Bagel Basket Cafe: A Local's Guide to Authentic Bagels in Commack, NY

Bagel Basket Cafe Introduce

If you're a New Yorker, you know that a truly great bagel isn't just food—it's a way of life. The perfect bagel is a delicate balance of a crispy, chewy crust and a soft, airy interior. It's the foundation of a great breakfast sandwich, a simple yet satisfying lunch, or a quick snack to power you through the day. In the heart of Commack, Long Island, one name frequently comes up when locals talk about their go-to spot for this quintessential New York staple: Bagel Basket Cafe. This article is your comprehensive guide to what makes Bagel Basket Cafe a beloved fixture in the community, from its delectable offerings to its friendly staff and convenient location.

Bagel Basket Cafe has established itself as more than just a place to grab a bite; it's a neighborhood hub where people start their mornings, catch up with friends, and fuel up for their busy schedules. Located on Commack Road, this establishment has built a loyal following over the years, with many customers considering it a staple in their daily routines. The cafe prides itself on serving fresh, high-quality food in an environment that feels both welcoming and efficient. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a long-time regular, the goal is to provide a satisfying experience that leaves you eager to return. The cafe's reputation is built on consistency and a genuine commitment to customer satisfaction. Many patrons praise the staff for their kindness and the owner for creating a friendly atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasant one. This dedication to both quality food and excellent service is a key reason why Bagel Basket Cafe continues to thrive in a competitive market.

The cafe’s menu extends far beyond just bagels. While the star of the show is undoubtedly their fresh-baked bagels, they offer a wide variety of breakfast and lunch options to cater to all tastes. From classic cream cheese spreads and butter to more elaborate breakfast sandwiches featuring eggs, bacon, sausage, and cheese, there's something for everyone. For those seeking a heartier meal, the cafe serves a selection of deli sandwiches, salads, and wraps, making it an ideal destination for a quick and delicious lunch. The menu is designed to be both comprehensive and straightforward, ensuring that even on the busiest mornings, you can quickly find and order your favorite meal. Their commitment to using fresh ingredients is evident in every bite, from the perfectly cooked eggs to the crisp vegetables in their salads. This focus on quality is a primary reason for their enduring popularity in the local community. The cafe’s offerings are a testament to its understanding of what local customers truly want: delicious, fresh food that is both quick and reasonably priced.

Bagel Basket Cafe is conveniently located at 639 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA. This prime location on a major thoroughfare makes it easily accessible for residents and commuters alike. Situated in a bustling area, it is a convenient stop for those heading to work, running errands, or simply looking for a great meal. The cafe provides easy parking options, which is a significant plus for customers on the go. Its proximity to other local businesses and residential areas means it is a natural meeting point and a regular destination for many in the community. Whether you're driving by and need to grab a quick coffee and bagel or you're planning to sit and enjoy your meal, the accessibility of the location is a major draw. The clear signage and well-maintained storefront make it easy to spot, ensuring you won't have trouble finding this local gem. Its central location solidifies its role as a key part of the local landscape, serving the needs of the Commack community with ease and efficiency.

Services Offered:

Fresh-baked bagels and a variety of spreads
Customizable breakfast sandwiches with eggs, cheese, and various meats
A wide selection of hot and cold deli sandwiches
Gourmet salads and wraps for a lighter lunch option
Coffee, tea, and other beverage selections
Catering services for meetings, parties, and events
Quick takeout and efficient counter service for on-the-go customers

Features / Highlights:

A reputation for consistently fresh and delicious food, praised by long-term customers.
Friendly and professional staff who create a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere.
Reasonably priced menu items that offer excellent value for the quality.
Conveniently located on Commack Rd with easy parking.
A wide-ranging menu that caters to both breakfast and lunch crowds.
A local, independently owned business with strong ties to the Commack community.
A place where many locals feel like they are part of a family, with the owner and employees remembering regulars.

For any inquiries or to place an order, you can contact Bagel Basket Cafe directly. The team is always ready to assist you with your order, answer any questions about their menu, or discuss catering options. The primary phone number is (631) 486-5126. You can also reach them via mobile at +1 631-486-5126. Their physical address, as a reminder, is 639 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA. The team’s responsiveness and willingness to help are just another example of their commitment to providing exceptional customer service. Whether you need to inquire about their daily specials or place a large order for an office gathering, a simple phone call will connect you with a helpful member of their staff. This direct line of communication is essential for maintaining the personal touch that local businesses are known for, and Bagel Basket Cafe excels at it.

In conclusion, Bagel Basket Cafe is more than just a place to get a bagel; it's a cornerstone of the Commack community. For locals, it's a reliable, friendly, and delicious option for any time of day. The consistent quality of their food, coupled with the warm and welcoming service, makes it an ideal spot for a quick breakfast before work, a relaxed lunch with friends, or a grab-and-go meal for the family. The cafe's commitment to fresh ingredients and a positive customer experience is what truly sets it apart. While every business may have an occasional hiccup, the overwhelming sentiment from long-time patrons is one of loyalty and satisfaction. For anyone in the New York region, and specifically in the Commack area, seeking an authentic, local bagel experience, Bagel Basket Cafe is a must-visit destination. Its blend of classic New York fare and genuine neighborhood charm makes it a place that locals are proud to call their own. It is a perfect example of a small business that not only serves its customers but also enriches the community it is a part of, one delicious bagel at a time.

