Smith Street Bagels: A Local's Guide to Brooklyn's Beloved Bagel Shop

Smith Street Bagels Introduce

For many New Yorkers, the hunt for the perfect bagel is a lifelong quest. The ideal bagel is a delicate balance: a crisp, crackly exterior that gives way to a soft, chewy, and satisfyingly dense interior. It’s a sensory experience that’s a quintessential part of life in the city. In the heart of Brooklyn, located on the vibrant and bustling Smith Street, you'll find a place that has been a long-time favorite for locals seeking this very experience: Smith Street Bagels. This neighborhood gem has earned its reputation by consistently delivering on the promise of a freshly made, authentic New York bagel, alongside a menu that offers something for everyone, from classic cream cheese spreads to innovative sandwiches and fresh-pressed juices.

Smith Street Bagels is more than just a place to grab a quick bite. It's an integral part of the Cobble Hill and Boerum Hill community. For over a decade, it has served as a morning ritual for many, a go-to spot for a weekend brunch, and a reliable provider of delicious, comforting food. The shop’s commitment to quality is evident in its process: hand-rolling and kettle-boiling each bagel before it’s baked to perfection. This traditional method is what gives their bagels their distinctive texture and flavor, setting them apart from the mass-produced alternatives. Whether you’re a long-time resident or just passing through, a visit to Smith Street Bagels offers a genuine taste of Brooklyn.

The atmosphere inside is often described as modern yet inviting, with a bustling energy that is typical of a busy, successful New York eatery. Customers praise the staff for being friendly and efficient, even during the busiest hours of the day. Reviews from customers mention the welcoming staff, quick service, and a pleasant overall dining experience. It's a place where you can feel at home, whether you're grabbing a bagel to go or taking a moment to sit and enjoy your meal. The commitment to providing a welcoming environment is a key part of what makes Smith Street Bagels a local favorite and a place that fosters a strong sense of community.

The shop’s menu goes far beyond the basic bagel with cream cheese. They offer a diverse range of options that cater to various tastes and dietary needs, including a wide array of vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices. This inclusivity is part of the reason for its broad appeal. Customers can choose from a vast selection of classic bagel flavors, as well as unique, seasonal offerings. The cream cheese spreads are a highlight, with house-made, whipped spreads that come in both traditional flavors and more creative, gourmet concoctions. This dedication to variety and quality ensures that every visit to Smith Street Bagels is a new and exciting culinary adventure.

While the in-store experience is a major draw, Smith Street Bagels also excels at providing convenient service options for those on the go. Their robust delivery system has been praised by customers for its efficiency, particularly after improvements were made to streamline the process. The shop has a separate entrance for delivery drivers, which helps to maintain the flow of foot traffic and ensures that in-store customers and delivery orders are handled with equal attention. This forward-thinking approach to service demonstrates their commitment to meeting the needs of a modern, fast-paced urban community.

The quality of their food is a recurring theme in customer feedback. A new visitor to NYC mentioned that the jalapeno cheddar seasonal bagel was "flavourful and tasted very well" and was "not heavy or chewy," which is high praise for any bagel shop. Another customer noted the "nice crunch" of their toasted bagel and the "good size" of the sandwich, which they were able to split with someone and still feel satisfied. This consistent quality, combined with a welcoming atmosphere and a wide variety of menu items, solidifies Smith Street Bagels' reputation as a top-tier bagel destination in Brooklyn.

Whether you’re in the mood for a simple breakfast, a hearty lunch, or a catering order for a special event, Smith Street Bagels has you covered. Their extensive menu, combined with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients and a friendly staff, makes them a standout in a city full of bagel shops. It’s a place that understands the importance of a good bagel and the role it plays in the daily lives of its patrons. For anyone in the New York area looking for an authentic and delicious bagel experience, Smith Street Bagels is an excellent choice.

No matter what your bagel preference may be—from a simple plain bagel with a schmear of classic cream cheese to a fully loaded lox sandwich—you're likely to find something to love at this beloved Brooklyn spot. The dedication to their craft, combined with a genuine appreciation for their customers, has cemented their place as a cherished local institution.

The article is currently at 790 words.

Location and Accessibility

Smith Street Bagels is conveniently located at 202 Smith St in Brooklyn, New York. This prime location places it right in the heart of the bustling Cobble Hill and Boerum Hill neighborhoods, making it a central point for residents and visitors alike. The area is well-served by public transportation, with several subway stations and bus routes within walking distance, making it easily accessible from various parts of Brooklyn and Manhattan. For those who prefer to drive, street parking can be available, though it is often limited. The shop itself is easily identifiable and sits on a lively street known for its local businesses, boutiques, and eateries. It's a perfect stop for a quick bite before heading to the nearby attractions or simply as part of your daily routine. The location also makes it a great spot for an impromptu meeting or a casual brunch with friends.

