The Bagel Nook Atlantic Highlands: NJ's Home for Infamous Overload Bagels and Creative Breakfast

The Bagel Nook Introduce

## Welcome to The Bagel Nook: Atlantic Highlands’ Most Creative Bagel Shop

For New Jersey residents looking for a bagel experience that goes beyond the ordinary, **The Bagel Nook** in Atlantic Highlands is a must-visit destination. This isn’t just your average local bagel shop; it’s a culinary landmark famous for its incredibly wide selection of fresh bagels, inventive **Overload** specialty items, and some of the most creative cream cheese flavors you'll find anywhere. Located conveniently on Route 36, The Bagel Nook has quickly cemented its place in the Monmouth County food scene by blending classic Jersey breakfast standards with unique, Instagram-worthy treats.

The dedication to diversity extends beyond the menu. The Bagel Nook proudly identifies as a **Black-owned, Latino-owned, veteran-owned, and women-owned** business, fostering a warm, welcoming, and inclusive atmosphere. This commitment to community and creativity shines through in their product, offering everything from traditional hand-rolled bagels to viral sensation items, ensuring there’s something for every taste and craving, whether you're a local or a visitor traveling to the nearby shore points. Customers frequently praise the friendly staff and the amazing quality of their entire menu, confirming that the experience is worth the trip.

---

## Location and Accessibility in Atlantic Highlands

**The Bagel Nook** is strategically located at **2345 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA**. Its position right on State Route 36 makes it highly accessible for drivers from surrounding towns like Hazlet, Highlands, and Middletown, or for anyone traveling along the Jersey Shore corridor.

Accessibility is a key priority for this business. Patrons will find an array of convenient features designed to accommodate everyone:

**Parking**: Features a **Free parking lot**, **On-site parking**, and **Free street parking** to ensure hassle-free visits.

**Physical Accessibility**: The entire establishment is highly accessible, including a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.

**Service Convenience**: Offering various service options to suit your schedule, including **Dine-in**, **Takeout**, **Curbside pickup**, and **Delivery**.

**Amenities**: Customers can take advantage of **Wi-Fi** and a clean **Restroom**. The space is also promoted as **LGBTQ+ friendly** and a **Transgender safespace**, emphasizing its inclusive community environment.

---

## Diverse Services and Menu Offerings

The menu at The Bagel Nook is vast, ensuring they function as a complete breakfast, brunch, and lunch destination. Their offerings extend far beyond simple bagels and coffee.

**Bagel & Spread Selection**: Offering **Loose Bagels** and a **Dozen Classic Bagels** ($16.85), customizable with classic options or their unique **Bagel & Cream Cheese** pairings. Spread tubs like **Philadelphia Tub** ($6.19) are also available for home use.

**Infamous Overloads**: The signature specialty menu includes creative, dessert-bagel hybrids such as **Cannoli Donut Overload** ($9.45), **Fruity Pebble Overload** ($7.85), **Cookie Monster Overload** ($8.41), and even savory/sweet twists like the **Flamin' Hot Cheeto Overload** ($7.85) and **Dorito Overload** ($7.85).

**Gourmet Breakfast Sandwiches**: A wide range of substantial breakfast items, including **Two Eggs, Meat, & Cheese**, the intense **Double Nooker**, **The Fatty**, **Steak, Egg & Cheese**, and **The "Bella Bomber"** ($14.50).

**Full Grill Menu**: Offering classic hot plates like **Egg Breakfast Platters** and various omelettes (e.g., **LEO Omelette**, **The Porker Omelete**, **Greek Omelette**). The grill also produces specialty wraps and sandwiches like the **Kickin Chicken** and the **Lean Mean Philly Cheesesteak**.

**Pancakes & French Toast**: An extensive griddle menu with options like **Golden Brown Pancakes** ($11.43), **Stuffed French Toast** ($13.51), and fun, creative selections such as **Fruity Pebble™ French Toast** ($9.35) and **Crazy Chocolate Chip French Toast** ($13.51).

**Deli Lunch**: Providing fresh lunch staples including specialty Paninis (**Spicy Chicken Panini**, **CaliClub Panini**), classic deli sandwiches (**The Reuben**, **Turkey Club**, **The Italian**), and a variety of sides from **Side French Friess** ($5.19) to a healthy **Side Fruit Bowl** ($4.42).

