a cake 😅 these are the most delicious cakes that I have ever tried. I will definitely come back
October 23 · Dasha Nezhelskaya
I ordered a beautiful custom cake and 30 cupcakes of different varieties with this business for my babyshower. Not only was the owner extremely helpful but so was her staff. Very friendly as well. The cake and the cupcakes were very very delicious and everyone at the party asked where I placed my order. I will definitely be coming back to smallcakes. The presentation was above expectation as well. Thank you Tonyia and the staff. It was great working you.
July 25 · Daynes Morales Clark