Bagel Basket Cafe Food & drink

Breakfast
2 Eggs
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
2 Eggs and Cheese
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
Meat, 2 Eggs
Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Turkey, Turkey Bacon, Boar's Head MeatsEggs or Egg Whites Roll, Seedless Roll, Any Bagel, Any Flagel, Croissant, Hero, Any Toast, On Plate (no bread)
Meat, 2 Eggs, and Cheese
Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Turkey, Turkey Bacon, Boar's Head MeatsEggs or Egg Whites American, Cheddar, Provolone, Swiss, Mozzarella, Muenster, PepperjackRoll, Seedless Roll, Any Bagel, Any Flagel, Croissant, Hero, Any Toast, On Plate (no bread)
Hungryman
3 EGG, BACON, SAUSAGE, HAM & CHEESE ON HERO.SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE $2.15
Greek Omelette
EGG, SPINACH, TOMATO, ONION, AND FETA CHEESE
Spanish Omelette
EGG, PEPPERS, ONION, TOMATO, JALAPENO
Western Omelette
EGG, HAM, ONION, AND PEPPERS
Vegetable Omelette
EGG, SPINACH, TOMATO, ONION, MUSHROOMS, PEPPERS
Lox Omelette
LOX, EGG & ONION
Buttermilk Pancakes
Served with syrup and butter on the side
B.B.C. Pancakes
includes fresh strawberries and walnuts
French Toast / Challah
Served with syrup and butter on the side
Home Fries
small (12oz) or large (16oz)*also available on a breakfast sandwich
Hashbrown
hashbrown patty available either on the side or on a breakfast sandwich

Gourmet Breakfast Wraps
B.B.C. Breakfast Wrap
Egg Whites, Spinach, Alpine Lace Swiss, Tomatoes in a Whole Wheat Wrap
Classic Breakfast Wrap
SCRAMBLED EGGS, HAM, BACON OR SAUSAGE, AMERICAN CHEESE IN A PLAIN WRAP
Healthy Breakfast Wrap
3 EGG WHITE, TURKEY, ALPINE LACE SWISS CHEESE & TOMATO IN WHOLE WHEAT WRAP
Western Breakfast Wrap
SCRAMBLE EGG, HAM, PEPPERS & ONION IN PLAIN WRAP

Bagels & Flagels
Bagels
plain (or whole wheat)blueberrycinnamon raisineggegg everythingegg onioneverything (or whole wheat)garlicholiday (*only during selected holidays*)multigrainonionpoppypumpernickelpumpernickel everythingryerainbowsaltsesame (or whole wheat)sunflower seedgluten-free plain
Flagels
EggEgg EverythingEverything (or whole wheat)Onion (or whole wheat)Plain (or whole wheat)Poppy (or whole wheat)Sesame (or whole wheat)Sunflower Seed (or whole wheat)
Bialy
French Toast Bagel

Cream Cheese & Spreads
also sold in containers at quarter, half, & one pound
Butter
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
Cinnamon Raisin Cream Cheese
Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese
Lox Cream Cheese
Maple Walnut Cream Cheese
Olive Cream Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Strawberry Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese

Classic Homemade Oatmeal
Small (12oz) or Large (16oz)add:raisins | dried cranberries | strawberries | granola | maple syrup | blueberries | walnuts | almonds | brown sugar | cinnamon
Small Oatmeal
ADD TOPPING: BLUEBERRY, STRAWBERRIES, BANANAS, CRAISIN, OR CHOCOLATE CHIP $1.50.ADD: SLICE ALMONDS, GRANOLA $2.00
Large Oatmeal
ADD TOPPING: BLUEBERRY, STRAWBERRIES, BANANAS, CRAISIN, OR CHOCOLATE CHIP $1.50.ADD: SLICE ALMONDS, GRANOLA $2.00

Protein Bowl
base: quinoa & kale blend, brown rice, or white riceprotein: marinated grilled chicken, cajun spiced chicken, marinated flank steak, or grilled vegetablestoppings: pico de gallo, corn salsa, sweet potatoes, black beans, homemade onion rings, cucumbers, jalapenos, banana peppers, tortilla chips, strawberries, blueberries, 3-cheese blend, avocadosauce: pesto, hot sauce
Build Your Protein Bowl
choose 1 basechoose 1 proteinchoose up to 4 toppings (avocado is not included)

Homemade Soups
Small (12oz) or Large (12oz)Mon - Fri: 2-3 choices of soups available
Chicken Noodle Soup
*served daily*
Beef Barley Soup
Cream of Turkey Soup
Lentil Soup
Corn Chowder Soup
Split Pea Soup
Vegetable Soup

Salad Bar
Choose Greens: Romaine, Mesculin, Spinach, Iceberg LettuceUp to 5 ingredients includedChoose: dressing mixed or on the side, salad tossed or chopped. Served with a mini bagelIngredients:Bacon Bits | Banana Peppers | Beets | Black Olives | Broccoli | Carrots | Celery | Chick Peas | Corn | Croutons | Cucumbers | Crumbled Bleu Cheese | Dried Cranberries | Feta Cheese | Green Olives | Green Peppers | Hard Boiled Egg (sliced) | Jalapeno Peppers | Mushrooms | Onion | Parmesan Cheese | Raisins | Roasted Red Peppers | Shredded Cheddar Cheese | Sunflower Seeds | Tomato | Tri-Color Tortilla Strips | WalnutsAdditional Ingredients ($2.50+): Grilled Chicken | Chicken Cutlet | Roast Turkey | Tuna Salad | Egg Salad | Chicken Salad | Ham | Fresh Mozzarella | Avocado Dressing Options:Creamy Caesar | Buttermilk Ranch | Balsamic Vinaigrette | Thousand Island | Honey Mustard | Italian Herb | Balsamic Vinegar | Asian Sesame Ginger | Chunky Bleu Cheese | Fat Free Raspberry Vinaigrette | Oil & Vinegar
Small
Large

