Sylvia's Sweet Cakes Introduce
### Discover Sylvia's Sweet Cakes: Your Destination for Delicious Treats in Selinsgrove, PA
Located within the bustling Susquehanna Valley Mall, **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** has become a noteworthy spot for residents of Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding Susquehanna Valley region seeking delightful baked goods. This local bakery aims to be a go-to for everything from an everyday sweet treat to a beautifully crafted custom cake for life's most special moments. For Pennsylvanians looking for quality, flavor, and a touch of indulgence, Sylvia's Sweet Cakes offers a range of options designed to satisfy even the most discerning sweet tooth. While experiences can vary, many customers have discovered truly exceptional items that keep them coming back for more.
**Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** has garnered attention for its impressive array of delicious creations, with some customers expressing sheer amazement at the quality. One enthusiastic review highlights their "fabulous" tres leches cake, irresistible cake pops, and cookies, along with a chocolate cupcake described as "hands-down the best cupcake I have ever eaten." Such glowing feedback points to a bakery capable of producing moist, flavorful cakes with absolutely "to die for" frosting. This article will provide an in-depth look at Sylvia's Sweet Cakes, covering its accessible location, the variety of services it offers, its standout features, and why it holds potential as a valuable local resource for baked goods in the Selinsgrove area.
---
### Location and Accessibility
**Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** is conveniently located at **1 Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr, Selinsgrove, PA 17870, USA**. This prime location within the **Susquehanna Valley Mall** makes it exceptionally accessible for residents of Selinsgrove and the broader Central Susquehanna Valley region. Being situated inside a well-known shopping mall means easy navigation and ample parking, which is a significant advantage for customers.
The **Susquehanna Valley Mall** serves as a central hub for shopping and entertainment in the area, drawing visitors from various communities, including Lewisburg, Sunbury, Mifflinburg, and Danville. For locals, this means that a stop at **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** can easily be combined with other errands or a planned shopping trip, enhancing convenience. The mall environment provides a comfortable and familiar setting for patrons to access the bakery. Whether you're making a quick stop for a treat or picking up a special order, the mall location ensures that reaching Sylvia's Sweet Cakes is straightforward and hassle-free, reinforcing its role as an accessible sweet spot for the community.
---
### Services Offered
**Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** offers a variety of baked goods, specializing in items that cater to both everyday cravings and special occasion needs. Based on customer reviews, their services and products include:
Custom Cakes: A primary service, allowing customers to order personalized cakes for events like graduations, birthdays, and other celebrations. Customers can provide specific design ideas and discuss details to create a unique cake.
Cupcakes: Highly praised for their moistness and flavorful frosting. Specialties include a notable chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting, and potentially other creative flavors that are regularly available.
Tres Leches Cake: A standout item that has received "fabulous" reviews, indicating a high-quality version of this popular Latin American dessert, known for its rich, milky texture.
Cake Pops: Described as "fabulous," these bite-sized cake creations offer a fun and convenient way to enjoy cake, often available in various flavors and decorative styles.
Cookies: Part of their general offerings, providing classic and potentially specialty cookie options for a simple treat.
General Baked Goods: The overall sentiment from positive reviews suggests a wider array of "everything" being "good," implying a broader selection of pastries, desserts, or other sweet treats beyond the explicitly mentioned items.
Special Occasion Orders: The bakery positions itself as a place to head for "special occasion cake," indicating a focus on catering to significant life events with custom-made confections.
---
### Features / Highlights
**Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** possesses several notable features and highlights that distinguish it for customers seeking delicious baked goods:
Exceptional Cake Quality: A key highlight is the consistently praised quality of their cakes, particularly the "moist and flavorful" cake base and "to die for" frosting, which are critical components of a great cake experience.
Signature Tres Leches Cake: The "fabulous" tres leches cake stands out as a unique and highly recommended offering, appealing to those who appreciate this rich and indulgent dessert.
Delicious Cupcakes: The chocolate cupcake is singled out as "hands-down the best cupcake I have ever eaten," suggesting that their cupcakes are a definite must-try for any sweet lover.
Variety of Treats: Beyond cakes and cupcakes, the availability of items like cake pops and cookies ensures there's something for various preferences and occasions, from quick snacks to party favors.
Convenient Mall Location: Being situated inside the Susquehanna Valley Mall provides easy access, ample parking, and the opportunity for spontaneous purchases while shopping.
Potential for Customization: While one review details a negative custom order experience, the intention to offer custom cakes, as evidenced by initial discussions, highlights a service meant to provide personalized creations for customers.
Indulgent Flavor Profiles: The overall feedback, especially regarding the frosting, points to a bakery that prioritizes rich, satisfying, and memorable flavors in its products.
---
### Contact Information
To experience the sweet offerings of **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** or to inquire about their custom orders, you can reach them using the following contact details:
Address: 1 Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr, Selinsgrove, PA 17870, USA
Phone: (570) 374-2619
Mobile Phone: +1 570-374-2619
It is generally advisable to contact the bakery directly by phone for specific inquiries regarding custom cake orders, availability of certain items, or current operating hours, especially since their location is within a mall. This will ensure you get the most up-to-date information and can discuss your needs directly with their team.
---
### Conclusion: Why Sylvia's Sweet Cakes is Suitable for Locals
For the residents of Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania, and the surrounding Susquehanna Valley, **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** presents itself as a compelling local bakery option, particularly suited for those seeking high-quality and exceptionally tasty baked goods. Despite some mixed feedback on custom orders, the strong positive reviews for their core products highlight its potential as a beloved local treat destination.
