Stellina Bakery & Cafe

stellina bakery oyster bay

Hello, New Yorkers! Are you in search of a bright, inviting spot where you can savor delicious pastries, enjoy a fresh coffee, or even order a stunning custom cake for your next celebration? Look no further than Stellina Bakery & Cafe in Syosset, NY. This charming establishment, an extension of the renowned Stellina Ristorante, brings a touch of exquisite Italian culinary tradition to Long Island, offering a delightful blend of baked goods, savory bites, and a welcoming cafe atmosphere. From your morning croissant to a meticulously crafted birthday cake, Stellina Bakery & Cafe aims to be your go-to destination for quality and taste. This article will provide a detailed overview of what makes Stellina Bakery & Cafe a cherished local spot, covering its convenient location, extensive menu, notable features, and why it’s perfectly suited for the diverse needs of the Syosset community and beyond.

Stellina Bakery & Cafe is conveniently located at 14 Cold Spring Rd, Syosset, NY 11791, USA. This address places it in a highly accessible area of Syosset, a vibrant and desirable community in Nassau County, Long Island. Cold Spring Road is a well-known local thoroughfare, ensuring excellent visibility and straightforward access for residents of Syosset and neighboring towns. For those traveling by car, there is typically parking available in the vicinity, which is a key convenience for a popular cafe and bakery. While specific public transportation routes would depend on local Nassau Inter-County Express (NICE) bus schedules, Syosset is also served by the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), making it a viable destination for those coming from other parts of Long Island or even New York City for a dedicated visit. The cafe’s bright and airy interior, coupled with its location in a welcoming community, creates an inviting ambiance that encourages both quick visits and leisurely enjoyment. Its strategic position makes it an ideal spot for locals looking for a convenient place for breakfast, lunch, or a sweet treat.

• Artisanal Baked Goods: A wide selection of freshly baked pastries, including various croissants (butter, chocolate, almond, hazelnut, raspberry, apricot, sweet cheese & blueberry), muffins, cinnamon rolls, Danishes, and Italian specialties like Bomboloni and Sfogliatelle.
• Custom Cakes: Specializing in magnificent cake masterpieces for all occasions. Options include Strawberry Shortcake, NY Cheesecake, Raspberry Dacquoise, various Mousse Cakes (Cappuccino Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Mango Chocolate, Raspberry Chocolate, Triple Chocolate), Oreo Cake, Red Velvet Cake, Carrot Cake, and Cannoli Cake, all available for custom order.
• Mini Treats and Desserts: Perfect for when you're not too hungry but want to try something out, including mini cheesecakes, Napoleons, Lobster Tails, Tiramisu Parfaits, and Strawberry Shortcake Parfaits.
• Cookies and Biscotti: An assortment of cookies like chocolate chip, sprinkle, assorted S-cookies, sesame cookies, trecce, Almond Biscotti, Anisette Biscotti, Coconut Macaroons, Elephant Ears (palmiers), Hamentaschen, Oatmeal Raisin Cookies, Pignoli Cookies, and Rainbow Cookies.
• Full Coffee Bar: Offering a range of hot and iced coffees, lattes, cappuccinos, americanos, and espressos, with various milk options (almond, oat, skim, whole, half & half).
• Breakfast & Savory Items: Beyond pastries, they serve breakfast sandwiches (on English muffin, bagel, ciabatta roll, or croissant with choice of eggs, cheese, and meat), American Style Breakfast platters, Avocado Toast, and various omelets. They also feature Breakfast Pizza.
• Paninis and Sandwiches: A selection of expertly crafted paninis and sandwiches, as an extension of their Ristorante offerings.
• Gelato: A delightful selection of authentic Italian gelato, available in scoops, cones, or pints.
• Catering Services: Likely offers catering for events, given their range of products and connection to Stellina Hospitality.

• Exceptional Custom Cakes: Customers are "blown away" by the custom cakes, describing them as "better than I expected" and "amazing" at a "reasonable price," highlighting the bakery's skill in creating memorable centerpieces.
• Bright, Airy, and Charming Atmosphere: The interior is frequently praised for being "nice, hip," "bright and airy," and "well thought-of," creating a pleasant and inviting environment for customers to relax and enjoy their treats.
• Diverse Italian-Inspired Menu: As an extension of Stellina Ristorante, the cafe offers not only an extensive range of traditional Italian baked goods and pastries but also savory items like paninis and a robust breakfast menu, providing a comprehensive culinary experience.
• Mini Treats for Tasting: The availability of "mini treats" is a thoughtful feature, allowing customers to sample different items without committing to a full-sized portion, perfect for those with varied cravings.
• Attentive and Helpful Young Staff: Customers have noted the staff as "attentive and helpful," indicating a commitment to good service, which enhances the overall customer experience.
• Authentic Italian Products: Stellina Bakery & Cafe strives to bring "the most authentic Italian products that Long Island has to offer," ensuring a genuine taste of Italy.
• All-Day Dining: Serving breakfast, lunch, and desserts, it functions as an all-day cafe, catering to different dining needs throughout the day.

Address: 14 Cold Spring Rd, Syosset, NY 11791, USA

Phone: (516) 496-2489

For residents of Syosset and the broader Long Island community, Stellina Bakery & Cafe stands out as an exceptionally suitable and appealing local establishment. Its convenient location on Cold Spring Road ensures excellent accessibility, making it an easy stop for daily commuters, families, or anyone seeking a delightful culinary experience. This ease of access is a significant advantage in the busy pace of New York life, allowing locals to enjoy high-quality food and beverages without significant travel.

The core strength of Stellina Bakery & Cafe lies in its unique blend of authentic Italian bakery traditions and a comprehensive cafe menu. From exquisite custom cakes that leave customers "blown away" to a wide array of freshly baked Italian pastries and a full coffee bar, it caters to every sweet craving. Beyond the baked goods, the inclusion of savory breakfast items, paninis, and even gelato broadens its appeal, making it a versatile destination for any meal of the day. This diversity ensures that whether you're looking for a quick morning bite, a relaxed lunch, or a show-stopping cake for a special occasion, Stellina has something to offer.

Furthermore, the inviting atmosphere—described as "bright and airy" with "well thought-of interiors"—creates a pleasant environment for patrons. The attentive and helpful staff contribute to a positive customer experience, making visits enjoyable and encouraging repeat business. While some minor issues, like staff munching, were noted, the overall sentiment points to a charming and welcoming space. As an extension of Stellina Ristorante and founded by experienced culinary professionals, Stellina Bakery & Cafe brings a legacy of quality and authentic Italian culture to the Syosset neighborhood. For locals who appreciate artisan baked goods, delicious Italian-inspired fare, and a comfortable cafe setting, Stellina Bakery & Cafe is undoubtedly a top choice and a valued asset to the community.

Stellina Bakery & Cafe

14 Cold Spring Rd, Syosset, NY 11791, USA