Salad Menu
House Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, cucumbers, peppers and red onion
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Classic Caesar Salad with Marinated Grilled Chicken
Southwestern Chicken Salad
Cajun Spiced Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Corn, Tomato, Black Olives, Crunchy Tortilla Strips served with ranch dressing
Gorgonberry Salad
Grilled Chicken, Mixed Baby Greens, Gorgonzola Cheese, Walnuts, Dried Cranberries served with Raspberry Vinaigrette

acai station
includes:acai fruit, granola, banana, strawberry, blueberry, coconut, and drizzle of honeyadd nutella or peanut butter for $1.00+
Small Acai Bowl
Acai berries, blueberries & strawberries, topped with orange granola, fresh sliced bananas,blueberries & shredded coconut.Extra Toppings $ 1.25 EACH: peanut butter, nutella, mango, kiwi, pineapple, walnuts, chiaseeds, hemp seeds, flax seeds, honey
Large Acai Bowl
Acai berries, blueberries & strawberries, topped with orange granola, fresh sliced bananas,blueberries & shredded coconut.Extra Toppings $ 1.25 EACH: peanut butter, nutella, mango, kiwi, pineapple, walnuts, chiaseeds, hemp seeds, flax seeds, honey

Breakfast
Bagel US$1.62
Bagel Only US$1.68
Gluten Free Bagel US$2.59
Dozen Bagels US$20.79
Buy a dozen, get 2 more bagels for free! Please let us know per instructions (i.e. plain - 14) *Flagels, Bialy, French Toast Bagels, Gluten-Free are NOT included*- PLAIN, GLUTEN-FREE PLAIN, HOLIDAY BAGEL, SESAME, POPPY SEED, ONION, GARLIC, EVERYTHING, EGG, EGG ONION, MULTIGRAIN, WHOLE WHEAT PLAIN, WHOLE WHEAT SESAME, WHOLE WHEAT EVERYTHING, OAT BRAN, SALT, BLURBERRY, CINNAMON RAISIN, RAINBOW, PUMPERNICKEL, PUMPERNICKEL EVERYTHING, RAY, BAILEYS, ROLLS
Mini Bagel US$1.24
Mini Bagel Dozen US$14.55
PLAIN, POPPY SEED, SESAME, EVERYTHING
Flagel /F.T/Bialy US$2.30
Flagel Dozen US$23.91
PLAIN, EGG, EGG EVERYTHING, EVERYTHING, POPPY SEED, SESAME, SUNFLOWER SEED, ONION, WHOLE WHEAT PLAIN, WHOLE WHEAT SESAME, WHOLE WHEAT EVERYTHING, WHOLE WHEAT SUNFLOWER SEED
2 Eggs On Plate US$5.19
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
2 Eggs On Roll US$5.19
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
2 Eggs & Meat US$7.27
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
2 Eggs & Cheese US$5.71
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
2 Eggs, Meat & Cheese US$7.79
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
Turkey, Bacon, Egg, Cheese US$8.31
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT- SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE$2.15
Hungry Man US$11.43
3 EGG, BACON, SAUSAGE, HAM & CHEESE ON HERO.SUBSTITUTE W/EGG WHITE $2.15
Side Of Meat US$3.11
Side Of Hash Browns US$2.70
BBC Breakfast Wrap US$10.39
EGG WHITE, LACEY SWISS CHEESE, SPINACH & TOMATO IN A SPINACH WRAP
Classic Breakfast Wrap US$10.39
SCRAMBLED EGGS, HAM, BACON OR SAUSAGE, AMERICAN CHEESE IN A PLAIN WRAP
Healthy Breakfast Wrap US$10.39
3 EGG WHITE, TURKEY, ALPINE LACE SWISS CHEESE & TOMATO IN WHOLE WHEAT WRAP
Western Breakfast Wrap US$10.39
SCRAMBLE EGG, HAM, PEPPERS & ONION IN PLAIN WRAP
Gourmet Omelettes US$11.43
Western, Greek, Vegetable, Spanish, or Cheese OmeletteServed with a side of white, whole wheat, or rye toast with butter or any mini bagel with butter
Leo Omelette US$12.47
French Toast US$10.39
Pancakes US$9.87
ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS $1.99 EXTRA(BLUEBERRIES, STRAWBERRIES, BANANAS, CHOCOLATE CHIPS, OREOS, WALNUTS)
Home Fries
small (12oz) or large (16oz)*also available on a breakfast sandwich
Acai Bowls
Classic Oatmeal
ADD TOPPING: BLUEBERRY, STRAWBERRIES, BANANAS, CRAISIN, OR CHOCOLATE CHIP $1.50.ADD: SLICE ALMONDS, GRANOLA $2.00
Hot Chocolate
Small, Medium, Large
Iced Coffee
Small or Large
Iced Tea
Orange Juice
Fruit Cup US$6.23
Rice Pudding/Yogurt US$6.23
Banana US$1.30
Fresh OJ 8 Oz US$5.19
Fresh OJ 12 Oz US$8.31
Grilled Cheese US$6.23
- BAGEL, ROLL, PLATTER- HERO AND WRAP IS $1 EXT
Copy of Healthy Breakfast Wrap US$10.81
3 EGG WHITE, TURKEY, ALPINE LACE SWISS CHEESE & TOMATO IN WHOLE WHEAT WRAP
Coffee