Services Offered

Hand-Rolled Bagels: The cornerstone of their business, all bagels are hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and baked in-house daily.
Extensive Menu: A wide range of options including breakfast sandwiches, omelettes, deli sandwiches, paninis, wraps, and salads.
Gourmet Cream Cheeses: An impressive selection of house-made cream cheese spreads, including unique and seasonal flavors.
Vegan and Gluten-Free Options: A dedicated menu with clearly labeled vegan and gluten-free choices, including vegan cream cheese and bagel options.
Fresh Beverages: A full espresso bar, fresh-pressed juices made in-house daily, smoothies, and Counter Culture coffee.
Catering: Bagel and sandwich platters are available for catering, with a minimum order requirement.
Online Ordering and Delivery: Convenient services for pickup and delivery are offered through their website and various third-party platforms.

Features / Highlights

Community Focus: The shop is known for its friendly, welcoming staff and a strong connection to the local community.
Quality Ingredients: A focus on using fresh, high-quality ingredients, including organic eggs for their breakfast items.
Spacious Seating: Both indoor and outdoor seating are available, making it a great place to sit down and enjoy a meal.
Fast and Efficient Service: Customers frequently praise the speed of service, which is particularly important during peak hours.
Diverse Menu: The menu's variety ensures that there is a delicious option for everyone, whether they're a traditionalist or looking for something new.

Contact Information

Address: 202 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Phone: (929) 556-2624

Conclusion: Why This Place is Suitable for Locals

Smith Street Bagels is an ideal spot for anyone living or working in the Brooklyn area. Its prime location in a bustling neighborhood, combined with its reputation for delicious, fresh, and high-quality food, makes it a reliable destination for any meal of the day. The shop's commitment to traditional bagel-making methods ensures that you're getting a true New York experience, while its extensive and modern menu caters to the diverse tastes of a cosmopolitan city. The friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere make it more than just a place to eat; it's a community hub. Whether you need a quick coffee on your way to work, a leisurely brunch on the weekend, or a catering order for a gathering, Smith Street Bagels delivers. It is a true local institution that embodies the spirit of Brooklyn.

Smith Street Bagels Food & drink

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Hand Rolled Bagels
Hand Rolled Bagel With Cream Cheese US$5.95
Fresh hand rolled bagel with house made whipped cream cheese
Hand Rolled Bagel With Vegan Cream Cheese US$6.95
Fresh hand rolled bagel with house made whipped vegan cream cheese
Hand Rolled Bagel With Butter Or Jelly Spreads US$4.00
Fresh hand rolled bagel with specialty butter spreads and/or jelly
Hand Rolled Bagel With Chicken, Egg, Tuna Salad US$8.00
Fresh hand rolled bagel with house made salad spreads
Hand Rolled Bagel With Hand Nova Sliced Lox US$13.95
Fresh hand rolled bagel with house made cream cheese and hand sliced Nova Lox
Hand Rolled Dry Uncut Bagels US$2.00
Fresh hand rolled bagel dry, uncut, not toasted

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Hand Rolled Mini Bagels
Hand Rolled Mini Bagels With Cream Cheese US$3.75
Fresh hand rolled mini bagel
Hand Rolled Mini Bagel With Vegan Cream Cheese US$4.25
Fresh hand rolled mini bagel with house made whipped vegan cream cheese
Hand Rolled Mini Bagel With Butter Or Jelly Spreads US$3.00
Fresh hand rolled mini bagel with specialty butter spreads and/or jelly

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Smith Street Lox Corner
Mocha Special US$14.95
Nova lox, plain cream cheese, tomato, onion and capers.
Lox And Cream Cheese US$13.95
hand sliced lox with your choice of cream cheese add what you like to get it your way
Hot Lox US$15.95
Nova lox, jalapeno cheddar cream cheese, tomato and onion.
New Smith US$16.95
Plain cream cheese, lox, tomato, and avocado.
Healthy Fit US$15.95
Nova lox, hummus, onions, tomato and cucumber.
Brooklyn Lover US$16.95
Nova lox, cucumber dill cream cheese, avocado, onion, tomato and lemon juice.
Whitefish Salad Classic US$11.95
Whitefish salad, tomato, red onion and cucumber.
Baked Salmon US$11.95
Baked salmon salad, tomato, onion and cucumber.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - All Organic Egg Bar & Breakfast
B1. Organic Egg Whites, Avocado And Scallion Cream Cheese US$10.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B2. 2 Organic Eggs, Chorizo, Jack Cheese, Onion And Jalapeno US$10.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B3. Organic Eggs, Hot Pastrami, Scallion Cream Cheese And Red Onion US$10.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B4. 2 Organic Eggs, Sirloin Steak, American Cheese, And Caramelized Onion US$11.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B5. Organic Egg White, Pepper, Sausage, Onion And Spinach US$11.95
Organic Egg white, mixed peppers, chicken sausage, caramelized onions and spinach. Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B6. Lox, Organic Eggs, And Caramelized Onion US$12.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B7. Organic Eggs, Beef Bacon, Chorizo, Cheese, And Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese US$12.95
Beef bacon, chorizo, cheddar cheese, and jalapeno cheddar cream cheese. Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B8. Organic Pesto Eggs, Roasted Red Peppers And Fresh Mozzarella Cheese US$10.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
B9. 2 Organic Eggs, Bacon, Red Onion, Tomato And Chipotle Cream Cheese US$10.95
Comes with choice of bagel. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
2 Organic Eggs On A Bagel US$5.95
Made with all organic cage free eggs
2 Organic Eggs With Cheese On Bagel US$6.95
Made with all organic cage free eggs
2 Organic Eggs, Cheese And Meat US$7.95
Choice of American or Swiss cheese, and bacon, ham, or sausage. Made with all organic cage free eggs
French Toast US$9.95
with Butter and Syrup
Classic Pancake (Order Of 3) US$10.95
Served With butter and Maple syrup.
Homemade Steel Cut Oatmeal US$5.00
Homemade Steel Cut Oatmeal Comes with choice of Honey & Brown Sugar (optional)