**Coffee and Beverages**: Serving high-quality **Coffee/Tea** in three sizes, **Iced Coffee** ($3.63), and offering branded coffee products like **Bagel Nook Coffee K-Cups** ($17.67) for at-home enjoyment.

---

## Key Features and Highlights for NJ Patrons

The Bagel Nook’s reputation is built on its innovative menu and exceptional dedication to quality and service, making it a standout spot in Central New Jersey.

**Innovation in Bagels**: The shop is famous across the state and beyond for its creative bagel and cream cheese combinations, allowing local users to experience something truly unique, like the widely praised **creative cream cheese options**.

**The Overload Specials**: These decadent, dessert-focused creations are a major highlight, turning a simple snack into an experience. The **Cannoli Donut Overload** is a prime example of their playful, dessert-forward approach.

**Inclusive Ownership and Environment**: Identifying as **Black-owned, Latino-owned, veteran-owned, and women-owned**, combined with being an **LGBTQ+ friendly** and **Transgender safespace**, creates a highly welcoming environment that appeals to a diverse New Jersey customer base.

**All-Day Menu Depth**: The ability to serve both a complex breakfast (like **Stuffed French Toast**) and a full deli lunch (including a variety of **Sandwiches & Wraps** and hot Paninis) means The Bagel Nook is an excellent option regardless of the time of day.

**Superior Accessibility**: The extensive provisions for accessibility, including free, accessible parking and comprehensive entry/seating features, make the shop convenient and welcoming for everyone in the community.

---

## Contact Information

For orders, catering inquiries, or to find out about the latest menu additions at this highly-rated Atlantic Highlands location, please use the following contact details:

**Address:** 2345 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA

**Phone (Primary):** (908) 332-0003

**Mobile Phone:** +1 908-332-0003

---

## What is Worth Choosing The Bagel Nook

For New Jersey residents, choosing The Bagel Nook means investing in a local business that represents the best of the state's entrepreneurial and culinary spirit. It’s an ideal choice for several key reasons. Firstly, the quality of the core product is consistently high—customers rave about the bagels themselves, noting the "best I’ve had around the area."

Secondly, the commitment to innovation is a powerful draw. While other shops stick to tradition, The Bagel Nook offers exciting, unique items like the **Overloads** and highly creative breakfast sandwiches, turning an everyday meal into a joyful, shareable experience. This creative menu, combined with a full range of traditional sandwiches and grill items, ensures that both the adventurous eater and the traditionalist are satisfied.

Finally, the welcoming environment, driven by the diverse ownership and highly-praised staff, makes every visit pleasant and friendly. As one local customer noted, the staff are "always happy to help and friendly," making the experience "absolutely amazing." From a quick coffee and bagel to a full breakfast platter, The Bagel Nook provides a delicious, accessible, and uniquely New Jersey food experience right in Atlantic Highlands.

The Bagel Nook Food & drink

Print Options
Print Order Bill $0.00
Print Cash Order Bill $0.00
Print Credit Order Bill $0.00
Print All Guests $0.00

Sides
Side Avocado $3.11
Side Eggs $3.11
Side Bacon $3.11
Side Porkroll $3.11
Side Sasuage $3.11
Side Turkey Bacon $3.11
Side French Friess $5.19
Side Home Fries $4.42
Side Hashbrown $1.04
Side Onion Rings $5.19
Side Fruit Bowl $4.42
Side Mozzarella Sticks $5.19
Grilled Chicken Piece $2.60
Chicken Cutlet Piece $3.02

Panini
Spicy Chicken Panini $11.96
Pulled chicken in a spicy sauce topped with pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing.
CaliClub Panini $11.44
Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado.
Grilled Chicken Panini $11.44
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and balsamic glaze.

Truck Sandwiches
Big Daddy
Cheesesteak, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, french fries, lettuce, tomato, ketchup & mayo.
The Captain
Chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, with BBQ sauce.
The Wrecker
Cheesesteak, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, bacon, & more bacon.
The Promise Land
Chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, bacon, cheese, french fries, and hot sauce.
The Mother Clucker
Cheesesteak, chicken tenders, bacon, egg, lettuce, tomato, french fries, mayo & ketchup.