Classic Sandwiches
Veggie Tuna Sandwich US$10.91
Tuna Salad Sandwich US$10.39
Egg Salad Sandwich US$9.35
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich US$10.39
Chicken Salad Sandwich US$9.87
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich US$10.99
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$11.43
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
American Cheese Sandwich US$7.27
BLT Sandwich US$9.35
Salsalito Turkey Sandwich US$9.99
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Cracked Pepper Turkey Sandwich US$10.39
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Maple Honey Turkey Sandwich US$10.39
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Ovengold Turkey Sandwich US$10.39
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Pastrami Sandwich US$10.91
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Roast Beef Sandwich US$11.43
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Genoa Salami Sandwich US$10.39
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Maple Honey Ham Sandwich US$10.39
Deluxe Ham Sandwich US$10.39
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Liverwurst Sandwich US$9.35
Honey Mustard Chicken Salad US$9.99
Whitefish Salad US$10.39
Bologna Sandwich US$9.35
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Vege Delight Sandwich US$9.35
Mini Bagel Sandwich US$8.31

Signature Sandwiches
Gourmet Signature Sandwiches US$12.47
S1. The Banana Chicken US$12.47
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, mayo, and balsamic vinegar on a Garlic Hero
S2. The B.B.C Sub US$12.47
Cracked Pepper Turkey, Crispy Bacon, Melted Muenster Cheese, Cole Slaw, and Russian dressing on a Hero
S4. The Commack High US$12.47
Honey Maple Turkey, Melted Mozzarella, Crispy Bacon, Tomato, and sweet honey mustard on a Hero
S3. Ovengold Turkey US$12.47
Oven-Gold Turkey with Crispy Bacon, Sundried Tomato, and pesto mayo on an Onion Roll
S5. Honey Chicken Salad US$12.47
Honey Chicken Salad with Crispy Bacon, Tomato, and Lettuce on Whole Wheat Toast
S6. The Candlewood US$12.47
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Bacon, Melted American, Lettuce, and Russian dressing on a Roll
S7. Death Wish US$12.47
Roast Beef with Melted Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, and Russian dressing on a Garlic Hero
S8. The Predator US$12.47
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Bacon, Melted Mozzarella, and Russian dressing on a Garlic Hero
S9. Italian Hero US$12.47
Capicola Ham, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, Lettuce, Onion, and oil & vinegar on a Hero
S10. The Cracked Turkey US$12.47
Cracked Pepper Turkey with Melted Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, and pesto mayo on a Garlic Hero
S11. The Bob O US$12.47
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, and balsamic vinaigrette on a Grilled Garlic Hero
S12. The Thunderbird US$12.47
Salsalito Turkey with Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Tomato, Banana Peppers with mayo on a Grilled Hero

Signature Wraps
Wrap US$11.95
W1. Vegetable Tuna US$11.95
Vegetable Tuna Salad with Roasted Peppers and Lettuce in a Plain Wrap
W2. Southwestern US$11.95
Grilled Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & chipotle mayo in a Plain Wrap
W3. Steakhouse US$11.95
Seasoned Roast Beef with Caramelized Onion, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and horseradish dressing in a Plain Wrap
W4. Main Street US$11.95
Grilled Balsamic Vegetables with Fresh Mozzarella, Mixed Baby Greens, and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette in a Plain Wrap
W5. North Shore US$11.95
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad with Lettuce and Tomato in a Whole Wheat Wrap
W6. South Beach US$11.95
Roast Turkey with Bacon, Tomato, Cucumber, and mayo in an Iceberg Lettuce Wrap
W7. Smithtown US$11.95
Honey Chicken Salad with Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato in a Whole Wheat Wrap
W8. Commack Slim US$11.95
Mixed Greens with Feta Cheese, Olives, Red Onions, Cucumber, and balsamic vinaigrette in a Plain Wrap
W9. Motor Parkway US$11.95
Cracked Pepper Turkey with Swiss Cheese, Mixed Greens, Tomato, and honey mustard in a Plain Wrap
W10. The Vanderbilt US$11.95
Honey Maple Turkey with Mixed Greens, Red Onion, Tomato, Bleu Cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette in a Plain Wrap
W11. The Hamlet US$11.95
Turkey with Mixed Greens, Tomato, Red Onion, and sweet honey mustard in a Plain Wrap
W12. Half Hollow US$11.95
Oven-Gold Turkey with Swiss cheese, Bacon, Mixed Greens, Tomato, and russian dressing in a Whole Wheat Wrap
W13. The Dix Hills US$11.95
Grilled Chicken, Mixed Greens & Caesar dressing in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Signature Panini
Panini US$12.47
P1. Commack US$12.47
FRESH MOZZARELLA, TOMATO, FIRE ROASTED PEPPERS, FRESH BASIL & BALSAMIC VINEGAR
P2. Sawmill US$12.47
GRILLED CHICKEN, FRESH MOZZARELLA, SUNDRIED TOMATOES & PESTO ON RUSTIC ROSEMARY PANINI BREAD
P3. Kicking Turkey US$12.47
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, TOMATO & FIERY CHIPOTLE GOURMAISE ON EUROPEAN FLAT BREAD
P4. Veggie US$12.47
BALSAMIC GRILLED VEGETABLES & FRESH MOZZARELLA ON EUROPEAN WHOLE WHEAT FLAT BREAD
P5. Indian Hollow US$12.47
MAPLE HONEY TURKEY, BACON, MELTED CHEDDAR, TOMATO & HONEY MUSTARD ON EUROPEAN WHOLE WHEAT FLAT BREAD
P6. Couger US$12.47
CHICKEN CUTLET, BACON, MELTED MOZZARELLA, TOMATO & PESTO MAYO ON GARLICPARMESAN PANINI BREAD
P7. Rolling Hills US$12.47
OVENGOLD TURKEY, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO & PESTO MAYO ON EUROPEAN FLAT BREAD
P8. Wood Park US$12.47
CHICKEN CUTLET, BACON, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE & RUSSIAN DRESSING ON GARLIC EUROPEAN FLAT BREAD
P10. Burr Lane US$12.47
SEASONED ROASTED BEEF, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS & HORSERADISH SAUCE ON RUSTIC ONION PANINI BREAD
P9. North Ridge US$12.47
FRIED EGGPLANT, FRESH MOZZARELLA, ROASTED PEPPERS & BALSAMIC VINEGAR ON GARLIC PARMESAN PANINI BREAD

