That NY Bagel Place

Introduction / Overview: Bringing the Real Taste of New York Bagels to Bonita Springs, FL

Florida residents no longer need to travel north to experience the chewy, authentic taste of a kettle-boiled and baked New York-style bagel. That NY Bagel Place has firmly established itself in Bonita Springs, offering Southwest Florida a genuine slice of the Big Apple’s culinary tradition. Operating as both a dedicated Bagel shop and a full-service Restaurant, this establishment is committed to serving fresh, large bagels and oversized deli-style sandwiches that consistently earn high praise from local patrons.

Customers frequently highlight the quality and size, noting that the "Bagels are large and fresh, delicious" and come with "large filling portions." The menu is a comprehensive tour of classic NYC flavors, with breakfast sandwiches named after iconic boroughs and landmarks like The Big Apple (BEC), Staten Island (SEC), and Jersey Shore (PREC – featuring the famous Taylor Ham/Pork Roll). It’s an ideal spot for anyone craving a quick, high-quality Breakfast or a robust, satisfying lunch.

More than just breakfast, the shop transitions seamlessly into a deli-style experience for midday meals, offering incredible sandwiches and wraps like the NY Cheesesteak and Governors Island (NOVA) with Nova Salmon. Patrons feel at home here, describing the atmosphere as "very comfortable," making it the perfect destination to "take your coffee, eat a delicious bagel and enjoy the life!" That NY Bagel Place is the ultimate answer for authentic New York bagel cravings right here in the heart of Florida.

Location and Accessibility on the Tamiami Trail

That NY Bagel Place is conveniently located in the bustling Bonita Springs area, making it easily accessible for residents and visitors traveling through Southwest Florida on the major artery, Tamiami Trail.

The specific address is: 24830 S Tamiami Trl #2100, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, USA.

This prime location ensures that a quick stop for a morning bagel or an enjoyable lunch is hassle-free. The shop is well-equipped to welcome all guests, offering comprehensive accessibility features:

• A Wheelchair accessible entrance for smooth entry.
• A dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot for convenience.
• Comfortable Wheelchair accessible seating within the dining area.
• A fully equipped Wheelchair accessible restroom.

For all drivers, parking is readily available and straightforward with both a Free parking lot and options for Free street parking, making a Quick visit completely stress-free.

Comprehensive Services Offered

That NY Bagel Place is structured to serve its Florida clientele through multiple convenient avenues, ensuring everyone can enjoy their fresh bagels and gourmet sandwiches, regardless of their schedule.

• In-House Dining: Enjoy a relaxed Dine-in experience in the comfortable seating area, perfect for meeting friends or starting the day with a hot bagel and coffee.
• Carry-Out Service: Quick and efficient Takeout service for those on the go who need to grab their order and head to the beach, work, or school.
• Order Ahead Options: Simplified In-store pickup for orders placed online or by phone, minimizing wait times during peak morning hours.
• Convenient Delivery: Full Delivery service is available, allowing customers across the Bonita Springs and surrounding areas to have authentic bagels and sandwiches delivered right to their home or office.
• Modern Payments: Accepts all major forms of payment, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features and Culinary Highlights

The menu at That NY Bagel Place is a carefully curated selection of classic New York-style fare, built around their fresh, large, and delicious bagels.