Firstly, the bakery’s prime location within the **Susquehanna Valley Mall** offers unparalleled convenience. This means easy access and abundant parking, allowing locals to seamlessly integrate a visit to **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** into their shopping trips or daily routines. This accessibility makes it a practical choice for both spontaneous cravings and planned purchases.
Secondly, the quality of their standard offerings, such as the "fabulous" tres leches cake and the "hands-down best" chocolate cupcake, makes it a highly attractive option. These glowing reviews indicate that when it comes to fundamental baked goods, **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** excels in delivering moist, flavorful, and incredibly satisfying treats. For locals prioritizing taste and quality in their everyday indulgences or last-minute dessert needs, these items are a significant draw.
Finally, as a local bakery, **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** aims to cater to the community's needs for special occasion cakes, even if experiences can vary. For those seeking delicious everyday treats and popular specialty items like their renowned tres leches cake or celebrated cupcakes, **Sylvia's Sweet Cakes** offers a valuable, convenient, and often delightful option right in the heart of Selinsgrove, making it a suitable choice for many Pennsylvanians in the region.
Sylvia's Sweet Cakes Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- In-store pick-up
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Sylvia's Sweet Cakes Photos










Sylvia's Sweet Cakes Location
Sylvia's Sweet Cakes
1 Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr, Selinsgrove, PA 17870, USA
Sylvia's Sweet Cakes Reviews
cupcakespricecake popstres leches cakemallcookie
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1I ordered a cake for my graduation party and had sent pictures of the exact cake I wanted. I had shown up to leave a deposit and we discussed the details of my cake. When my friend got back from picking up my cake the day of my party is was no where near what we had discussed. The details were not on it and the picture was not even close. I had texted her because I was not sure how to go about the situation and did not even receive an answer back. I showed up to her store and she got very rude and tried saying I should’ve brought the cake back. I’ve never ordered a cake before so that is why I messaged her the same day I saw the cake was wrong. She should have answered and now we get no refund. The cake tasted horrible and was thrown out. So no, I don’t want your store credit.
July 18 · Erin HessI only recently found Sylvia's, and I have been amazed at how good everything is! The first time we were there, we got a big piece of the tres leches cake, some cake pops, and a cookie. Everything was fabulous. Today, I got a chocolate cupcake with chocolate frosting. I just ate it (with a cup of coffee), and it was hands-down the best cupcake I have ever eaten. The cake was moist and flavorful, and the frosting was absolutely to die for! I don't go to the mall very often, but I may have to start stopping in there more often just to get a treat from Sylvia's. And if I ever need a special occasion cake, I know exactly where I'll be heading!
November 16 · Barbra HarperSylvia was so sweet and accommodating, especially considering the pandemic situation. Literally after trying 2 cake flavors, we knew that we had to order our wedding cake from her. I also put in an order from some cookies for our cookie table. Everything was delicious and priced very reasonably. I definitely recommend
July 25 · Meaghan DornSylvia's Tres le leche cake is the best I've ever eaten! It is absolutely delicious 😋 Her cake pops and cupcakes are awesome too. If you want a yummy treat, stop here!!!
November 28 · Loriann KelleherWent in a few days ago got a chocolate cheesecake and a cupcake. Good prices and very good sweets. Definitely do recommend will be back!
May 23 · Leah Martin
More Bakery Near Me
Cinnabon4.0 (5 reviews)1 Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr, Selinsgrove, PA 17870, USA
Auntie Anne's4.0 (54 reviews)One Susquehanna Valley Mall Dr, Selinsgrove, PA 17870, USA
Dough C Dough5.0 (6 reviews)6 W Sherman St, Selinsgrove, PA 17870, USA
Mama G's Bakery4.0 (20 reviews)436 Market St, Sunbury, PA 17801, USA
Sunbury CSG Bakery4.0 (13 reviews)330 B N 2nd St, Sunbury, PA 17801, USA
Blind Bob's Bakery0.0 (0 reviews)2 Front St, Freeburg, PA 17827, USA
Sweet u2010N- Savory4.0 (12 reviews)179 Salem Church Rd, Middleburg, PA 17842, USA
Paris Bakery & Cafu00e94.0 (145 reviews)335 Market St, Lewisburg, PA 17837, USA
Esch's Pretzels4.0 (5 reviews)499 Fairground Rd, Lewisburg, PA 17837, USA
All Star Bagels4.0 (547 reviews)300 Market St, Lewisburg, PA 17837, USA
Catherman's Home Made Candy4.0 (101 reviews)209 N Front St, Lewisburg, PA 17837, USA
Our Best Friends Bakery5.0 (15 reviews)8693 Old Turnpike Rd, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Rosie's Bagel Cafe4.0 (38 reviews)
Honey Dew Donuts4.0 (78 reviews)
Baked Bouquet5.0 (2 reviews)
Daily Donuts4.0 (54 reviews)
Station Donuts4.0 (154 reviews)
Doughlicious Donuts4.0 (120 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
Why Baking with Fresh Ingredients Makes All the Difference
The Secret to Baking the Perfect Fruit Cake: Tips and Techniques
How to Make Bakery-Style Danish Pastries at Home – Step-by-Step Guide
How to Bake the Best Crusty Artisan Bread in a Dutch Oven – A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Make the Best Soft Pretzels with Sea Salt | Heavenly Delights Bakery
How to Make the Best Homemade Chocolate Pudding Pie - Heavenly Delights Bakery Recipe Guide