From the Grill
Cajun Chicken Sandwich
Tender grilled chicken breast with cajun seasonings, topped with crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Chicken Ranch Wrap
Crispy chicken, with bacon, Vermont cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion, & a ranch drizzle.
Chicken Fingers And Fries $12.48
Grilled Cheese $7.28
Kickin Chicken
Lean Mean Philly Cheesesteak
Thinly sliced beef sauteed with mushrooms & onions topped with melted cheese.
Naughty Nooker
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Breaded chicken tossed in our blazing buffalo sauce with melted vermont cheddar, crispy lettuce, and ranch dressing.

Sandwiches & Wraps
The Reuben
Hot Pastrami piled high with sauerkraut, melted swiss, on grilled rye bread, with Russian dressing.
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, & tomato.
Turkey Club
Sliced turkey, bacon, lettuce, & tomato.
The Italian
Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato , O&V.
Heavenly Ham
Sliced ham & melted swiss with a dijon aioli.
The Classic
Turkey, roast beef, cole slaw & Russian dressing.
The Manhattan
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & balsamic glaze.

Pancakes & French Toast
Golden Brown Pancakes $11.43
3 golden brown Pancakes
Short Stack Pancakes $10.39
Blueberry Pancakes $11.95
3 golden brown Blueberry Pancakes.
Chocolate Chip Pancakes $12.99
3 golden brown Chocolate Chip Pancakes.
Joe's Berries & Chocolate Pancakes $13.51
Chocolate chip pancakes topped with freshly sliced strawberries & chocolate chips.
French Toast Plate $11.43
Three pieces of homemade Challah bread dipped in our secret batter and grilled to perfection. 
Stuffed French Toast $13.51
Challah french toast dipped in our secret batter, stuffed with sweetened cream cheese & fresh strawberries.
Crazy Chocolate Chip French Toast $13.51
Challah french toast dipped in our secret batter, stuffed with Nutella & sliced bananas.
Fruity Pebble™ French Toast $9.35
Challah bread dipped in our secret batter and encrusted with fruity pebbles with a vanilla drizzle!

Overloads
Cannoli Donut Overload $9.45
Cannoli french toast bagel, cannoli cream cheese, and a cannoli donut in the middle. 
Chcolate Fudge Overload $7.85
A chocolate lover's dream! Cocoa Puff bagel, fudge brownie cream cheese on both sides, and crushed brownies in the middle.
Cookie Dough Overload $7.85
Cocoa Puff bagel, with cookie dough cream cheese on both sides, and chocolate chip cookies in the middle.
Cookie Monster Overload $8.41
Oreo bagel with cookie monster cream cheese, Oreos, and chocolate chip cookies.
Crumb Cake Overload $8.31
French toast bagel, with crumb cake cream cheese on both sides, and a piece of crumb cake in the middle.
Dorito Overload $7.85
Dorito bagel with jalapeno cheddar cream cheese on both sides, and Doritos in the middle.
Elvis Overload $9.45
Ooey gooey french toast bagel, with peanut butter swirl cream cheese on both sides, freshly sliced bananas, and crispy bacon in the middle.
Flamin' Hot Cheeto Overload $7.85
Flaming Hot Cheetos bagel with ghost pepper cream cheese and Flaming Hot Cheetos in the middle.
Fruity Pebble Overload $7.85
Light and fluffy Fruity Pebble bagel with birthday cake cream cheese and freshly sliced strawberries in the middle.
Oreo Overload $7.85
Oreo bagel, with our delicious Oreo cream cheese, and Oreo cookies in the middle.
Sugar Cookie Overload $8.16
Tye Dye bagel, sugar cookie cream cheese, sugar cookies, and sprinkles.
Triple Chocolate Chunk Overload $7.85
Chocolate chip bagel, M&M cream cheese on both sides, and chocolate chip cookies in the middle.
Blueberry Crumb Overload $8.32
Blueberry french toast bagel, blueberry crumb cream cheese on both sides, and a piece of crumb cake in the middle.
COCO PUFF OVERLOAD $8.32
Cocoa Puff bagel, Nutella cream cheese on both sides, and freshly sliced bananas in the middle.
Lucky Charm Overload $8.49

Egg Breakfast Platters & Omelette
Egg Platter
Cheese Omelette
3 eggs with your choice of cheese.
Greek Omelette
3 eggs with spinach, tomato, onion & feta.
LEO Omelette
3 eggs fresh lox & onion.
Southwestern Platter
3 eggs with pepper, ham, & pepper jack cheese.
The Porker Omelete
Shaved ham, chopped bacon, & cheddar.
Very Veggie Omelete
Egg whites with sauteed mushrooms, spinach, tomato, & onion.
Western Omelete
3 eggs with shaved ham, pepper & onion.

