Buttercup BakeShop: A Sweet Treat Destination in Midtown East, NYC

Buttercup BakeShop Introduce

In the bustling heart of Midtown East, where the city’s energy is at its peak, finding a sweet escape can feel like a small victory. Buttercup BakeShop, located on 2nd Avenue, is a delightful destination that offers a moment of indulgence in a fast-paced world. While the name suggests a focus on baking, the establishment serves as a perfect spot for those seeking a sweet treat paired with a coffee, making it an ideal coffee shop alternative for locals. This article is designed to provide a clear, engaging, and informative overview of Buttercup BakeShop, helping New Yorkers learn more about what makes this place so special. Based on genuine customer reviews and publicly available information, we will explore the dedication to quality, the wide variety of offerings, and the features that have earned them a loyal following. The information presented is factual and aims to give you a comprehensive understanding of why Buttercup BakeShop is a cherished part of the Midtown East community.

For many New Yorkers, a craving for something sweet is a common occurrence, whether it's for a midday treat, a late-night snack, or a special celebration. Buttercup BakeShop caters to all these needs with its impressive selection and commitment to deliciousness. The customer reviews, which praise the "good cupcakes," "rich frosting," and "lots of selection," paint a picture of a business that truly understands its craft. This guide is crafted to be a valuable resource for anyone in the New York region looking for a top-tier dessert experience. We will delve into their specific offerings, the quality of their products, and the kind of service that has made them a local favorite. The tone is friendly and professional, mirroring the welcoming and wonderful staff that customers have reported. It is our goal to provide a trustworthy and pleasant read that captures the true essence of Buttercup BakeShop.

Buttercup BakeShop is conveniently located at 973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA. This address places it in the vibrant Midtown East neighborhood, a hub for professionals, residents, and visitors alike. Its location on 2nd Avenue, a major thoroughfare, makes it highly accessible for those traveling by foot or public transportation. The area is well-served by New York City's extensive bus network and is within a reasonable distance of several subway stations, ensuring that customers from across Manhattan can easily reach the shop. The fact that the bakery is a perfect spot for "late night snacks" also highlights its convenient hours, which extend until 10 pm on most nights and 11 pm on Fridays. This accessibility, combined with its prime location, makes Buttercup BakeShop a practical and convenient destination for a quick treat or a planned dessert run. The shop’s presence in such a high-energy part of the city reinforces its role as a go-to spot for busy New Yorkers.

The accessibility of this Midtown East location is a major benefit for customers who rely on Buttercup BakeShop for their sweet cravings. Its presence on a main street means it's easily found and remembered, a key factor for a successful business in New York. The welcoming atmosphere and convenient hours also make it a reliable spot for a post-dinner dessert or a treat on the way home from work. In a city that never sleeps, having a quality bake shop that stays open late is a significant advantage. The location on 2nd Avenue is a testament to the business's commitment to being a convenient and accessible resource for the community it serves. The simple and clear address, 973 2nd Ave, makes it a hassle-free point of contact for anyone looking to satisfy their sweet tooth.

Buttercup BakeShop offers a wide array of services and products that extend beyond just cupcakes. Based on customer reviews and public data, their offerings include:

A large selection of "good cupcakes" with "rich frosting."
Various other baked goods, including cakes, cookies, and dessert bars like the lemon bar.
Late-night snack options, as noted by a customer who appreciated the convenience.
The option for custom orders and special requests, as they provide an extensive menu of layered cakes, cheesecakes, and puddings.
A wide variety of "premium" and "traditional" cupcakes, with flavors like red velvet, lemon, salted caramel, and more.
The sale of individual items and platters for catering, including assortments of mini cupcakes, bars, and cookies.

This comprehensive menu demonstrates that Buttercup BakeShop is a full-service dessert destination, not just a cupcake shop. While one customer noted that a specific lemon bar "did not taste very lemony," the overall feedback on the quality and richness of the products is overwhelmingly positive. The wide variety of offerings ensures that there is something for every taste and occasion, from a simple cupcake to a large platter for an event. The availability of late-night snacks is a key service that caters to the New York lifestyle, making it a convenient stop for a post-dinner treat.

Based on the provided customer reviews and available information, Buttercup BakeShop has several key features and highlights that make it a favorite in the community.

