Sweet Sweet Sues custom cakes

Are you searching for a show-stopping centerpiece for your next New York City area celebration? Look no further than Sweet Sweet Sues Custom Cakes, a family-owned and operated business that has been transforming flour and frosting into stunning edible art since 2007. Located right here in Staten Island, this is not your typical bakery; Sweet Sweet Sues specializes exclusively in custom-designed cakes and cupcakes, ensuring that every creation is a unique masterpiece tailored precisely to your vision. For over 15 years, Sue and her husband, Dom, have proudly served the New York Tristate area, earning a reputation for incredible attention to detail, moist and flavorful cakes, and personalized customer service that makes the entire ordering process a delight.

For New Yorkers planning a wedding, a milestone birthday, an anniversary, or any grand event, the dessert is a moment-maker. Sweet Sweet Sues understands this completely. Their mission is to create a cake that not only looks unbelievable but also tastes absolutely divine. Customer testimonials consistently highlight the exceptional quality of their cakes—moist, perfectly balanced in sweetness, and available in a wide array of gourmet flavors and fillings, like the highly praised white chocolate frosting with raspberry drizzle, or rich chocolate with chocolate ganache. The passion for baking, which began with Sue creating cakes for family and friends, has grown into a highly-regarded local New York business that truly loves a challenge. If you have an intricate design idea or a detailed picture, their cake designer, Dom, will patiently work with you, even sketching the cake to your specifications so you can visualize the final product.

Sweet Sweet Sues Custom Cakes has become a top-tier choice for residents throughout the five boroughs and beyond who demand both artistic excellence and delicious flavor. This dedication to quality and custom work has even earned them top honors, including a 1st Place Cake and 1st Place Wedding Cake award at the prestigious Taste of Staten Island. Whether you need a towering, multi-tiered wedding cake that guests will rave about for years, a sculpted creation that perfectly matches a theme, or simply a dozen perfectly baked cupcakes, Sweet Sweet Sues provides a specialized, luxury experience focused on making your special occasion unforgettable. Their commitment to only using the finest ingredients shines through in every bite, setting them apart from mass-produced options.

Location and Accessibility

Sweet Sweet Sues Custom Cakes is strategically located in Staten Island, making it a convenient option for many New York and New Jersey residents. The business operates out of its primary location at 140 Main Street, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA.

While the address is a fixed point of contact, it is crucial for local customers to note a key distinction: Sweet Sweet Sues is not a walk-in retail bakery; they are custom cake designers who operate strictly by appointment. This model ensures that their full focus remains on the specific design and quality of pre-ordered creations, rather than on daily retail sales.

The Staten Island location is central enough to efficiently serve a massive portion of the New York Tristate area. They proudly service:

• Staten Island
• Manhattan
• Brooklyn
• Bronx
• Queens
• Mid to Northern New Jersey
• Mid to Western Long Island

For New York users relying on public transport to reach the Staten Island location for consultations or pick-ups, it is advisable to use a modern mapping service to determine the most efficient bus routes to the area of 140 Main Street, as it is a localized neighborhood. Given the nature of transporting a custom cake—especially a large wedding or multi-tiered celebration cake—many New York clients choose to utilize the available delivery and setup service offered by Sweet Sweet Sues to ensure their edible art arrives safely and professionally installed at the event venue. For smaller cupcake orders, local Staten Island delivery or pickup by appointment is generally the preferred method.

Services Offered

Sweet Sweet Sues provides a focused range of services centered around creating fully customized desserts for special events.

• Custom Cake Design and Creation: Crafting unique, one-of-a-kind cakes for any occasion, from birthdays and baby showers to corporate events and retirement parties.
• Wedding Cake Specialization: Designing and executing breathtaking multi-tiered wedding cakes, including dedicated services for cake tastings, design consultations, and professional delivery and setup.
• Groom’s Cakes: Custom-themed cakes specifically designed for the groom's preferences.
• Free Design and Tasting Consultations: Available weekly by appointment to discuss concepts, flavors, and pricing with the resident designer, Dom.
• Cupcakes: Available for order by the dozen, including the creation of unique cupcake towers and cupcake bouquets/centerpieces.
• Specialty Dietary Options: Offering Vegan and Gluten-free options for cupcakes and other confections with a one-week notice.
• Delivery Service: Offering professional cake delivery and setup within Staten Island, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens, and parts of New Jersey and Long Island.
• Flexible Payment: Accepting all major credit cards for convenience.
• Takeout/Pickup: Available for pre-ordered items, strictly by appointment.

