South Shore Bagels: A Wantagh Favorite for Authentic Bagels and Friendly Service

South Shore Bagels Introduce

In the heart of Long Island, a great bagel isn't just a food item; it's a way of life. The search for a "real" bagel, with a crusty exterior and a soft, chewy interior, is a quest that many New Yorkers take seriously. For the residents of Wantagh and the surrounding South Shore communities, that quest often ends at South Shore Bagels. This local bagel shop has built a reputation not only on the quality of its namesake product but also on its unwavering commitment to excellent service and community involvement. It’s a place that feels like home, where every customer is treated with kindness and where the bagels are a testament to the time-honored craft that makes New York bagels famous.

South Shore Bagels stands out in a crowded market because it delivers on the promise of an authentic bagel. As one customer aptly put it, they "don’t sell soft rolls with holes in the center and pass them off as bagels." The bagels here are the real deal, crafted with a perfect balance of a crusty exterior and a dense, fluffy interior. This texture is the result of a traditional process that involves kettle-boiling the dough before it is baked, a crucial step that many establishments skip. The dedication to this classic method ensures that every bagel that comes out of the oven is as fresh and delicious as it should be. The aroma alone is enough to draw you in, and the first bite confirms that you've found a true local gem.

Beyond the bagels, South Shore Bagels has cultivated a reputation for its genuinely friendly and quick service. In a fast-paced environment, the staff manages to be both efficient and personable, making every visit a pleasant experience. Customers consistently praise the kindness of the workers, highlighting how a positive attitude can elevate a simple morning coffee and bagel run into a cherished daily ritual. This commitment to customer happiness extends to a willingness to go the extra mile, as evidenced by a review where the shop provided day-old bagels for a volunteer service project without hesitation. This kind of community-minded approach, where a business sees itself as a neighbor rather than just a vendor, is what truly sets South Shore Bagels apart and makes it a beloved local institution.

The menu at South Shore Bagels is extensive, offering far more than just bagels with cream cheese. It’s a full-service deli that caters to a wide range of tastes and meal times. While the bagels are the star, their menu of breakfast and lunch options is equally impressive. They serve up a variety of breakfast sandwiches on their freshly baked bagels, rolls, or heroes, featuring classic combinations like eggs with meat and cheese, as well as hearty omelettes. For lunch, the options are plentiful and include a full Boar’s Head deli counter, allowing customers to create their own custom sandwiches. They also offer a variety of signature sandwiches, wraps, salads, and hot sandwiches, all made with fresh, quality ingredients. This diversity makes South Shore Bagels a destination for any meal of the day, not just breakfast.

South Shore Bagels is also a key partner in community life through its catering services. Whether for a small family gathering, an office breakfast meeting, or a large event, the shop offers bulk deals on bagels and catering platters that make planning an event simple and delicious. The fact that they offer day-old bagels for community projects speaks volumes about their willingness to support local initiatives and be a positive force in Wantagh. Their catering menus feature a wide array of options, from bagel platters and fresh spreads to sandwich and wrap trays, ensuring that they can provide the perfect food for any occasion. This community-focused business model has earned them a loyal following that appreciates both their great food and their neighborly spirit.

The physical location of South Shore Bagels also adds to its appeal. Situated on Merrick Road, it's a convenient stop for locals and commuters alike. The shop's easy parking is a major bonus, especially during busy hours, making the experience of grabbing a quick bite stress-free. The combination of a welcoming atmosphere, efficient service, and high-quality food makes it a go-to spot for many in the area. In a world where customer service can often be a secondary thought, South Shore Bagels prioritizes it, creating an environment where people genuinely feel happy to be there. This is a core part of its identity and a major reason why it has become such a staple in the Wantagh community.

Ultimately, South Shore Bagels is a prime example of a local business that gets it right. They honor the tradition of the New York bagel while also providing a modern, diverse menu that meets the needs of their customers. Their exceptional customer service and genuine desire to be a positive force in the community have cemented their place in the hearts of locals. For anyone on the South Shore of Long Island, whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, this is a destination that delivers on quality, taste, and a warm, welcoming experience every single time.