Exceptional Staff and Service: Customers specifically mentioned the staff as "wonderful" and "the ladies offered suggestions," highlighting a positive and welcoming customer experience.
High-Quality Cupcakes: The cupcakes are consistently praised for being "good" and having "rich frosting," which is a crucial highlight for a bake shop.
Wide Variety and Selection: The shop offers "lots to choose from," from cupcakes to cakes, bars, and puddings, ensuring there is a treat for every preference.
Reasonable Pricing: One customer noted the "really good prices," a significant highlight in a city with many expensive dessert options.
Convenient for Late-Night Cravings: The shop's late hours make it an ideal spot for those looking for a dessert after a late dinner or evening out.

These highlights collectively paint a picture of a business that is not only dedicated to its product but also to its customer experience. The combination of high-quality, delicious baked goods, friendly service, and a wide variety of options makes it an attractive and reliable destination. The fact that the staff is praised for being "wonderful" and offering suggestions creates a personalized experience that goes beyond a simple transaction. The positive feedback on the prices also makes it an accessible option for a broad range of customers, solidifying its place as a true local favorite.

For those looking to get in touch with Buttercup BakeShop, the contact information is as follows:

Address: 973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

Phone: (212) 350-4144

The availability of a direct phone number makes it easy for customers to inquire about their menu, place custom orders, or ask about catering services. This clear and accessible contact information reinforces the bakery’s professionalism and commitment to open communication.

In conclusion, Buttercup BakeShop is a perfect choice for locals in the Midtown East area, offering a delightful and convenient escape for anyone with a sweet tooth. Its strategic location on 2nd Avenue, coupled with its wonderful staff and wide selection of high-quality baked goods, makes it a reliable and beloved destination. The consistently positive feedback on the deliciousness of their cupcakes, the variety of their menu, and their reasonable prices highlights a business that is truly dedicated to customer satisfaction. For any New Yorker seeking a tasty treat, a late-night snack, or a custom cake for a special occasion, Buttercup BakeShop is an ideal spot. It embodies the best of what a neighborhood bakery can be: a place of sweet indulgence, friendly faces, and consistently delicious products that make life a little sweeter.

Buttercup BakeShop Menu

Main Menu
1 Dzn Bar And Cookie Platter ** US$39.00
A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter. Please specify if you would like this assortment to be NUT-FREE!!
1 Dzn Bar Platter - Assorted US$54.00
Assorted mix of 12 bars. Will include flavors that include nuts unless requested otherwise!!
Lemon Vanilla Bundt Cake
A fresh lemon zesty cake and a vanilla glaze.
Cinnamon Maple Bundt Cake
A moist, rich cinnamon maple bundt cake with cinnamon glaze on top!
1 Dzn Cookie Platter*** US$32.50
A dozen of our house special cookies in a platter!
1 Dozen Premium Cupcakes Full Size US$47.00
A dozen of our top flavor cupcakes of the day. Please specify if you would like these to be nut-free!
1 Dozen Traditional Assortment NUTFREE Full Size US$45.00
A dozen traditional cupcakes, free of nut.
1 Dozen Mini Cupcakes NUTFREE MINIS US$20.00
A nut free assortment of mini cupcakes.
1 Dozen Premium Mini Cupcakes Nut-Free MINIS US$24.00
A dozen of our top flavors in mini. A dozen of our top flavors in mini. (coconut, chocolate espresso, salted caramel, lemon raspberry, red velvet, chocolate raspberry, lemon)

Brownies, Bars, and Squares
1 Dzn Bar And Cookie Platter ** US$39.00
A platter of 6 of our favorite bars and 6 of our favorite cookies. All in one platter. Please specify if you would like this assortment to be NUT-FREE!!
Lemon Tart Squares** US$4.75
Our tart lemon squares topped with fine powdered sugar on a soft flaky crust. A topseller.
S'mores Campfire Bar*** US$5.50
Our top selling bar: Graham cracker crust, marshmallows, rich ganache, topped with torched meringue and chocolate fudge drizzle. Messy, but yummy.
Gooey Choc Chip Bar US$4.00
A lovely chewy bar mixed with brown sugar and packed with chocolate chips.
Magic Coconut Bar US$4.25
Shredded coconut, walnuts and chocolate chips caramelized in layers in a graham cracker crust.
Fudge Brownie US$3.99
Rich and moist fudge brownies each infused with a hint of creamy dark chocolate.
Peanut Butter Jelly Bar*** US$4.50
Top Seller: The classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich with a twist. Grape jelly sandwiched between two layers of peanut butter cookie dough. Sprinkled with salty roasted peanuts.
Pecan Pie Bars US$5.50
A rich square slice of Pecan pie in a bar!
Butter Cake Bar * New Bar Alert! * US$4.00
Golden butter cake crust topped with gooey butter cake filling.
Cherry Cheesecake Brownie US$4.50
Fudge brownie base, cherry cheesecake filling on top
1 Dzn Bar Platter - Assorted US$54.00
Assorted mix of 12 bars. Will include flavors that include nuts unless requested otherwise!!
Peanut Butter Bar *New Item!!* US$4.50
Delicious and rich Peanut Butter Bar with peanut butter chips!
Brookie *New* US$4.75
A blend of your favorite Ooey Gooey Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar and Fudge Brownie!
Chocolate Butter Cake Bar US$4.50

