Katie's Creations custom cookies

Introduction / Overview

For local residents across Wisconsin who value both high-quality baking and detailed artistic customization, Katie's Creations custom cookies represents a true local treasure within the Sussex community. Operating as a specialized bakery, this business elevates the simple sugar cookie into a canvas for celebration, crafting beautiful and delicious treats perfectly suited for any event, from the most intimate family gathering to the grandest local milestone. The philosophy here is rooted in passion, with the baker, Katie, describing her craft as her "love language," a sentiment that translates directly into the care and quality found in every hand-decorated creation.

Katie's commitment to her craft is supported by a formal culinary background, having attended culinary school to pursue and enhance her baking skills. This professional foundation ensures that while the aesthetics are stunning, the taste and texture are always paramount. Since establishing this endeavor in 2019, driven by encouragement from friends and family, Katie’s Creations has become a recognized source for personalized, high-detail confectionery across Waukesha County and the broader Wisconsin area. The business focuses heavily on custom orders, ensuring that each client's vision is brought to life with meticulous attention to color, shape, and theme, whether it’s for a wedding, a birthday, or simply a seasonal indulgence.

While the business operates with the flexibility often found in home food artisans, its reach and reputation reflect a professional, quality-driven operation. By dedicating her free time outside of her primary role as a Special Education Paraprofessional to baking, Katie ensures her passion remains central to the business. For Wisconsin locals seeking a truly personalized and professional bakery experience that consistently delivers treats that are as delightful to look at as they are to eat, Katie's Creations custom cookies is a distinguished and highly recommended choice right here in Sussex.

Location and Accessibility

Katie's Creations custom cookies is an established local operation situated in the welcoming Sussex community of Wisconsin. The business utilizes its operational base on Sharon Drive in the 53089 ZIP code area of Sussex, WI, USA. This placement makes it particularly convenient for customers in the local Waukesha County area, allowing for easy arrangement of pickups for custom orders and seasonal specialties. While the business operates out of this specific location, all inquiries and orders must be placed remotely, respecting the nature of a custom, specialized bakery service.

The specific address on Sharon Drive serves as the central point for coordination and the collection of meticulously prepared treats. As the business is primarily focused on custom, pre-ordered products, clients are encouraged to utilize the provided phone and digital contact methods to discuss their needs and arrange logistics, including pickup details. The dedicated local nature of this business means it is integrated into the Sussex community, offering a convenient, neighborhood-based option for specialized dessert services.

Based on the publicly available information, details regarding general physical location accessibility, such as dedicated parking or ramp access, are not specified. Therefore, local users are encouraged to communicate directly with Katie's Creations via the provided phone number when placing an order to confirm any specific needs or arrangements for convenient and easy collection of their specialized custom cookie and dessert creations from the Sharon Drive location. This communication ensures a smooth, personalized service experience for every Wisconsin customer.

Services Offered

• Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies: The flagship service, offering one dozen custom cookies designed specifically for an upcoming event. Customers choose the design theme, color details, and can select up to three different cutter shapes per dozen, ensuring a truly personalized, one-of-a-kind result. A minimum order of two dozen is generally required, with a lead time of at least one week recommended to secure the booking and allow for the meticulous detailing involved in the artistry.
• Simple Design Cookie Orders: Catering to basic needs, this option focuses on custom cookies with a simple design, typically limited to two colors and one or two cutter shapes, offering a streamlined option for larger or less intricate events.
• Interactive Paint Your Own (PYO) Cookie Kits: A unique and fun offering perfect for children’s birthday parties, holiday activities, and engaging favors. These kits include one large cookie ready to be decorated, along with a dedicated cookie paint palette, providing a creative, edible activity that has been praised by local customers for being both enjoyable and delicious.
• Seasonal and Holiday Cookie Sets: Offering pre-designed, themed collections for major holidays. Examples include the popular Thanksgiving dozen, festive pumpkin-themed gift boxes, and specialty cookies like the "Pumpkin pie" sugar cookie look-alike, which provides a sweet alternative to traditional holiday desserts.
• Holiday Advent Calendars: Providing highly popular seasonal products like the 12 Day and 24 Day Advent Calendars, which feature daily 2-inch decorated mini sugar cookie surprises throughout December, a delightful tradition for Wisconsin families leading up to Christmas.
• Specialty Treat Trays: Providing comprehensive dessert solutions for large gatherings, such as the Thanksgiving Treat Tray, which includes an assortment of sweet items like a dozen mini sugar cookies, a dozen assorted drop cookies, a dozen brownie bites, a 5-inch cookie cake, and a 5-inch pumpkin pie, offering variety and convenience for local hosts.