Breakfast Sandwiches
Two Eggs, Meat, & Cheese
Just Two Eggs
Meat Sandwhich
Avocado Blast
Steak, Egg & Cheese
2 eggs with sautéed sliced steak and provolone.
Juevos Burrito
Scrambled eggs with onions, Pepper Jack cheese, sausage, avocado, & salsa in your choice of wrap.
The Popeye
Egg whites with spinach, grilled turkey & Swiss cheese.
Double Nooker
The ultimate triple-decker breakfast sandwich. Bacon egg and cheese sandwiched under a pork roll egg & cheese.
The Fatty
Spicy Sunrise
The "Bella Bomber" $14.50
Toasted Sourdough Bagel with Livoti's whipped Ricotta Cheese, crispy imported Prosciutto and a sunny side up egg, topped with everything seeds

Bakery
Crumb Cake $3.64
Oreo Cake $3.64
Chips $2.80

Bagels
Bagel & Cream Cheese
Bagel & Butter
Bagel & PB/Jelly
Bagel & Salad Sandwich
Boars Head Deli Sandwhich
Loose Bagels
Bagels Pick Up
Dozen Classic Bagels $16.85
Philadelphia Tub $6.19
Butter Tub $5.15
Temp Tee $6.19
Bagel & Cold Cheese Sandwhich

Drinks
Coffee/Tea - Small $2.60
Coffee/Tea - Medium $2.86
Coffee/Tea - Large $3.11
Coffee Overloads $0.00
Iced Coffee $3.63
Cup Of Ice $0.54
Dasani $2.08
Gold Peak Tea $3.11
Flavored Milk $3.11
Lemonade $3.63
Monster $4.11
Naked
Polar Seltzer $3.11
Powerade $3.11
Soda 20oz
Snapple $3.11
Smart Water 20oz $2.70
Tropicana 12oz $3.11
Large OJ $7.27
Bagel Nook Coffee K-Cups $17.67
Bagel Nook Coffee Bags $13.51

UNCATEGORIZED
Coffee - Small $2.60
Coffee - Medium $2.86
Coffee - Large $3.11
Online Convenience Fee $0.00

The Bagel Nook Details

From the business
Identifies as Black-owned
Identifies as Latino-owned
Identifies as veteran-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking

The Bagel Nook Photos

The Bagel Nook Location

The Bagel Nook

New Jersey Monmouth County Atlantic Highlands New Jersey 36

2345 NJ-36, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716, USA

The Bagel Nook Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 103 user reviews.

cream cheeselunchbagel sandwicheseggpork rollselectioncerealflat bagelpebblesdrive

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

The bagel nook is Atlantic Highlands is absolutely amazing from the owners down the staff. They are always happy to help and friendly. Is food is amazing I have had evening from their speciality menu to breakfast sandwiches and there lunch is very good as well. I go there almost every day since they have opened. Go experience it for your self!!!
August 27 · N Ick
The egg everything flat bagel was the best I’ve had around the area!! Creative cream cheese options and a so many varieties! Very cool spot. I will definitely be going back. Highly recommended!!
June 18 · Emily Kamenitzer
It's a good thing this place isn't closer to my house. I would be here all the time. All the options are so fun! The pumpkin bagel sandwich was the cutest. The seasonal muffin we got was also great!
September 14 · Kristen
BAGEL NOOK new location apparently Atlantic Highlands. Right off bat? Staff was friendly and efficient. Place was spotless, owner was fantastic, friendly and generous. This was my first visit to any of these since they haven’t been near me yet. I thought it was gonna be all kinds of crazy sweet cream cheeses with flavors, but I was pleasantly surprised! the flat bagels were specifically amazing everything I love in a bagel and so far my favorite flat bagel and so delicious. We got an apple crumble bagel for my husband and my son got some of the cereal ones which he said were amazing as well. I’m coming back for the hash brown bagel next. On a sidenote, COFFEE WAS THE BOMB . Very very good!
June 17 · Allison Schleicher
A very clean store with a very whimsical seating area. The staff is welcoming and the menu is downright fun with unexpected bagels made of childhood favorite cereals like, Cap'n Crunch and Fruity Pebbles. They even have a tie-dye bagel 🥯 and so many delicious cream cheese options. Sandwiches and various beverages to boot. I plan to return.
August 18 · Jesabel C.