Location and Accessibility

South Shore Bagels is conveniently located at 3451 Merrick Rd, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA. The shop is easily accessible by car, situated on a major road that makes it a visible and convenient stop. Customers appreciate the ample parking available, which makes quick pickups or leisurely meals equally simple.

Services Offered

Freshly Baked Bagels: A wide variety of authentic, hand-rolled, and kettle-boiled bagels baked fresh daily.
Breakfast & Lunch Deli: A full deli serving breakfast sandwiches, a variety of lunch sandwiches, wraps, and salads, all made with quality Boar's Head cold cuts and other fresh ingredients.
Homemade Spreads: An array of homemade cream cheeses and other spreads to complement their bagels.
Catering: Comprehensive catering services for events, meetings, and parties, featuring bagel platters, sandwiches, wraps, and more.
Coffee & Beverages: A selection of hot coffee, iced coffee, and other beverages to round out any meal.

Features / Highlights

Authentic Bagels: Known for a traditional bagel-making process that results in a perfectly crusty-on-the-outside and soft-on-the-inside texture, the hallmark of a true New York bagel.
Exceptional Customer Service: The staff is consistently praised for being kind, friendly, and efficient, creating a welcoming atmosphere for every customer.
Community-Minded: The shop actively supports the local community, as shown by its willingness to donate day-old bagels for service projects and other local initiatives.
Diverse Menu: Beyond bagels, the extensive menu of breakfast and lunch options, including deli items and catering, makes it a versatile choice for any meal.
Convenient Location: Easy to find on Merrick Road with plenty of parking, making it a stress-free destination for a quick stop or a longer visit.

Contact Information

Address: 3451 Merrick Rd, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

Phone: (516) 804-9626

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For the people of Wantagh, South Shore Bagels is more than just a business; it's a trusted community partner. It’s a place that provides the comfort and familiarity of a classic New York bagel while also offering a diverse menu that meets all of their dining needs. The combination of an authentic product, a friendly and efficient staff, and a deep commitment to the local community makes it a standout establishment. Whether you need a quick, delicious breakfast, a hearty lunch, or catering for a large event, South Shore Bagels delivers with consistent quality and a personal touch. Its presence on Merrick Road has made it an integral part of daily life, and its reputation for kindness and great food ensures that it will remain a local favorite for years to come.

South Shore Bagels Food & drink

From the Bakery
Crumb Cake US$4.25
Plain crumb cake.
Brownies US$4.25
With walnuts.
Apple Turnover US$4.25
Large Assorted Cookies US$4.25
Black white, rainbow sprinkle, chocolate sprinkle, or chocolate chip.
Assorted Muffins US$4.25
Choose from Corn, Blueberry, Banana Nut, Chocolate Chip, Double Chocolate, Red Velvet, Pistachio, Cranberry, Raisin, Carrot, Apple or Cappuccino.