Signature Hero
Signature Burrito Wrap US$11.95
Chicken Quesadilla US$11.43
Grilled chicken, mozzarella cheese, avocado ,and mayo
Meat Quesadilla US$11.43
Cheese Quesadilla US$10.39
Made With Cheddar Cheese

Protein Bowls
Protein Bowl US$13.51
base: quinoa & kale blend, brown rice, or white riceprotein: marinated grilled chicken, cajun spiced chicken, marinated flank steak, or grilled vegetablestoppings: pico de gallo, corn salsa, sweet potatoes, black beans, homemade onion rings, cucumbers, jalapenos, banana peppers, tortilla chips, 3-cheese blend, avocadosauce: pesto, hot sauce

Salad Bar
Tossed Salad
Romaine, carrots, cucumbers, black olives and tomatoes.
Gorgonberry Salad US$16.63
Grilled Chicken, Mixed Baby Greens, Gorgonzola Cheese, Walnuts, Dried Cranberries served with Raspberry Vinaigrette
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad US$16.63
Classic Caesar Salad with Marinated Grilled Chicken
Southwestern Chicken Salad US$16.63
Cajun Spiced Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Corn, Tomato, Black Olives, Crunchy Tortilla Strips served with ranch dressing
Chef's Salad US$19.75
Romaine Lettuce, Turkey, Ham, Swiss Cheese, American Cheese, Tomato, Cucumbers, Onions, with Sliced Hardboiled Eggs

Bakery
Muffin US$4.15
Muffin With Butter US$4.68
Cherry Turnover US$4.15
Blueberry Turnover US$4.15
Homemade Cookie US$4.15
Mini Cookies US$1.55
Brownie/Crumb Cake US$4.67
Croissant US$4.15
Mini Black & White Cookies US$2.70
Holiday Cupcake US$4.15
Pound Cake Tradition/ Double Chocolate US$4.15
Cupcake US$4.67
Fresh Pastry US$5.19
BJ Pistachio Chocolate US$13.51

Gourmet Italian Sandwiches
Panini - Gourmet Sandwich US$12.47

Soups
Clam Chowder Soup
Chicken Noodle Soup
*served daily*

Special Deal
Peppers, Onions, Spinach US$11.43
3 Eggs Whites US$11.43

Classic Sandwiches
served with a side of potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, cucumber salad, or a pickletoppings:lettuce | tomato | onion | cucumbers | banana peppers | roasted red pepper | jalapenos | crispy bacon | black olives | pickles | avocado cheese:american | cheddar | mozzarella | provolone | pepperjack | swiss | muensterbread:kaiser roll | seedless roll | wrap (plain, whole wheat, spinach) | bagel | flagel | croissant | hero | panini | toast (white, rye, whole wheat)
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich
BLT Chicken Salad Sandwich
BLT Sandwich
Bologna Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Breaded Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Buffalo Chicken Breast Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Buffalo Chicken Salad Sandwich
Deluxe Ham Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Cracked Pepper Turkey Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
EverRoast Chicken Breast Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Genoa Salami Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Sandwich US$7.99
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Honey Mustard Chicken Salad
Liverwurst Sandwich
Nova Lox Sandwich
*capers available*
Ovengold Turkey Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Pastrami Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Roast Beef Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Salsalito Turkey Sandwich
Boar's Head cold cuts and more! Served with a free side salad!
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Veggie Tuna Salad Sandwich
Whitefish Salad Sandwich