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Breakfast Omelettes
Organic Classic Western Omelette Breakfast US$11.95
Ham, pepper and onion. Comes with 3 Organic eggs served with redskin home fries, mini bagel and choice of cream cheese. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
Organic Garden Omelette Breakfast US$11.95
Pepper, onion, mushroom, tomato and spinach. Comes with 3 Organic eggs served with redskin home fries, mini bagel and choice of cream cheese. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
Organic Florentina Omelette Breakfast US$11.95
Tomato, spinach, and fresh mozzarella. Comes with 3 Organic eggs served with redskin home fries, mini bagel and choice of cream cheese. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
Four Cheese Organic Omelette US$11.95
A good blend of Swiss, cheddar, fresh mozzarella and Asiago cheese. Comes with 3 Organic eggs served with redskin home fries, mini bagel and choice of cream cheese. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
The Avocado Omelette Breakfast US$11.95
Avocado and mixed pepper. Comes with 3 Organic eggs served with redskin home fries, mini bagel and choice of cream cheese. Made with all organic cage free eggs.
A-L-E-O Omelette Breakfast US$12.95
Avocado, lox, Organic egg, and caramelized onions. Comes with 3 Organic eggs served with redskin home fries, mini bagel and choice of cream cheese. Made with all organic cage free eggs.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Bagels and Rolls
Hand-Rolled Bagel US$2.00
Assorted hand-rolled bagels including classic, whole wheat, gluten-free, and seasonal options like pumpkin.
Roll US$1.80
Plain roll, typically enjoyed without spreads or butter. For additional options, please refer to our spreads and salad sandwiches section.
Bialy US$3.00
Soft, baked cousin of the bagel, typically includes onion, poppy seeds, and olive oil.
Gluten-Free Bagel US$3.00
Naturally gluten-free bagel made with a blend of tapioca starch, brown rice flour, potato starch, and sorghum flour.
6 Bagels + 1 Free US$12.00
Six bagels with one free. Choose from an extensive variety, including plain, sesame seed, everything, cinnamon raisin, pumpernickel, blueberry, and seasonal options like pumpkin. Gluten-free available.
12 Bagels + 2 Free US$24.00
12 bagels + 2 free. Choose from plain, sesame, everything, poppy seed, cinnamon raisin, multi-grain, whole wheat, onion, salt, garlic, pumpernickel, egg, flat (flagel), blueberry, french toast, rainbow, pumpkin (seasonal), gluten-free options.
Flagel (Flat Bagel) US$2.25
Hand rolled, kettle boiled, fresh baked daily

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Bagel packages
Bagel Packlage 1 US$19.20
6 bagels, 1/2 lb plain cream cheese, 1/4 lb butter or jelly + 1 free bagel
Bagel Package 2 US$35.20
1 dz bagels 1 lb plain cream cheese, 1/2 veggie or scallion and 2 free bagels
Bagel Package 3 US$33.20
6 bagels 1/2 pound plain cream cheese 1/4 sliced nova lox, side of onions, tomato, capers and 1 free bagel
Bagel Package 4 US$57.20
1 dz bagels 1 lb plain cream cheese 1/2 lb sliced nova lox, sides of tomato, onion, capers and lemon slices and 2 free bagels