Bundt Cakes
Cinnamon Maple Bundt Cake
A moist, rich cinnamon maple bundt cake with cinnamon glaze on top!
Tres Leches Square US$7.50
"Tom Cruise's" White Chocolate Coconut Bundt US$5.50
A replica of that Mission Impossible guy's famously gifted dessert.

Cakes by the Slice
Buttercup Golden (Vanilla) With Chocolate Buttercream SLICE US$7.00
Classic Chocolate Cake With Chocolate Buttercream SLICE US$7.00
Lemon/Lemon Slice US$7.50
Coconut Meringue Slice US$7.25
Mochaccino Slice US$7.50
Carrot Cake Slice US$7.50
Red Velvet Slice US$7.50
Vanilla Cake Vanilla Buttercream Slice US$7.00
Vanilla Cake with Rich Vanilla Buttercream.
Chocolate Cake With Vanilla Buttercream Slice US$7.00
Ube Cake With Rich Ube Frosting Slice US$7.50
Salted Caramel Dulce-De-Leche SLICE US$7.25
Tres Leches Cubes US$7.50
Rainbow Cookie Cake Slice US$10.00
CONTAINS ALMOND FLOUR + ALMOND PASTE! Our version of a rainbow cookie in the best form it could take - a cake. Enjoy a slice, it won't last long. ;)

Whole Cakes
9"2-Layer Buttercup Golden Vanilla Cake With Vanilla Icing Cake US$45.00
Our vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream. The vanilla buttercream is dyed a pastel yellow, this cannot be changed! (Feeds 10-15)
7"2-Layer Buttercup Golden Vanilla Cake With Vanilla Icing Cake US$55.00
Our vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream. The vanilla buttercream is dyed a pastel yellow, this cannot be changed! (Feeds 4-6)
9"2-Layer Buttercup Golden Vanilla Cake With Chocolate Icing Cake
Our vanilla cake with a semi-sweet chocolate buttercream. (Feeds 10-15)
7"2-Layer Buttercup Golden Vanilla Cake With Chocolate Icing Cake
Our vanilla cake with a semi-sweet chocolate buttercream. (Feeds 4-6)
9"2-Layer Classic Chocolate Cake With Chocolate Icing US$55.00
Classic chocolate cake with a semi-sweet chocolate buttercream. (Feeds 10-15)
7"2-Layer Classic Chocolate Cake With Chocolate Icing US$45.00
Classic chocolate cake with a semi-sweet chocolate buttercream. (Feeds 4-6)
9"2-Layer Classic Chocolate Cake With Vanilla Icing US$55.00
Classic chocolate cake with a white vanilla buttercream. The color for the buttercream cannot be changed. (Feeds 10-15)
7"2-Layer Classic Chocolate Cake With Vanilla Icing US$45.00
Classic chocolate cake with a white vanilla buttercream. The color for the buttercream cannot be changed. (Feeds 4-6)
9"3-Layer Carrot Cake (CONTAINS NUTS) US$68.00
Made with fresh carrots, apples, and pecans, frosted with cream cheese frosting (iced in between layers and on top). (Feeds 15-20)
9"3-Layer Red Velvet Cake US$68.00
Yellow cake with a hint of cocoa, dyed a deep beautiful red (tastes like a light chocolate cake). Frosted with cream cheese frosting between layers and on top. (Feeds 15-20)
7"3-Layer Red Velvet Cake US$48.00
Yellow cake with a hint of cocoa, dyed a deep beautiful red (tastes like a light chocolate cake). Frosted with cream cheese frosting between layers and on top. (Feeds 6-8)
9"3-Layer Lemony Lemon Cake US$68.00
A lemony cake with fresh lemon zest, and lemon buttercream. (Feeds 15-20)
9" 2-Layer Salted Caramel Dulce-De-Leche Cake US$55.00
Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt). (Feeds 15-20)
9"3-Layer Ube Cake *Filipino Yam* US$68.00
A light, filipino purple yam cake. Iced with an Ube flavored cream cheese frosting. (Feeds 15-20)