Gourmet Wraps
served with a side of potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, cucumber salad, or a pickle
W1 - Veggie Tuna Wrap
Vegetable Tuna Salad with Roasted Peppers and Lettuce in a Plain Wrap
W2 - Southwestern Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & chipotle mayo in a Plain Wrap
W3 - Steakhouse Wrap
Seasoned Roast Beef with Caramelized Onion, Crumbled Bleu Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, and horseradish dressing in a Plain Wrap
W4 - Main Street Wrap
Grilled Balsamic Vegetables with Fresh Mozzarella, Mixed Baby Greens, and a drizzle of balsamic vinaigrette in a Plain Wrap
W5 - The North Shore Wrap
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad with Lettuce and Tomato in a Whole Wheat Wrap
W6 - Southbeach Wrap
Roast Turkey with Bacon, Tomato, Cucumber, and mayo in an Iceberg Lettuce Wrap
W7 - Smithtown Wrap
Honey Chicken Salad with Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato in a Whole Wheat Wrap
W8 - Commack Slim
Mixed Greens with Feta Cheese, Olives, Red Onions, Cucumber, and balsamic vinaigrette in a Plain Wrap
W9 - Motor Pkwy
Cracked Pepper Turkey with Swiss Cheese, Mixed Greens, Tomato, and honey mustard in a Plain Wrap
W10 - The Vanderbilt
Honey Maple Turkey with Mixed Greens, Red Onion, Tomato, Bleu Cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette in a Plain Wrap
W11 - The Hamlet
Turkey with Mixed Greens, Tomato, Red Onion, and sweet honey mustard in a Plain Wrap
W12 - Half Hollow Wrap
Oven-Gold Turkey with Swiss cheese, Bacon, Mixed Greens, Tomato, and russian dressing in a Whole Wheat Wrap
W13 - The Dix Hills
Grilled Chicken, Mixed Greens & Caesar dressing in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Paninis
served with a side of potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, cucumber salad, or a pickle
P1 - The Commack
FRESH MOZZARELLA, TOMATO, FIRE ROASTED PEPPERS, FRESH BASIL & BALSAMIC VINEGAR
P2 - The Sawmill
GRILLED CHICKEN, FRESH MOZZARELLA, SUNDRIED TOMATOES & PESTO ON RUSTIC ROSEMARY PANINI BREAD
P3 - The Kicking Turkey
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, TOMATO & FIERY CHIPOTLE GOURMAISE ON EUROPEAN FLAT BREAD
P4 - The Veggie Panini
BALSAMIC GRILLED VEGETABLES & FRESH MOZZARELLA ON EUROPEAN WHOLE WHEAT FLAT BREAD
P5 - The Indian Hollow
MAPLE HONEY TURKEY, BACON, MELTED CHEDDAR, TOMATO & HONEY MUSTARD ON EUROPEAN WHOLE WHEAT FLAT BREAD
P6 - The Cougar Panini
CHICKEN CUTLET, BACON, MELTED MOZZARELLA, TOMATO & PESTO MAYO ON GARLICPARMESAN PANINI BREAD
P7 - Rolling Hills
OVENGOLD TURKEY, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO & PESTO MAYO ON EUROPEAN FLAT BREAD
P8 - Wood Park
CHICKEN CUTLET, BACON, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE & RUSSIAN DRESSING ON GARLIC EUROPEAN FLAT BREAD
P9 - North Ridge
FRIED EGGPLANT, FRESH MOZZARELLA, ROASTED PEPPERS & BALSAMIC VINEGAR ON GARLICPARMESAN PANINI BREAD
P10 - The Burr Lane Panini
SEASONED ROASTED BEEF, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS & HORSERADISH SAUCE ON RUSTIC ONION PANINI BREAD

Signature Sandwiches
served with a side of potato salad, macaroni salad, cole slaw, cucumber salad, or a pickle
S1 - The Banana Chicken
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, mayo, and balsamic vinegar on a Garlic Hero
S2 - The B.B.C. Sub
Cracked Pepper Turkey, Crispy Bacon, Melted Muenster Cheese, Cole Slaw, and Russian dressing on a Hero
S3 - Roast Turkey Breast
With crisp bacon, sundried tomato and pesto mayo on an onion roll.
S4 - The Commack High
Honey Maple Turkey, Melted Mozzarella, Crispy Bacon, Tomato, and sweet honey mustard on a Hero
S5 - Our Famous Honey Chicken Salad
Honey Chicken Salad with Crispy Bacon, Tomato, and Lettuce on Whole Wheat Toast
S6 - The Candlewood
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Bacon, Melted American, Lettuce, and Russian dressing on a Roll
S7 - Death Wish
Roast Beef with Melted Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, and Russian dressing on a Garlic Hero
S8 - Predator
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Bacon, Melted Mozzarella, and Russian dressing on a Garlic Hero
S9 - Italian Hero
Capicola Ham, Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone, Lettuce, Onion, and oil & vinegar on a Hero
S10 - The Cracked Turkey
Cracked Pepper Turkey with Melted Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, and pesto mayo on a Garlic Hero
S11 - The Bob-O
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, and balsamic vinaigrette on a Grilled Garlic Hero
S12 - The Thunderbird
Salsalito Turkey with Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Tomato, Banana Peppers with mayo on a Grilled Hero

Coffee Bar
Hot Coffee
SMALL $2.99, MEDIUM $3.49, LARGE $3.99
Iced Coffee
Small or Large
Hot Chocolate
Small, Medium, Large
Hot Tea
liptongreen tea (decaf available)chamomilepeppermintearl greySMALL $2.99, MEDIUM $3.49, LARGE $3.99
Iced Tea
Sweetened or UnsweetenedSmall or Large

Desserts
~ Homemade desserts and more ~
Black & White Cookie
Brownie Bites
*includes whipped cream*
Cheese Danish
Croissant
Crumb Cakes
PlainBlueberryCherryapple
Fresh Brownie Slice
Fruit Salad Cup
Muffins
Banana Chocolate ChipBanana NutBerry BlastBlueberryBlueberry CrumbCarrot Cream CheeseChocolate ChipCoffee CakeCorn Double Chocolate ChipFrench ToastPistachio NutRed Velvet
Pound Cake
plainblueberrymarble
Rice Pudding
Turnovers
Apple BlueberryCherry
Yogurt & Granola Parfait
Vanilla or Strawberry*includes blueberries*