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Cream Cheese by the pound
Plain Cream Cheese US$3.25
Plain cream cheese. Available by the pound in 1/4 LB, 1/2 LB, or 1 LB options.
Scallion Cream Cheese US$3.75
Creamy cheese with scallion bits. Available in 1/4 LB, 1/2 LB, or 1 LB sizes.
Veggie Cream Cheese US$3.75
Available in 1/4, 1/2, or 1 LB portions.
Lox Spread Cream Cheese US$4.00
Smoked salmon-infused cream cheese. Available by the pound: 1/4 LB, 1/2 LB, 1 LB.
Lox & Scallion Cream Cheese US$4.00
Lox scallion spread.
Guacamole Cream Cheese US$3.75
Guacamole-flavored cream cheese. Available in 1/4 LB, 1/2 LB, or 1 LB.
Chipotle Cream Cheese US$3.75
Chipotle.
Pimento Olive Spread US$3.75
Olive spread.
Strawberry Cream Cheese US$3.74
Strawberry spread.
Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese US$3.74
Walnut raisin spread.
Jalapeño Cheddar Cream Cheese US$3.74
Jalapeño cheddar spread.
Bacon Cheddar & Scallion Cream Cheese US$3.74
Bacon cheddar scallion spread.
Garlic & Herb US$3.74
Garlic and herb spread.
Apple Spice Cream Cheese US$3.74
Apple spice spread.
Veggie Tofu (Non-Dairy) US$3.50
Veggie Tofu (non-dairy) Tofu spread with mixed vegetables. Available in 1/4 LB, 1/2 LB, or 1 LB packs.
Scallion Tofu (Non-Dairy) US$3.50
Plain Tofu (Non-Dairy) US$3.50
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese US$3.74
Sun dried tomato spread.
Roasted Mushroom & Truffle Cream Cheese US$3.75
House whipped cream cheese with roasted mushrooms, garlic, and black truffle
Blueberry Cream Cheese US$3.75
House whipped cream cheese with farm fresh blueberries, and blueberry preserves
ALL VEGAN Cashew Cream Cheese US$4.25
House made VEGAN Cashew Cream Cheese

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Smoked fish by the pound
Nova Scotia Lox US$10.95
Hand sliced nova
Pastrami Lox US$11.95
Cold smoked lox with pastrami spices

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Salad Spreads by the Pound
Mexican Tuna Salad Spread US$3.50
tuna hot peppers red onion cilantro
Italian Tuna Spread US$3.50
tuna onion parsley mayo
Buffalo Chicken Salad US$3.50
Abf Buffalo Chicken Salad, Carrots, celery, blue cheese crumble
Cranberry Apple Chicken Salad Spread US$3.50
chicken apple cranberry walnuts mayo
Baked Salmon Salad Spread US$3.75
baked salmon with spices and mayo
White Fish Salad US$3.75
whole white fish deboned and spiced with mayo

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Espresso Bar
Single Espresso US$3.00
Single shot of espresso, typically featuring a rich, robust flavor extracted from finely ground coffee beans.
Double Espresso US$4.00
Rich, bold double shot espresso, perfectly concentrated for a robust coffee experience.
The Red Eye Hot US$2.95
Espresso with your choice of size: 10 oz., 16 oz., or 20 oz.
The Red Eye Iced US$4.45
Espresso with a dash of cold brew. Available in 16 oz. or 20 oz. sizes.
Cappuccino US$3.95
Hot.
Mochaccino US$4.25
Espresso with rich chocolate. Choose between 16 oz. or 20 oz.
Hot Latte US$3.95
Rich espresso with steamed milk. Sizes: 10 oz., 16 oz., 20 oz.
Iced Latte US$4.95
Iced latte. Available in 16 oz. or 20 oz. sizes.
Hot Cafe Americano US$3.25
Classic espresso diluted with hot water. Choose size: 10 oz., 16 oz., or 20 oz.
Cold Cafe Americano US$3.95
Chilled espresso with water. Choice of 16 oz. or 20 oz.
Hot Chocolate US$3.50
100% milk.
Hot Chai Latte US$3.95
Warming chai tea blend. Available sizes: 10 oz., 16 oz., 20 oz.
Iced Chai Latte US$4.95
Chai tea served over ice. Available in 16 oz. or 20 oz.
House Blend Coffee US$3.00
House blend coffee. Choose between Small or Large.
House Made Cold Brew US$4.00

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Fresh Pressed Juice & Smoothie Bar
Tropical Kale US$8.99
Kale, spinach, coconut water, pineapple + banana
Almond Delight US$8.99
Banana, almond butter, almond, chocolate whey protein, chocolate almond milk
PBJ US$8.99
Banana, coconut, sugar, peanut butter, coffee, chocolate almond milk
Elvis Shake US$8.99
Peanut butter, banana + soy milk
Fiber Fixer US$8.99
Blueberries, banana, soy milk + flax seed
Skinny Berry US$8.99
Raspberries, blueberries, skim milk + low fat yogurt
Açaí US$8.99
Blueberries , bananas + soy milk
Perk Me Up US$8.99
Peanut butter, banana, almond milk + shot of espresso
Green Summer US$8.99
Pineapple, mango, fiber fixer, orange juice + kale
Go Go Mango US$8.99
Strawberries, orange juice, soy milk + protein
Green Juice US$8.99
Kale, Spinach , lime, celery, cucumber, parsley+ green apple
Immune Booster US$8.99
Orange, apple, kale, carrot + ginger
Fat Burner US$8.99
Ginger, carrot, orange + cayenne pepper
Morning Energizer US$8.99
Beets, pineapple, carrot, apple , celery+ ginseng
Hangover Helper US$8.99
Apple, pineapple + orange juice
Tropical Rush US$8.99
Grapefruit, lemon, lime + orange juice
SSB US$8.99
Carrot, beets, ginger + green apples
Smooth Special US$8.99
Carrot, grapefruit, beet, pineapple, orange juice + lime
Zaggy US$8.99
Kale, green apple, pineapple, lemon, shot of wheatgrass
Really Juice US$8.99
Kale, spinach, grapefruit, pineapple + green apple
Fresh Wheat Grass Shot US$5.00
Fresh wheat grass shot: Wheatgrass juice, typically includes lemon or ginger for added zest.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Daily Made In House Fresh Juices
16 Oz. Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice US$6.99
Made daily fresh
16 Oz. Green Juice US$6.99
Made daily fresh
16 Oz. Carrot Juice US$6.99
Made fresh daily
16 Oz. Red Juice US$6.99
Made fresh daily
16oz. Fresh Strawberry Lemonade US$5.99
Made Fresh Daily
16 Oz. Fresh Blueberry Lemonade US$6.99
Made Fresh Daily
16 Oz. Fresh Mint Lemonade US$5.99
Made Fresh Daily
16oz Fresh Watermelon Juice US$5.99
Juiced Daily In house
16 Oz Fresh Cantaloupe Juice US$5.99
Freshly squeezed daily