Beverages
Vita Coco 11.1 Oz US$2.99
Sunkist 20 Oz US$3.49
Nesquik Chocolate US$4.39
Celsius Peach Mango Green Tea US$3.99
Hal's Black Cherry US$2.99
Celsius Strawberry Lemonade US$3.99
Starbucks Doubleshot Espresso 6.5 Oz US$4.49
Made with the signature espresso coffee.
Naked Strawberry Banana 15.2 Oz US$4.99
Essentia Water 20 Oz US$2.75
Snapple Diet Peach Tea US$3.49
Sprite 20 Oz US$3.49
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Nesquik Double Chocolate US$4.39
C4 Energy Starburst US$3.99
Canada Dry 20 Oz US$3.49
Nesquik Strawberry Banana US$4.39
Yoohoo US$3.99
Snapple Peach Tea US$3.49
Hal's Original US$2.99
Hal's Lemon US$2.99
Snapple Diet Lemon Tea US$3.49
Hal's Lime US$2.99
Hershey's Creamy Chocolate Flavored Milk Shake 12 Oz US$3.49
Snapple Diet Raspberry Tea US$3.49
Gatorade Lemon Lime US$3.49
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Essentia Water 1 L US$3.99
Tropicana Orange Juice 12 Oz US$3.25
A juice drink made with a blend of summer’s most delicious fruit juices, with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.
Snapple Raspberry Tea US$3.49
Redbull 8.4 Oz US$3.99
Hal's Blackberry US$2.99
Snapple Lemon Tea US$3.49
Starbucks Doubleshot Energy Vanilla 15 Oz US$4.99
Made with the signature espresso coffee.
Starbucks Doubleshot Energy Mocha 15 Oz US$4.99
Made with the signature espresso coffee.
Celsius Peach Vibe US$3.99
Vitamin Water Revive US$3.25
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Tropicana Apple Juice 12 Oz US$3.25
A juice drink made with a blend of summer’s most delicious fruit juices, with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.
Naked Green Machine 15.2 Oz US$4.99
Celsius Watermelon US$3.99
Vitamin Water Power C US$3.25
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Hal's Watermelon US$2.99
Celsius Artic Vibe US$3.99
Celsius Orange US$3.99
Hal's Ginger Ale US$2.99
Redbull Zero Sugar 8.4 Oz US$3.99
Vitamin Water Essential US$3.25
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Nesquik Strawberry US$4.39
Starbucks Doubleshot Energy Coffee 15 Oz US$4.99
Made with the signature espresso coffee.
Diet Coke 20 Oz US$3.49
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Celsius Wild Berry US$3.99
Pepsi 20 Oz US$3.49
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Monster Energy Drink US$3.99
Gatorade Cool Blue US$3.49
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Naked Blue Machine 15.2 Oz US$4.99
Nesquik Vanilla US$4.39
Martinelli's Gold Medal Apple Juice 10 Oz US$4.49
Tropicana Cranberry Juice 12 Oz US$3.25
A juice drink made with a blend of summer’s most delicious fruit juices, with no artificial sweeteners or flavors.
Coke 20 Oz US$3.49
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Vitamin Water XXX US$3.25
Vitamin and nutrient-enhanced water beverage with electrolytes and other good stuff.
Naked Mighty Mango 15.2 Oz US$4.99
Gatorade Fruit Punch US$3.49
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Gatorade Orange US$3.49
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Diet Pepsi 20 Oz US$3.49
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.

Homemade Salads
Lite Tuna Salad US$14.75
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Craisins Chicken Salad US$15.49
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with Hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Lite Veggie Tuna Salad US$14.75
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Chicken Salad US$14.49
On your choice of bagel or roll. Made with hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw.
Shrimp Salad US$15.99
Whitefish Salad US$15.99
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Seafood Salad US$15.99
Tuna Salad US$13.99
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with Hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Veggie Tuna Salad US$14.75
Vegetarian. Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with Hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Lite Chicken Salad US$14.75
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.
Egg Salad US$12.99
Your choice of bagel or roll. Made with Hellman's mayonnaise. Served with a choice of 1/4 lb.

Breakfast Mains
French Toast US$13.49
2 slices of French toast bread with powdered sugar.
Pancakes US$13.49
3 pancakes.
Grand Slam US$15.99
2 pancakes, or 2 French toast, 2 eggs, 2 bacon, 2 ham, and, sausage.

Wraps
The All American Wrap US$14.49
Fried chicken cutlet, melted American, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and, Russian dressing. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Caesar Wrap US$14.49
Grilled chicken Caesar dressing, romaine lettuce, and, Parmesan cheese. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Godfather Wrap US$14.49
Genoa salami, cappi ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, , and, Italian dressing. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Bootlegger Wrap US$14.49
Roast beef, melted Cheddar, lettuce, and, tomato. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Gobbler Wrap US$14.49
Oven gold turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato, and, onion. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Frisco Wrap US$14.49
Salsalito turkey, melted Pepper Jack cheese, bacon, romaine lettuce, and, blue cheese dressing. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Classic Wrap US$14.49
Chicken salad BLT. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Little Italy Wrap US$14.49
Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, red roasted peppers, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, and, balsamic vinaigrette. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Wild Bill Wrap US$14.49
Buffalo chicken, melted Monterey Jack cheese, lettuce, and, blue cheese dressing. Served with 1/4 lb potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.