• Authentic, Fresh-Baked Bagels: The core of the business is the bagel itself—large, fresh, and perfectly baked. Customers can choose from classic flavors like Plain, Everything, Sesame, and Onion, along with specialty options like Jalapeno Cheddar, Pepper Jack, and Cinnamon Raisin.
• Gourmet Cream Cheese Spreads: A wide variety of house-made cream cheese flavors are available to perfectly complement the bagels, including Plain, Scallion, Garden Vegetable, Jalapeno, Walnut Raisin, Lox Spread, and Strawberry.
• Signature Breakfast Sandwiches: A dedicated menu of generously filled breakfast sandwiches named after NYC locations:
  • The Big Apple (BEC): Two eggs, bacon, and American cheese.
  • Jersey Shore (PREC): Two eggs, Taylor Ham (Pork Roll), and American cheese—a true North-East specialty.
  • Governors Island (NOVA): Nova Salmon, cream cheese, tomato, capers, and red onion—a classic lox experience and one of the most-liked items.
  • Hells Kitchen: A robust sandwich featuring two scrambled eggs, shaved ribeye steak with salsa fresca, and jalapeno cream cheese.
• Deli-Style Lunch Specialties: The lunch menu is equally impressive, built around high-quality meats and fresh ingredients:
  • New Yorker: Hot pastrami, melted Swiss cheese with grilled onions, and deli mustard.
  • NY Cheesesteak: Shaved ribeye grilled with peppers and onions, topped with provolone cheese.
  • The Chelsea: Turkey, bacon, and avocado served with tomato and veggie cream cheese.
  • Roosevelt Island: Corned beef, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and 1000 island dressing (served on grilled rye bread).
• Fresh Sides and Drinks: Alongside the main meals, the shop offers fresh, homemade sides like Side Potato Salad, Side Pasta Salad, and Side Sweet Potato Salad ($2.99 each), plus quality beverages like fresh Natalie's Juices ($3.99) and Coffee.
• Baked Goods: Features other treats like the classic, highly-rated Crumb Cake ($4.16).
• Comfort and Amenities: Offers in-house amenities including a clean Restroom and complimentary Wi-Fi for a comfortable, extended stay.

Contact Information for That NY Bagel Place

For ordering, general inquiries, or checking the current availability of specialty items, customers in the Florida region can reach the Bonita Springs shop using the following details:

• Address: 24830 S Tamiami Trl #2100, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, USA
• Phone: (239) 405-7908
• Mobile Phone: +1 239-405-7908

What is Worth Choosing: The Authentic New York Experience

For Florida users seeking the absolute best in bagels and deli fare, That NY Bagel Place presents a compelling choice that goes far beyond a typical breakfast spot. Choosing this establishment is all about investing in authenticity, quality, and a superior dining experience.

The primary reason to choose That NY Bagel Place is the Unmistakable Authenticity and Quality of the Bagel. Many Florida residents from the Northeast understand that replicating a genuine New York bagel is a challenge, but this shop delivers. Customers consistently praise the bagels for being "large and fresh" with a perfect texture. This commitment to a true New York-style bagel—often characterized by kettle-boiling and proper baking techniques—is the foundation of its success and provides a taste of nostalgia that is hard to find in Southwest Florida.

Secondly, the value of the Gourmet Sandwiches and Generous Portions is a significant draw. Unlike competitors that skimp on fillings, this shop is noted for its "large filling portions" across its entire menu, from the popular Governors Island (NOVA) with Nova Salmon, to the hearty Manhattan (SKEC) with shaved ribeye steak. Their menu is thoughtfully designed, offering unique, New York-themed specialties like the Jersey Shore (PREC) that provides a distinct flavor profile not commonly found in the South. The lunch offerings, such as the New Yorker pastrami sandwich and the unique Koreatown Wrap, demonstrate a breadth of creativity and quality well beyond a standard bagel shop.

Finally, the focus on Customer Comfort and Convenience enhances the overall appeal. With a welcoming atmosphere described as "very comfortable," complete with Dine-in service, clean amenities, and free Wi-Fi, it's a place where patrons feel encouraged to "take a seat, take your coffee, eat a delicious bagel and enjoy the life!" Coupled with seamless ordering options for Delivery, Takeout, and easy, accessible Free parking, That NY Bagel Place provides the ideal, high-quality, and convenient solution for all your breakfast and lunch needs in the Bonita Springs area.

That NY Bagel Place

24830 S Tamiami Trl #2100, Bonita Springs, FL 34134, USA