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Counter Culture Coffee
Big Trouble US$16.00
Big Trouble Coffee: Nutty, caramel, and chocolate flavors typically found in this drip coffee blend.
Forty Six US$16.00
Forty Six Counter Culture Coffee: Typically includes chocolate, nutty, and berry notes, creating a balanced and smooth flavor profile.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Cold Cuts On A Bagel & Deli Sandwiches
Roast Beef On A Bagel US$7.95
Sandwich with thinly sliced beef that has been cooked over a dry heat.
Fresh Turkey On A Bagel US$7.95
Poultry sandwich. Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Pastrami On A Bagel US$7.95
Smoked and cured pastrami sandwich.
Honey Turkey On A Bagel US$7.95
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Pepper Turkey On A Bagel US$7.95
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
Salsalito Turkey On A Bagel US$7.95
Boiled and baked round bread roll.
BLT US$6.99
Bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Grilled Cheese US$4.50
Hot sandwich filled with cheese that has been pan cooked or grilled.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Smashed Avocado Toast
The Moroccan US$9.95
Hummus spread, smashed avocado, crumbled feta cheese, diced tomato, lemon juice, salt, and red pepper flakes.
Mini Tex US$9.95
Smashed avocado, pico de gallo, and shredded cheddar.
Portobello Avo US$10.95
Smashed avocado, portobello mushroom, sundried tomato spread and arugula.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Gluten Free Bagel Sandwiches
The Green US$8.95
Pesto, avocado and tomato. Gluten free.
The Red US$8.95
Onion, avocado and cucumber. Gluten free.
The Orange US$8.95
Tomato, onion, and capers. Gluten free.
IC US$8.95
Avocado, cucumber and spinach. Gluten free.
IQ US$8.95
Artichoke heart, tofu spread, olives, and tomato. Gluten free.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Bagel Chips
Truffle Everything Bagel Chips US$3.00
House Made Everything Bagel Chips Drizzled with truffle oil. Try it with a Small (1/4#) Cream Cheese For Dipping!
Garlic Parmesan Bagel Chips US$3.00
House Made Bagel Chips toasted with Garlic, Parmesan, and Herbs. Try it with a small (1/4#) Cream Cheese for Dipping!
Cinnamon Sugar Bagel Chips US$2.50
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel Chips, Toasted with Cinnamon & Brown Sugar! Try it with a a small (1/4#) Cream Cheese For Dipping! (apple cinnamon recommended)
Rainbow Bagel Bites US$4.00
The Donut Holes of the Bagel World! Try With a small (1/4#) Cream Cheese or Honey Butter!

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Catering Options
Foot Long Heroes! US$24.99
Foot long heroes available! 3, 4, 5, or 6 foot. Italian or Americana. $24.99 per foot. Comes complete with salads and paper goods.
Box Of Joe US$26.99
box of smith street famous coffee blend for 10-12 ppl
Fruit Bowl US$25.00
seasonal selection of fruit chopped daily for
Smith Street Sandwich Platter US$65.00
your choice of meats and cheese made on fresh bagels slice bread or rolls comes with lettuce tomato dressing on the side choice of meats roast beef roast turkey honey turkey ham beef salami pastrami choice of cheese American Swiss cheddar provolone muenster dressing on the side includes water or can soda
Cold Cut Platter US$65.00
your choice of meats and cheese comes with lettuce tomato dressing on the side choice of meats roast beef roast turkey honey turkey ham beef salami pastrami choice of cheese American Swiss cheddar provolone muenster dressing on the side includes water or can soda Bagels slice bread and or rolls on the side
Dessert Platter US$20.00
Sweet selection of cup cakes cinnamon buns apple turnover cherry turnover Blondies pound cakes presented on platters
Muffin And Danish Platter US$16.00
Wide selection of baked fresh daily muffins and danish sliced and arranged on a platter
Cookie Platter US$15.00
Baked fresh daily chocolate chip M&M black and whites tri color sliced and platter
The Smith Cream Cheese Platter US$30.00
Your choice of 3 cream cheese served on a platter of lettuce tomato and cucumber with a selection of bagels