Notecard
Notecard Custom US$2.50
Add your own personalized message

Cookies
Bestest Oatmeal Cinnamon Chocolate Cookie US$2.70
Oatmeal cinnamon cookie loaded with chocolate chips.
Chocolate Chip Cookie US$2.70
A traditional style chocolate chip cookie. Soft but has a slight crunch.
Salted Caramel Chunk Cookie US$2.50
Soft and chewy cookie with gooey caramel bits and chocolate chunks topped with sea salt.
Snikerdoodle Cookie US$2.50
Cinnamon snickerdoodle cookie. No worries, it's soft.
1 Dzn Cookie Platter*** US$32.50
A dozen of our house special cookies in a platter!
Cup'o'Cookies US$5.00
A cup of mini chocolate chip crispy cookies.
Raspberry Thumbprints US$1.50
Buttery cookies with a raspberry dollop

Cupcakes
Apple Pie A La Mode *** US$4.25
Caramelized apple cinnamon struessel cake topped with a ice-cream scoop style vanilla buttercream.
FUNFETTI Birthday Cupcakes US$4.25
Our Vanilla Cake with Funfetti Rainbow Sprinkles throught. Comes only in white vanilla buttercream.
Buttercup Golden Vanilla Cupcake With Vanilla Icing. US$3.99
Fluffy vanilla cake with vanilla buttercream.
Buttercup Golden Vanilla Cupcake With Chocolate Icing US$3.99
Fluffy vanilla cake with a semi-sweet chocolate buttercream.
Classic Chocolate Cupcake With Vanilla Icing US$3.99
Semi-sweet chocolate cake with vanilla buttercream.
Classic Chocolate Cupcake With Chocolate Icing US$3.99
Semi-sweet chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream.
Red Velvet Cupcake US$3.99
Buttery cake with a hint of cocoa topped with cream cheese frosting.
Lemony Lemon Cupcake US$3.99
Light and lemony cake with zesty lemon buttercream.
Chunky Monkey Cupcake US$4.25
Banana cake filled with chocolate chips and chocolate buttercream.
Chocolate Lover's Mix Cupcakes US$42.00
A dozen of our top chocolate cupcake flavors. Contains nuts.
Hummingbird Cupcake US$4.25
Banana pineapple cake with cream cheese frosting and chopped pecans.
Devil Dog Cupcake US$3.99
Rich chocolate cake with a whipped meringue frosting and chocolate drizzle.
Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcake US$4.25
Dark choc cake filled with peanut butter icing with Reese's PB cups inside batter. For all you peanut butter freaks out there.
Espresso Shot Cupcake US$4.25
Dark choc cake with a nescafe espresso coffee buttercream. Just don't try to eat one and fall asleep. Not happening.
Lemon Raspberry Torched Meringue US$4.25
A light lemony cupcake with fresh raspberry jam filling and a whipped torched meringue frosting.
Oreo Cookies 'N Cream Cupcakes US$4.25
Vanilla cake stuffed with a whole Oreo (yes a whole one) topped with an Oreo crumb buttercream.
S'mores Cupcake US$4.25
Dark choc cake torched meringue, topped with toasted marshmallow, and don’t forget the graham cracker crust. Definitely addicting
Salted Caramel Dulce De Leche Cupcake US$4.25
Dulce de Leche cake with Swirls of salted caramel buttercream (sea salt). Sweet and salty, like a typical NY'ker.
Spiced Carrot Cupcake US$4.25
Carrot cake with apples & walnuts topped with a spiced cream cheese. Definitely a top favorite.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cupcake US$4.25
Vanilla cake with a chocolate chip cookie inside topped with cookie dough molasses buttercream + cookie dough topping.
Twinkie US$3.99
Vanilla cake with light whipped meringue interior and topping. Like a classic Twinky (minus the 37 ingredients)
UBE Cupcake US$4.25
Filipino purple yam cake topped with Ube cream cheese icing.
Strawberry Cupcake US$4.25
Light strawberry cake baked with fresh pieces of strawberry iced with a white chocolate infused vanilla buttercream
The Thaly *Raspberry Choc* US$4.25
Soft decadent chocolate cake with a rich raspberry filling, topped with a raspberry buttercream, ganache drizzle.