Breakfast
Assorted Breakfast Basket
A Beautiful display of Freshly Baked Muffins, Bagels, Danish & Croissants Garnished with Fresh Fruit. Accompanied by Cream Cheese, Butter & Preserves.Per Person.
Assorted Bagel/Flagel Basket
An Assortment of our delicious hand rolled Bagels, Flagels and Bialys displayed on a platter with a fresh fruit garnish. Served with an assortment of flavored cream cheese, regular cream cheese, butter & preserves. Per Person.
Breakfast Party Heros
Bacon, Egg & Cheese - Sausage Egg & Cheese - or Ham Egg &Cheese the Traditional long hero done breakfast style. Eggs, cheese and your choice of bacon, ham or sausage Per Foot (additional price per foot for egg whites) Available 3 ft - 6 ft ( feeds approximately 3 people per foot )Egg Whites with Turkey, Spinach and Swiss Per Foot Available 3 ft - 6 ft ( feeds approximately 3 people per foot )Southwest Style Eggs with or without Bacon Eggs with ham, peppers and onions Per Foot (additional price per foot for egg whites)Available 3 ft - 6 ft ( feeds approximately 3 people per foot )
Breakfast By The Tray-Ala Carte
Eggs: 1/2 Tray - Full Tray Southwest Style Eggs: 1/2 Tray - Full TrayBacon or Sausage: 1/2 Tray - Full Tray French Toast: 1/2 Tray - Full Tray Pancakes: 1/2 Tray - Full Tray Home Fries: 1/2 Tray - Full Tray

Breakfast Packages
Continental Breakfast Buffet
Our Fabulous Assortment of Bagels, Muffins, Danish & Croissants.Orange Juice & Freshly Brewed Coffee.Per Person (10 Person Minimum)Add fruit Salad for additional price Per Person.
Hot Breakfast Buffet
Scrambled Eggs, French Toast, Bacon Strips, Sausage Patties, Home Fries, Orange Juice and Freshly Brewed Coffee.Per Person (20 Person Minimum)Add Rolls for additional price Per PersonAdd Fruit Salad for additional price Per Person

Fresh Fruit
Sliced Fruit Platter
A Beautiful Presentation of Sliced Fresh Fruit with Decorative Garnish.Per Person.

Sandwich Platters
Assorted Gourmet Sandwich Platter
An assortment of our gourmet sandwiches on our Specialty Breads-French Baguettes, Focaccia, Ciabatta, Wraps and more!\Per Person ala carte.With potato, macaroni salad or cole slaw for additional price Per PersonWith Pasta Salad or Green Salad for additional price
Petite Sandwiches
An arrangement of sandwiches done on an assortment of small rolls. The sandwiches consist of turkey, roast beef, ham, tuna and chicken salad together with lettuce & tomato. Small and easy to handle.per person ala carte.With potato, macaroni salad or cole slaw for additional priceWith Pasta Salad or Green Salad for additional price
Hot Italian Sandwiches- Chaffing racks supplied
Eggplant Parmigiana, Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana and Meatball Parmigiana.Served with a Caesar Salad- Accompanied by Grated Parmesan Cheese, Crushed Red Pepper & Marinara Sauce.Per Person (10 Person Minimum)
Assorted Panini Sandwiches
A mouth watering selection of our own Hand Pressed Panini Sandwiches. Each one cooked to perfection.per person ala carte.With potato, macaroni salad or cole slaw for additional priceWith Pasta Salad or Green Salad for additional price
Bagel Sandwich Platter
A Mix of Cold Cuts and our Homemade tuna salad, chicken salad, cranberry walnut chicken salad and egg salad on our awesome hand rolled bagels.per person ala carte.With potato, macaroni salad or cole slaw for additional priceWith Pasta Salad or Green Salad for additional price
Mini Bagel Sandwich Platter
A Mix of Cold Cuts and our Homemade tuna salad, chicken salad, cranberry walnut chicken salad and egg- (2 sandwiches per person)per person ala carte.With potato, macaroni salad or cole slaw for additional priceWith Pasta Salad or Green Salad for additional price

Party Heros
available 3ft, 4 ft, 5 ft, and 6 ft
Italian US$17.99
Ham cappicola, genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion.
American US$17.99
Roast beef, roast turkey, ham, american cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Boone US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Bacon, American Cheese, Lettuce and Russian Dressing.
Turkey BLT US$24.99
Roast turkey with crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato and Russian Dressing.
Ward Melville US$24.99
Honey Turkey, Fresh Mozzarella Cheese, Crispy Bacon, Sliced Tomato and Sweet Honey Mustard Dressing.
The Sound US$24.99
Cracked Pepper Turkey with Swiss Cheese, Sliced Cucumber, Crisp Lettuce and Ranch Dressing.
The Long Island Sub US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Breaded Eggplant, Roasted Red Peppers, Provolone Cheese, Romaine Lettuce and Sliced Ripe Tomato.
RB Deluxe US$24.99
Seasoned Roast Beef with Onion Rings, Lettuce, Tomato and our Special Spicy Mayo.
Pirates Cove US$24.99
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, sliced avocado lettuce, tomato & pesto mayo.
Main Street US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Pepper, Leaf Lettuce and Balsamic Vinaigrette.
Grilled Vegetable US$24.99
Eggplant, zucchini, squash, onions, red & green peppers, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese and Balsamic Vinaigrette.
Death Wish US$24.99
Roast Beef with Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Russian Dressing.
Chipotle Chicken US$24.99
Chipotle Chicken Breast with Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo.
Southwestern US$24.99
Marinated Grilled Chicken with Pepper Jack Cheese, Crisp Lettuce, Tomato and Chipotle Mayo.
Northshore Style US$24.99
Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Roasted Peppers, and Vinaigrette.