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Baked In House Hero Sandwiches
1. Brooklyn Green US$10.00
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella cheese, baked roma tomato, broccoli rabe, and homemade pesto sauce. Comes with homemade side coleslaw and pickle.
2. Healthy Choice US$10.00
Grilled chicken, roasted red pepper, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and our housemade honey mustard. Comes with homemade side coleslaw and pickle.
3. Chicken Philly US$10.00
Grilled chicken, caramelized onions, mixed peppers and cheddar cheese. Comes with homemade side coleslaw and pickle.
4. Italiano Chicken US$10.00
Grilled pesto chicken, roasted red peppers, arugula and fresh mozzarella cheese. Comes with homemade side coleslaw and pickle.
5. Crispy Chicken US$10.00
Panko crust chicken cutlet, arugula, baked tomato and pesto mayo sauce.
6. Texmex US$10.00
Panko crust chicken cutlet, guacamole, bacon, cheddar cheese, and chipotle mayo.
8. The Mediterranean Chicken US$10.00
Grilled chicken, hummus spread, grilled vegetables, fresh mozzarella cheese with our popular homemade balsamic vinaigrette.
9. Chicken Parm Hero US$10.00
Breaded chicken, tomato sauce, and cheese sandwich.
The Original Philly US$11.00
Grilled peppers, onion and melted American cheese. Our homemade signature sirloin steak hero comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
French Philly US$11.00
Grilled mushroom and Swiss cheese. Our homemade signature sirloin steak hero comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
Italian Philly US$11.00
Melted fresh mozzarella and tomato sauce. Our homemade signature sirloin steak hero comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
Mexican Philly US$11.00
Melted jack cheese, avocado, tomato, jalapeno, and chipotle mayo. Our homemade signature sirloin steak hero comes with homemade side coleslaw and pickle.
BBQ Bacon Philly US$11.00
Smoked BBQ bacon, cheddar cheese and sauteed onion. Our homemade signature sirloin steak hero comes with homemade side salad and pickle.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Smith Street Wraps & Quesadillas
Chicken Caesar Wrap US$7.95
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, tomato and Caesar dressing. Comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
Cubano Wrap US$9.95
Grilled chicken, avocado, black beans, lettuce and tomato. Comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
California Wrap US$10.95
House made roast turkey, lettuce, tomato, avocado, bacon and honey mustard. Comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
Portobello Wrap US$8.95
Grilled marinated portobello mushroom, roasted red peppers, provolone cheese, mix green and balsamic vinaigrette. Comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
Tuna Salad Wrap US$8.95
Tuna salad, bacon, romaine lettuce and tomato. Comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
Philly Cheese Steak Wrap US$8.95
Sirloin steak, American cheese, grilled onions, pepper, mushroom and mayo. Comes with homemade side salad and pickle.
New York Turkey Wrap US$7.95
Honey turkey, lettuce, tomato, Swiss and honey mustard.
Veggie Wrap US$5.95
Eggplant, mushroom, onion, pepper, spinach, tomato, carrots and ranch.
Spring Wrap US$6.99
Sauteed baby spinach, eggs, grilled turkey breast, and imported smoked Gouda cheese
New East Coast Wrap US$6.99
Grilled sauteed tomatoes w eggs and mixed greens. imported Asiago cheese. (overstuffed)
New Yorker US$7.99
2 eggs, grilled tomatoes, imported melted Swiss cheese and home made hummus.
Classic Quesadillas US$10.00
Mix jack and cheddar cheese, caramelized onions, and mix pepper. Comes with sour cream and salsa.
Chicken Quesadilla US$11.00
Comes with sour cream and salsa.
Steak Quesadilla US$11.00
Comes with sour cream and salsa.
Shrimp Quesadilla US$11.00
Comes with sour cream and salsa.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Paninis
The Italiano Panini US$9.95
Grilled Pesto Chicken Breast, Roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese, and pesto sauce.
Tuna Melt Panini US$9.95
Albacore Tuna salad, lettuce, Wisconsin cheddar cheese Lettuce, and tomatoes.
Russian Panini US$9.95
Roast beef, Muenster cheese, caramelized onion, Fresh tomatoes, green lettuce, and Russian dressing.
Cuban Panini US$9.95
Smoked Turkey ham, Fresh turkey breast, Swiss cheese, pickles, and Mustard.
Capri Panini US$9.95
Smoked fresh turkey, beef pepperoni, Provolone cheese, Fresh tomatoes, Fresh spinach, hot peppers, and Balsamic vinaigrette.
Chicken Parmigiana Panini US$9.95
Panko crust chicken cutlets, melted fresh mozzarella Cheese, Parmigiana cheese, Marinara sauce, and fresh basil.
Eggplant Parmigiana Panini US$9.95
Panko crust baked eggplant, Marinara sauce, Melted fresh mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil.
Chicken Club Panini US$9.95
Grilled chicken breast, Turkey bacon, avocado, fresh tomatoes, and Herbal mayo.
The Meatless Panini US$8.95
Fresh mozzarella, Fresh tomatoes, Fresh spinach, and Sun-dried tomatoes spread. Comes With A Sliced Pickle & Side Of Salad.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Salad Bar
Create Your Own Salad US$9.00
Create your own salad with choices of greens like Romaine, mixed greens, spinach, or arugula. Main ingredients include grilled, spicy, or fried chicken. Add premium toppings like cheeses, nuts, eggs, or turkey bacon.
Lemon Chickpea Salad US$6.99
Chickpea salad with lemon accents, cucumber, onion and cilantro
Cucumber Dill Salad US$6.99
Sliced cucumber with dill dressed in lemon juice and pepper
Beet Salad US$6.99
Roasted Beets drizzled with Olive Oil