Famous Puddings
Famous Banana Pudding (10oz Cup) US$6.00
Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas.
Famous Banana Pudding (32oz Tub) US$21.00
Layers of luscious vanilla pudding with vanilla wafers and bananas. (Feeds 3-4)
Oreo Cookies And Cream Pudding (10oz Cup) US$6.00
Chocolate Trifle Pudding (10oz Cup) US$6.00

Mini Cheesecakes
Oreo Crumb Mini Cheesecake US$7.99
Oreo cookies and cream interior, oreo crumb topping. Chocolate based crust. Feeds 1-2
Marble Swirled Cheesecake US$7.99
A swirl of Chocolate Marble Ganache. Feeds 1-2
Strawberry Swirl US$7.99
Strawberry cheesecake swirled with our homemade strawberry jam. Feeds 1-2
Red Velvet Cheesecake US$7.99
Chocolate crumb crust / Red velvet cheesecake with cream cheese frosting and red velvet cupcake crumbs on top. Feeds 1-2
Quadruple Chocolate Cheesecake US$7.99
A chocolate crumb base, chocolate cheesecake, topped with a ganache fudge and chocolate shavings on top. Feeds 1-2
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake US$7.99
Vanilla Bean Cheesecake topped with our Vanilla Buttercream. Feeds 1-2
Raspberry Marzipan Cheesecake * Staff Fav* US$7.99
Raspberry swirled Cheesecake made with Marzipan (almond paste). Feeds 1-2
Salted Caramel Cheesecake US$7.99
Salted Caramel Cheesecake with Caramel Swirl. Feeds 1-2.

Macarons
1dz Assorted Macarons US$40.00
Flavors might include: Pistachio, Salted Caramel, Mocha, Mango, Lemon, Raspberry, Oreo cookies, Red velvet, Chocolate, Coconut, Vanilla, Strawberry Cheesecake. Varries.
6 Pack Macarons Assorted US$21.00
An assortment of 6 Macarons. Flavors might include: Oreo, Mango, Lemon, Raspberry, Strawberry Cheesecake, Coconut, Vanilla, Satled Caramel, Mocha, Chocolate, Pistachio, Fruity Pebbles
4 Pack Macarons US$14.00
4 Pack of Macaron assortment
Individual Macaron US$3.50
Please choose one

Gluten Free (Friendly) Cupcakes and Bars
Gluten Free Red Velvet Cupcakes US$4.25
Our traditional authentic cream cheese red velvet cupcake!
Gluten Free Vanilla And Vanilla US$4.11
Our buttercup golden vanilla cake with a vanilla buttercream.
Gluten Free Vanilla / Chocolate US$4.11
Traditional golden vanilla cake with a Chocolate buttercream
Gluten Free Chocolate / Vanilla US$4.11
Chocolate moist cake with a rich vanilla buttercream
Gluten Free Gooey Chocolate Chip Blondie Bar US$4.12
Gluten Free Chocolate Fudge Brownie Bar US$4.11

Buttercup BakeShop Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pick-up
Takeaway

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Buttercup BakeShop Photos

Buttercup BakeShop Location

Buttercup BakeShop

New York New York County New York 2nd Avenue

973 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

Buttercup BakeShop Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 998 user reviews.

banana puddingbaked goodsubestrawberry cakecupcakes, cookiesdulce de lechemonkeymeringuea birthday cakelemon bar

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Staff was wonderful! Greeted when we walked in, the ladies offered suggestions to us. We got like 6 different things so will update later. Lots to choose from and really good prices!
July 11 · DeMyra Harvey
Good cupcakes, rich frosting and lots of selection. Late night snacks should be easy to find and good when you first-bite. I think these easily met this criteria. The only not so good item was the lemon bar. It did not taste very lemony, no zest notes and not even lemon scented, not sure why. Everything else was really good.
June 07 · Dwayne
Buttercup makes the best cupcakes in the city. They’re never over baked. The buttercream frosting is delicious! I also love their lemon bars!
May 26 · S. Reid
This cupcake shop is an absolute gem! The cupcakes are moist, flavorful, and beautifully decorated—each one tastes like it was made with love. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making the whole experience even sweeter. I’ll definitely be coming back for every special occasion (and a few just because).
June 21 · Sayler Ribich
I really wanted to love this cake experience, but I left disappointed and frustrated. I ordered a custom cake for my boyfriend’s birthday the day before a big trip. The bakery did have it ready on time, which I appreciated—but when I picked it up, I noticed it was already leaning and slightly lopsided.I had it refrigerated at work and tried my best to adjust it, but by the time I got home, it had completely collapsed. I had requested meringue frosting instead of buttercream (since my boyfriend prefers it), but wasn’t informed that it would make the cake more unstable. I wish that had been communicated more clearly.I called the bakery the same day and was told refunds weren’t allowed per company policy, and that I should email the owner—which I did, along with photos. It’s now been almost two weeks with no response or follow-up at all. That lack of communication is what really disappointed me most. For the price I paid, I expected more care, transparency, and better customer service.
May 21 · Maricella Olague