Sunnyside Pastries

For residents of Pennsylvania, especially those living in or visiting the rich cultural landscape of Lancaster County, the allure of authentic, homemade baked goods is undeniable. Nestled in this region is Sunnyside Pastries, a cherished Amish-owned and operated bakery that has been delighting customers since 1993. This establishment is more than just a place to satisfy a sweet craving; it represents a tradition of quality, simplicity, and genuine craftsmanship that defines the best of Pennsylvania Dutch Country. From classic glazed donuts to traditional pies, nearly everything at Sunnyside Pastries is made from scratch, promising a taste of true local heritage with every bite. While some experiences may vary, the core appeal lies in their commitment to fresh, comforting treats. As one enthusiastic customer shared, "Love this place. Some of the best donuts I've had," highlighting favorites like the glazed ring and chocolate cake donuts. This article aims to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Sunnyside Pastries, detailing its location, the variety of products it offers, and what truly makes it a suitable and enduring choice for locals in Pennsylvania.

Location and accessibility are important considerations for any local business in Pennsylvania, and Sunnyside Pastries is uniquely situated to serve its community. You'll find their primary retail store next to their bake shop at 421 Weaverland Valley Rd, East Earl, PA 17519, USA. This location places the bakery in the scenic and tranquil heart of Lancaster County, an area known for its rural charm and strong Amish communities.

For those traveling by car, Weaverland Valley Road is a country road, and while it might require a bit of navigation for those unfamiliar with the area, it is generally accessible. Parking at their retail store is typically ample, allowing for a convenient and unhurried visit. What significantly enhances Sunnyside Pastries' accessibility to a broader audience across Pennsylvania is its strong presence at local farmers markets. They operate multiple stands at the renowned Green Dragon Market in Ephrata, PA, every Friday. As one customer noted, "This review is for one of the stands at the Green Dragon market in Ephrata." They are also found at the Leesport Farmers Market. This dual approach – a dedicated retail shop and popular market stalls – ensures that more Pennsylvanians can access their freshly baked goods, even if they're just passing through or visiting the markets. The experience of finding them at a vibrant market, or driving through the picturesque countryside to their East Earl location, adds to the authentic local charm that many residents appreciate.

Sunnyside Pastries offers a wide array of baked goods, nearly all of which are made from scratch, upholding the tradition of Amish baking. Their menu emphasizes classic, comforting treats that are popular favorites in the region.

• Donuts: A significant highlight and frequently praised item. They offer a variety of fresh donuts, with popular choices including glazed ring, sugar ring, and glazed chocolate cake donuts. Donut holes, especially chocolate ones, are also available, though they "sell fast."
• Pies: Sunnyside Pastries bakes a full line of homemade pies. These include traditional varieties such as Apple Pie, Cherry, Blueberry, Peach (seasonal), Pecan, Raisin, Rhubarb, and Strawberry Rhubarb. They also offer classic Pennsylvania Dutch favorites like Shoofly Pie (including Chocolate Shoofly), Lemon Sponge Pie, Egg Custard, Pumpkin, and Coconut Custard pies. Pies are available in various sizes, including 8", 4", and 3" personal pies.
• Whoopie Pies: A quintessential Pennsylvania Dutch treat, their Whoopie Pies are available in classic flavors like Chocolate, as well as Peanut Butter Long Johns.
• Breads: They offer various freshly baked breads, with Raisin Cinnamon Bread being a notable mention.
• Sweet Treats and Pastries: Beyond donuts and pies, the bakery produces other mouth-watering treats and pastries, reflecting a genuine Lancaster County experience.
• Custom and Event Orders: While not explicitly detailed, given their range, they likely accommodate custom orders for events, making them a suitable choice for gatherings in the local area.
• Freshness Promise: The bakery emphasizes that items are "made fresh in store," and advises customers to store them properly in "an air tight container for the next day to keep them fresh."

Sunnyside Pastries boasts several key features and highlights that contribute to its enduring popularity and status as a beloved local bakery in Pennsylvania.

• Amish-Owned and Operated: Being an Amish family business operating since 1993, Sunnyside Pastries offers an authentic Lancaster County experience. This heritage often implies a commitment to traditional methods, scratch-made goods, and a focus on quality that resonates with many customers.
• Freshness and Scratch-Made Products: The bakery takes pride in offering a "full line of baked goods, nearly all of which are made from scratch" and are "made fresh in store." This dedication to freshness is a significant draw, ensuring a superior taste.
• Beloved Donut Selection: Their donuts receive high praise, with customers specifically mentioning favorites like the glazed ring, sugar ring, and glazed chocolate cake. The popularity of their donut holes, selling out quickly, further attests to their appeal.
• Diverse Pie Offerings: The extensive variety of homemade pies, including traditional Pennsylvania Dutch specialties like Shoofly and Custard pies, makes them a go-to for classic desserts.
• Farmers Market Presence: Operating multiple stands at the Green Dragon Market (and Leesport Farmers Market) significantly expands their reach, making their products accessible to a wider audience beyond their physical store. This market presence allows them to connect directly with a large local customer base every Friday.
• Community Feel: Customers often note the friendly atmosphere. While one review mentioned a "large dog" that is "friendly," it suggests a relaxed, home-like environment, common in local, family-run establishments.
• Long-Standing Reputation: Operating for over two decades, Sunnyside Pastries has built a reputation for consistent quality among its loyal customer base, making it a trusted name in the community.
• Authentic Lancaster County Experience: For visitors and locals alike, Sunnyside Pastries offers a genuine taste of the region's culinary traditions.

For inquiries, placing orders, or any other assistance, Sunnyside Pastries can be reached through the following contact information:

Address: 421 Weaverland Valley Rd, East Earl, PA 17519, USA

Phone: (717) 445-5350

Mobile Phone: +1 717-445-5350

Retail Store Hours (at 421 Weaverland Valley Rd, East Earl, PA 17519):

• Thursday: Typically open (specific hours should be confirmed by calling)
• Friday: Typically open (specific hours should be confirmed by calling)
• Saturday: Typically open (specific hours should be confirmed by calling)
• Sunday-Wednesday: Closed at this location

Green Dragon Market Hours (Ephrata, PA):

• Every Friday: Open (check Green Dragon Market hours for specifics, typically 7:00 AM - Close)

It is highly recommended to call ahead or check their official website/social media for the most current operating hours, especially if planning a visit.

Sunnyside Pastries is an exceptionally suitable choice for local Pennsylvanians, offering a truly authentic and cherished experience that resonates deeply with the values of the region. Its identity as an Amish-owned and operated bakery ensures a commitment to traditional, scratch-made baked goods that harken back to beloved recipes and methods. For residents in Lancaster County and beyond, this provides a genuine taste of local heritage and a reassuring sense of quality. The bakery's accessibility, both at its East Earl retail location and through its prominent presence at the popular Green Dragon Market, makes it convenient for a wide array of customers to access their desired treats. While isolated negative feedback, such as the review concerning a potential overcharge or moldy donut (which, based on the bakery's longevity, appears to be an anomaly), should always be noted, the overwhelming sentiment points to a beloved establishment. The enthusiastic praise for their donuts and the wide array of classic pies speak to a consistent ability to deliver delicious, comforting products. For Pennsylvanians seeking fresh, authentic, and truly local baked goods from a community-rooted establishment, Sunnyside Pastries stands as an indispensable and much-loved destination.

Sunnyside Pastries

421 Weaverland Valley Rd, East Earl, PA 17519, USA