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Beverages
20 Oz. Bottled Soda US$2.25
20 oz. bottled soda - Various flavors including Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sunkist, Mountain Dew, Coke, Ginger Ale, Cherry Coke, Dr. Pepper, and diet options.
Tropicana Carton 14 Oz. US$3.25
14 oz carton of Tropicana juice. Options include pulp preferences, fruit blends, and added calcium.
Tropicana 12 Oz. Bottle US$3.00
12 oz. bottle of Tropicana juice. Choose from Calcium, Cranberry, Apple, or Grapefruit flavors.
Tropicana 32 Oz. US$4.49
32 oz. Tropicana juice. Choice of Grapefruit, Apple, or Cranberry.
Tropicana 59 Oz. US$6.49
Tropicana juice: 100% pure juice, typically includes orange, apple, cranberry, or grape.
Gatorade US$2.50
20 oz.
Snapple 16 Oz. US$2.50
16 oz. Snapple juice. Choose from Lemon Iced Tea, Peach, Raspberry, Apple, or Fruit Punch.
Boylan`S Soda US$3.00
Choice of Root Beer, Black Cherry, or Cream Soda.
Naked US$4.50
Naked juice: Typically includes blends of fruits like strawberry, banana, and apple. Please specify your preferred flavor.
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice US$6.99
16 oz. Bottle
Honest Organic Tea US$3.50
Honest® organic brings you premium organic teas, lemonade, juices, kids drinks and yerba mate tea.
Harney And Son Organic Tea US$3.50
Choice of organic tea flavors: Orange Mango, Peach, Green, or Black.
Scenery Organic Kombucha US$5.00
Kombucha with a variety of flavors including Gingerberry, Multi Greens, Trilogy, Lemonade, and Gingered.
Pam Antioxidant Drink US$4.50
Pomegranate-based juices, choose from Sweet Tea, Honey Green Tea, or Blueberry flavors.
Starbucks Coffee Drinks US$3.50
A selection of brewed beverages typically made from roasted coffee beans, often enjoyed with milk and sweeteners.
Red Bull US$2.50
Energy drinks. Sizes: 8 oz., 12 oz., 16 oz.
Vitamin Water US$2.50
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Poland Spring Water US$1.25
Hydrating Poland Spring water. Available in Small (16.9 oz), Sports Cap (23.7 oz), Medium (33.8 oz), or Large (50.7 oz).
Fiji Water US$3.00
Pure, natural artesian water. Available in 500 mL or 1.5 Liter.
Smart Water US$2.50
Every drop tastes pure and will leave you feeling refreshed.
Nesquick US$3.25
Choice of Nesquick flavor: Chocolate or Strawberry milk.
Tropicana 15 Oz. Bottle US$2.00
15 oz. bottle of Tropicana juice; flavors: cranberry, ruby red, apple, orange.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup US$5.99
Served with bagel of your choice.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Daily Baked In House Pastries
French Croissant US$3.75
Flaky and buttery, this classic French croissant is baked fresh daily in-house. Typically includes flour, butter, water, milk, sugar, yeast, salt, barley malt powder, egg, and heavy cream.
French Chocolate Croissant US$4.25
A buttery, flaky croissant typically filled with rich dark chocolate, baked fresh daily.
French Almond Croissant US$4.25
Croissant filled with almond cream, topped with toasted almonds, and lightly dusted with powdered sugar.
Apple Turnover US$3.75
Crisp, flaky pastry filled with warm, spiced apples.
Black & White Cookie US$1.75
Black & white cookie. Choose between Mini or Mighty size.
Fresh Baked Muffins US$4.00
Freshly baked muffins: Our daily selection typically includes flavors like blueberry, chocolate chip, and banana nut.
Fresh Baked Cookies US$3.50
Freshly baked cookies typically include varieties such as chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, peanut butter, or oatmeal raisin.
Old Fashioned Crumb Cake US$3.50
Moist vanilla cake topped with a thick crumb streusel, typically includes a hint of cinnamon and powdered sugar.
Fresh Sliced Pound Cake US$3.50
Lemon or Marble
Cheese Danish US$3.50
Delicate, Flaky Pastry Filled with Rich, Creamy Cheese
Raisin Danish US$4.00
David’s M&M Cookie US$3.50
House-made cookie typically loaded with colorful M&M candies.
David’s Chocolate Chunk Cookie US$3.50
A freshly baked cookie typically includes flour, brown sugar, butter, sugar, eggs, salt, baking soda, baking powder, vanilla extract, and generous chocolate chunks.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Dessert
Fruit Cup US$5.95
Fresh mixed fruit served in a cup- a perfect burst of natural flavors
Rice Pudding US$4.00
Creamy, sweet pudding made with tender rice, and other spice
Chocolate Pudding US$4.00
Decadent Chocolate Pudding: Rich, smooth, and blissfully indulgent.
Yogurt Parfait US$5.00
Layered yogurt parfait with fresh fruits and granola.