Confectionery
5 Gum Spearmint US$2.99
Hershey's Milk Chocolate US$1.99
Trident Peppermint US$2.25
Hershey's Milk Chocolate W/ Almonds US$1.99
Raffaello 3Ct US$2.99
Trident Spearmint US$2.25
KitKat US$1.99
Starburst US$1.99
Crunch US$1.99
Skittles US$1.99
Twix US$1.99
Peanut Chews (Original Dark) US$1.99
Ferrero Rocher US$2.99
Trident Bubblegum US$2.25
Altoids Minis Peppermint US$2.99
Altoids Arctic US$4.25
Kinder Bueno US$2.99
M&M's Peanut US$1.99
5 Gum Wintermint US$2.99
Reese's Peanut Butter Cup US$1.99
5 Gum Peppermint US$2.99
Snickers US$1.99
Altoids Peppermint US$4.25

Cream Cheese & Spreads by the Lb
Spreads By The Pound US$13.99

Paninis
The Harbor Panini US$14.49
Roast beef, oven gold turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and, mustard. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
25A Melt Panini US$14.49
Grilled chicken, melted mozzarella, red roasted peppers, and, balsamic vinaigrette. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Monte Cristo Panini US$14.49
Honey maple turkey, Virginia ham, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and, honey mustard. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Tiger Panini US$14.49
Breaded chicken cutlet, muenster cheese, bacon, romaine lettuce, and, mayonnaise. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, Macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Chicken Fajita Panini US$14.49
Grilled chicken, Cheddar cheese, roasted red peppers, onions, and, salsa. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Veggie Delight Panini US$14.49
Vegetarian. Fresh mozzarella, red roasted peppers, artichoke hearts, and, pesto sauce. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
The Alpine Panini US$14.49
Corned beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and, Russian dressing. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Mama Mia Panini US$14.49
Breaded eggplant with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and, balsamic vinaigrette. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Italian Night Club Panini US$14.49
Genoa salami, cappi ham, pepperoni, mozzarella, romaine lettuce, , and, balsamic vinaigrette. Served on European flatbread with 1/4 lb, potato, macaroni, or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.

Chopped Salad Bar
Make Your Salad Anyway US$11.99

Omelettes
Vegetable Omelette US$14.49
Vegetarian. Tomatoes, mushrooms, peppers, and, onions. Includes our choice of bagel or toast.
Spanish Omelette US$14.49
Onions, peppers, tomatoes, and, cheese. Includes your choice of bagel or toast.
Cheese Omelette US$12.99
Includes your choice of bagel or toast.
Western Omelette US$14.49
Ham, peppers, onions, and, cheese. Includes your choice of bagel or toast.

Salads to Go
Tossed Salad US$10.49
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, and, carrots.
Caesar Salad US$10.49
Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese garlic, herb, and, croutons, with Caesar dressing.
Chefs Salad US$12.99
Romaine lettuce with ham, turkey, roast beef, American, and, Swiss cheese, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, and, cucumbers.
Greek Salad US$10.49
Romaine lettuce, tomatoes, red peppers, and, cucumbers, black olives, and, feta cheese with Greek dressings.

Bagels, Bialys, and, Rolls
Roll US$1.99
A Dozen Bagels US$23.99
Bagel US$2.39
Flat US$2.99
Bialy US$2.50
½ Dozen Bagels US$12.49
Twist US$2.99

Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup US$6.49
Mouthwatering Homemade Fresh Chicken Noodle Soup
Oatmeal US$4.99

Make a Boar's Head Sandwich
Make A Sandwich - Flat US$10.50
All sandwich come with your choice of 1/4 lb of potato, macaroni or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Make A Sandwich - Hero US$11.99
All sandwich come with your choice of 1/4 lb of potato, macaroni or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Make A Sandwich - Bialy US$10.50
All sandwich come with your choice of 1/4 lb of potato, macaroni or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.
Make A Sandwich - Roll US$10.50
All sandwich come with your choice of 1/4 lb of potato, macaroni or coleslaw, and, a slice of pickle.