Features / Highlights

What sets Sweet Sweet Sues apart as a top choice for discerning New York customers? Their business model and operational highlights focus on excellence and personalization.

• Custom-Only Model: They are custom cake designers, not a typical walk-in retail bakery, ensuring every order is baked fresh and built to unique specifications.
• Family-Owned and Operated: Run by Sue and Dom since 2007, customers receive personalized service from the owners themselves, who are deeply invested in the success of every cake.
• Artistic Design Expertise: Dom, the designer, is an acknowledged artist who creates detailed sketches for clients to visualize their cake before production, allowing for perfect customization and confidence in the final product.
• Award-Winning Quality: Recipient of the Taste of Staten Island 1st Place Cake and Wedding Cake awards, a testament to their superior taste and design.
• Moist and Flavorful Cakes: Customers consistently praise the cakes for being exceptionally moist, not overly sweet, and featuring a wide array of delicious, balanced flavors and fillings.
• Intricate Detail: Renowned for incredible attention to detail, from sculpted elements made of gumpaste to edible paper for money designs, creating creations so realistic "everyone found it hard to believe that it was actually a cake."
• Wide Service Area: Successfully servicing the entire New York Tristate area, including delivery to Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens, and New Jersey.
• Appointment-Only Access: This structured approach ensures a high level of consultation and dedicated focus on each custom order.

Contact Information

For New York and Tristate area residents ready to begin the process of ordering a custom cake, consultation is the first step.

• Address: 140 Main St, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA
• Phone: (718) 966-2253 (also noted as 718-966-CAKE)
• Email: SweetSweetSues@yahoo.com
• Hours Note: The shop is currently only open by appointment. They are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.

What is Worth Choosing Sweet Sweet Sues

For New Yorkers accustomed to a high standard of quality and customization, Sweet Sweet Sues Custom Cakes offers a compelling value proposition that goes far beyond the average corner bakery. What truly makes them a premier choice is the seamless combination of artistic vision and culinary excellence. It's not just a cake; it's a personalized, handcrafted piece of edible architecture that tastes even better than it looks.

Consider the experience of one happy customer whose 5-tier wedding cake was handled by the team: "Dom patiently designed the cake and made recommendations... I thought his sketch was beautiful but seeing the actual cake took my breath away. Dom is an ARTIST!" They went on to rave about the cake's flavor, noting that unlike most wedding cakes, this one was not dry at all. The rave review concluded, "Truly one of the best cakes I have ever tasted." This sentiment underscores the business's dedication to quality control—using fine products and perfected recipes to deliver a moist, flavorful product every single time.

The customization process is a major draw. New York clients looking for intricate, thematic, or complex designs will find a partner in Dom, who has the ability to sculpt details and bring abstract ideas to life, such as lifelike busts of beloved family dogs or detailed sugar shoes. Whether you're planning a massive wedding in Manhattan or a themed birthday party in Queens, the family at Sweet Sweet Sues ensures a personal connection. They aim to make the planning process stress-free and exciting, providing a complimentary design consultation where your vision is the blueprint for their work.

In a busy, fast-paced city like New York, the ability to count on a reliable, professional, and talented team for one of the most important elements of your event is invaluable. Sweet Sweet Sues requires all custom orders to be pre-ordered and secures dates with a deposit, demonstrating a professional approach to scheduling and commitment that ensures your cake will be ready and perfect for your date. By choosing Sweet Sweet Sues, you are not just purchasing a dessert; you are commissioning a centerpiece from recognized local experts who are committed to delivering a product that will garner gasps of amazement and murmurs of delight from every guest. For the ultimate edible art experience in the New York Tristate area, Sweet Sweet Sues is the clear choice.

Sweet Sweet Sues custom cakes

140 Main St, Staten Island, NY 10307, USA