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Pizza Bagel
Classic US$5.95
Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, and tomato sauce
Mushroom US$6.95
House-Made Portobello, fresh mozzarella, and Mixed Peppers
Chicken Pesto US$7.95
Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, broccoli, and pesto
Spicy Hawaiian US$7.95
Chorizo , Pineapple, roasted Red peppers , and tomato sauce
Pepperoni US$7.95
Tomato sauce , shredded Mozzarella, and Pepperoni

Smith Street Bagels (Baltic St) [POS]-allday - Vegan Pizza Bagel
Margherita US$7.95
Tomato sauce , vegan mozzarella, basil leaves
Ultimate Veggie US$7.95
Red onion , bell pepper , mushroom, olive , tomato sauce
Tomato Bagel US$7.95
Sicilian Style tomato and Almond Parmesan
Vegan Cheese Bagel US$7.95
Tomato sauce and Vegan Cheese
Old School US$7.95
Garlic oil, vegan cheese , caramelized onions, broccoli, and cherry tomatoes

Smith Street Bagels Details

Service options
Kerbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Paid street parking

Smith Street Bagels Photos

Smith Street Bagels Location

Smith Street Bagels

New York Kings County Carroll Gardens Smith Street

202 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Smith Street Bagels Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 921 user reviews.

deliveryorderveganspreadgluten free bagelstruffleguacamoledairypizza bagelmocha

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

First time bagel experience in NYC! Jalapeño cheddar seasonal bagel was flavourful and tasted very well. Not heavy or chewy. Also tried tuna cream cheese which was good! Bagel pizza so much simulated Chicago’s deep dish pizza which I’m not a great fan of. Would go back to Smiths in the future.
March 23 · Srijan Valasapalli
Decent experience overall. Paid about ~$20 for a Truffle Shuffle lox bagel. Felt pricey, but it was a good size – I was able to split it with someone and not feel hungry. The bagel itself was solid, but I wished the truffle cream cheese had a lot more flavor. Definitely get the bagel toasted. It had a nice crunch
March 17 · Michelle
I purchased French toast. I got 3 slices of French toast, no fruit or anything else. Just French toast. The French toast is dry! Need butter! Not the tastiest! It cost me $9 plus tax. Not worth it! The lady at the counter was nice. However, I was given 1 syrup packet. I had to ask for another. I could have went to my local bodega, which I will do next time and purchased French toast with a protein for $8. Stick with the bagels! Overpriced!
March 06 · Lo “Lo” Brow
My first time having New York bagels and I can now say I understand the hype! Crisp outside and soft doughy inside with generous servings of cream cheese. The bar has been set! The fresh pressed juice was also delicious.
April 11 · Monica C.
I've been a customer here several times - as a vegan I have enjoyed that they offer many vegan options. I've always opted for a bagel sandwich and been very happy with the food. This past Saturday I was going to the movies nearby, and popped in because I wanted a bagel - just a bagel, nothing fancy.The sign board with all the menu items under Bagels listed a "BAGEL & FLAVORED VEGAN CREAM CHEESE" with the price of $5.50. I ordered a wheat bagel, toasted extra dark, with scallion vegan cream cheese. Side note, there are only plain and scallion vegan cream cheeses in the case.I was charged $4.95 for a bagel with cream cheese, AND AN EXTRA $1.75 for scallion tofu cream cheese. With tax and tip the total was $8.30 WHAT??!! I didn't even notice the prices until after I had paid.When I explained and questioned nicely that the menu item lists the bagel as $5.50 the cashier said she would check....and came back twice to say she was right. I repeated to her that it wasn't right, that the menu says differently. No one behind the counter would offer help or explanation or agree that THE PRICE ON THE MENU WAS WRONG, or that the Cashier had rung it up incorrectly. It wasn't even so busy that staff couldn't help.On top of all that, the bagel was barely toasted (I asked for extra toasted) and the cream cheese was too much - there was enough to cover three bagels at least. It was inedible.I was thoroughly discouraged and found this to be unacceptable staff behavior, improper preparation of the item I ordered, and unfortunately Smith Street Bagels will have lost a repeat customer.
April 14 · Andrea Suarez