Home Made Beverages
Herbal Tea US$3.25
Coffee US$3.25
Hot Tea US$3.25
Iced Coffee US$3.75
Pink Lemonade US$3.75
Hot Chocolate US$3.25
Iced Tea US$3.75
Decaf Coffee US$3.25
Flavored Coffee US$3.49
French Vanilla US$3.25
Cappuccino US$3.25

Breakfast Sandwich Specials
2 Eggs - Flat US$8.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
2 Eggs - Bagel US$8.99
Served with 10 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
3 Eggs, Potato - Bagel US$11.25
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
1 Egg - Roll US$7.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
2 Eggs - Roll US$8.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
2 Egg - Hero US$9.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
2 Eggs On A Wrap US$9.99
Hungry Man (Hero) 3 Eggs, 3 Bacon, 2 Ham, Sausage, , And, Cheese US$14.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz Orange Juice. Choose your cheese and egg.
3 Eggs, Potato - Flat US$11.25
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
1 Egg - Flat US$7.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
3 Eggs, Potato - Bialy US$11.25
1 Egg - Bialy US$7.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
2 Eggs - Bialy US$8.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
3 Eggs, Potato - Hero US$12.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
1 Egg - Bagel US$7.99
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.
3 Eggs, Potato On A Hero - Roll US$11.25
Served with 12 oz. coffee, tea, H/C, or 6 oz orange juice.

Hot Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese Sandwich US$8.65
Choice of bagel or bread.
BLT Sandwich US$10.65
Choice of bagel, roll, or bread.
Grilled Cheese And Bacon Sandwich US$10.65
Choice of bagel or bread.
Tuna Melt Sandwich US$11.99
Choice of bagel or roll.
Fried Chicken Cutlet Sandwich US$14.65
Your choice of bagel or roll.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$14.65
Your choice of bagel or roll.

South Shore Bagels Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

South Shore Bagels Photos

South Shore Bagels Location

South Shore Bagels

New York Nassau County Wantagh Merrick Road

3451 Merrick Rd, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA

South Shore Bagels Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 71 user reviews.

pricesegg sandwichescream cheesebaconiced coffeevegetableeverything bagelcostlunch

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Very kind workers, very good customer service. I asked for day-old bagels to give to volunteers for a service project, and they gave them to me without hesitation. South Shore Bagels has very good deals to buy bagels in bulk and I would recommend South Shore Bagels to anyone across Long Island.
June 13 · Bobby Daniel
I consider myself somewhat of a bagel maven. I know good bagels. And this place has them. They don’t sell soft rolls with holes in the center and pass them off as bagels; they have the real thing. Kind of crusty on the outside and soft on the inside. Not the best, but very good. And the slight bit they may lack in taste is more than made up for by their excellent, friendly, quick service. The gentleman who took care of me acted as if he was happy to be there, which in turn made me happy to be there. Lots of easy parking. I shall return.
February 22 · PhilYouIn
Yeah this place was fantastic. Went here for lunch after having done ceramics for my son’s birthday. The bagels themselves were really good, but the bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches were loaded and tasted excellent. I say this as a self proclaimed bagel connoisseur, I have these bagel sandwiches multiple times a week usually, and these were about as good as I’ve had, really.
January 06 · JJ Anderson
The bagels and bialys are very good. Egg sandwich excellent. Really pleasant service and fair prices.
July 04 · D L
Just stopped off here on my way to work. I pass Seaford bagel on my way in but wasn't crazy about their bagels. I decided to stop off here instead and omg what a difference the bagels I had a egg everything with scallion cream cheese it was outstanding and the staff is very friendly and polite. This is my go to place on my way in to work when I'm in the mood for a great bagel.
January 11 · Pete Pull