Warm Party Heros
available 3ft, 4ft, 5ft and 6ft
THE LANDSCAPER US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with melted American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Jalapeno Peppers and Mayonnaise on a Hero.
STEAK US$27.99
Grilled Flank Steak with Fresh Mozzarella, Lettuce and Tomato on a hero.
SAUSAGE & PEPPERS US$24.99
Our homemade Italian Sausage with Red & Green Peppers, SautA(c)ed Onion and Our Marinara Sauce on a hero.
REUBEN US$24.99
Pastrami with Melted Swiss and Cole Slaw with Russian Dressing on a Hero.
MEATBALL PARM US$24.99
Homemade Meatballs with Melted Mozzarella Cheese and topped with our Marinara Sauce on a hero.
FRIED EGGPLANT US$24.99
With Melted Mozzarella & Roasted Red Peppers on a hero. Served with Balsamic Vinaigrette.
EGGPLANT PARM US$24.99
Lightly Fried Eggplant topped with Melted Mozzarella Cheese topped with our Marinara Sauce on a hero.
CRAVIN' THANKSGIVING US$24.99
Fresh Turkey with Cranberry Sauce and Homemade Stuffing on a A Hero.
CHICKEN PARM US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Melted Mozzarella Cheese topped with our Marinara Sauce on a hero.
BANANA CHICKEN US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Melted Mozzarella Cheese, Sweet & Spicy Banana Peppers, Mayo and Balsamic Vinegar on a Hero.
FIRE ISLAND US$24.99
Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Crumbled Blue Cheese and shredded lettuce on a hero.
SG SUB US$24.99
Cracked Pepper Turkey with Crispy Bacon, Melted Muenster, Coleslaw and Russian Dressing on a hero.

Holiday Party Heroes
Birthday Fun (feeds 15-18)
A fun party hero done in the number of your child's birthday (choose any number 1 aEU 9). Made Your choice Italian or American.Served with Potato Salad and Macaroni Salad and a platter of Black & White Cookies. PackageAdd our kettle of our Chicken Noodle Soup for an additional price

Pasta Salads
Penne Pasta
With breaded chicken cutlet in a honey mustard dressing.
Pasta Primavera
Pasta tossed fresh mixed vegetables.
Pasta Pesto
With sun dried tomatoes & fresh parmesan cheese.
Bowtie Pasta
With fresh mozzarella and sun dried tomatoes.

Misc. Salads
Traditional Potato Salad
Traditional Cole Slaw

Green Salads
Tossed Salad
Romaine, carrots, cucumbers, black olives and tomatoes.
Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, feta cheese, tomato, black olives, red onion, red & green peppers.
Gorgonberry Salad
Grilled Chicken, Mixed Baby Greens, Gorgonzola Cheese, Walnuts, Dried Cranberries served with Raspberry Vinaigrette
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken
Romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese & grilled chicken.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, herb croutons & parmesan cheese.

Hot Hors d'ouvres
Half Tray / Full Tray
Hot Antipasto
(Full Tray Only)
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Wings
Buffalo | BBQ | Honey Mustard Boneless
Meatballs - Swedish
Mozzarella Sticks
Pigs in a Blanket
Miniature Potato Knish
Pulled Pork

Chicken Breast Dishes
Half Tray / Full Tray
Chicken Almondine
Chicken Bruschetta
Chicken Cacciatore
Chicken Florentine
Chicken Francese
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Piccata
Chicken Teriyaki
Chicken Sorrentino
Chicken Stir Fry
Coconut Chicken
Hawaiian Chicken
Sesame Chicken
Grilled Pesto Chicken
Chicken Balsamico
Blackened Cajun Chicken

Bagel Basket Cafe Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping
Takeaway
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Toilet

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot

Bagel Basket Cafe Photos

Bagel Basket Cafe Location

Bagel Basket Cafe

New York Suffolk County Commack Commack Road

639 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725, USA

Bagel Basket Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4 from 302 user reviews.

pricecream cheesesaladlunchdeliveryegg sandwichorderbaconareapanini

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I have nothing but great things to say about the Bagel Basket. I have been coming here for years and found that the owner and his employees are extremely kind, thoughtful, and friendly. Their food is always fresh and delicious. The prices are also very reasonable.I highly recommend if you’re in the area and want something delicious stop in. You definitely want be disappointed.
July 10 · Robert hampp
This is the first time I’ve ever done a review, simply because of how unbelievably rude the business was. They deliberately toasted the bagel to the point it was burnt to a crisp. Why would they ever give me a burnt bagel to eat? And if they made a mistake, they should have apologized, but the worker didn’t, just because he wasn’t the one that toasted the bagel.
March 23 · sue
Want a quick bagel breakfast that is also VERY GOOD, stop in here. Everything is good and the service is great. Tell your friends, because in this area it doesn’t get any better than this!
July 12 · Marc LeVine
Made this my go to place, come here every Sunday morning and other days. Up until recently I started getting treated like a back of the line customer for some reason even though I usually tip well. Most recently i got 3 of the same sandwiches and one was completely skimped out and i was told that the rest of the sandwich was on the other side of the bagel which it wasn’t. I guess its time to find a new bagels spot in the morning it was good wile it lasted 🤣
July 04 · Brian McCort
I expected better bagels based on the packed parking lot, but they weren't hot or fresh. Better bagels around the corner. If you're from the area, you know the other place.
June 03 · Bruce Fint