Features / Highlights

• Exceptional Decorative Detail: The primary highlight is the extraordinary level of artistry in the custom decoration. Customers consistently praise Katie’s work, noting her "great insight to please" and her meticulous "detailing in design." This attention to craft ensures that the cookies are not just treats, but beautiful, memorable additions to any Wisconsin celebration.
• Culinary School Expertise: The baker's background includes formal training at culinary school, a feature that distinguishes the operation and assures customers that the products are made with enhanced professional skill, resulting in both superior aesthetics and exceptional taste.
• Guaranteed Deliciousness: Beyond the visual appeal, the flavor is highly acclaimed. Reviews emphasize that the cookies are not only "the most beautiful" but also consistently "DELISH" and "delicious." This commitment to quality flavor ensures that the treats are enjoyed as much as they are admired.
• Unique Interactive Options: The inclusion of innovative products like the Paint Your Own (PYO) Cookie kits and the holiday Advent Calendars sets Katie’s Creations apart. These interactive and seasonal offerings provide unique ways for local Wisconsin families to engage with the treats, adding an element of fun and tradition to the baking business.
• Extensive Range of Themed Products: The capability to provide highly specific and creative themed products—from detailed custom designs for events to unique concepts like the “TV Dinner” sugar cookie and the non-traditional “Pumpkin pie” sugar cookie—showcases the baker’s creativity and ability to deliver truly distinctive items for the local market.

Contact Information

For residents in Sussex, Waukesha County, and the broader Wisconsin area looking to place a customized order or request information, Katie's Creations custom cookies can be reached using the following contact details:

Physical Location (Sussex, WI): Sharon Dr, Sussex, WI 53089, USA

Primary Phone Contact (for inquiries and orders): (262) 527-8929

Alternate Mobile Contact: +1 262-527-8929

What is Worth Choosing

For local Wisconsin users, choosing Katie's Creations custom cookies is choosing a perfect convergence of professional culinary skill and passionate, personalized artistry. What makes this Sussex bakery so highly worth selecting is the baker’s dedication, which stems from a genuine love for baking that she expresses as her "love language," a passion solidified by her formal culinary training. This unique combination ensures every single custom order, every holiday treat, and every unique item is executed with both technical precision and heartfelt care.

The primary value lies in the personalization and confirmed quality. Customers consistently report that the treats are not just beautiful, but "the very BEST" and unequivocally "delicious." This dual focus on impeccable taste and stunning, meticulous design detailing means that when you order a dozen custom cookies for an event, you are receiving a centerpiece that will be both admired and fully enjoyed by all your guests. The ability to request a high degree of personalization—specifying themes, colors, and up to three shapes per dozen—guarantees a product that truly reflects the individual nature of your Wisconsin celebration.

Furthermore, the variety of offerings ensures the bakery can meet diverse local needs beyond simple custom cookies. Whether you require a convenient, comprehensive Thanksgiving Treat Tray, a fun, interactive activity like the Paint Your Own Cookies kit, or a charming daily indulgence like the Christmas Advent Calendar, Katie's Creations provides specialized, high-demand products. The fact that the baker is personally invested, working hard to share her passion outside of her primary career, adds a layer of genuine, local connection and reliability that is highly valued by community patrons. For those in Sussex and the surrounding areas, Katie's Creations custom cookies offers an exceptional, personalized, and consistently delicious option for adding memorable sweetness to any moment.

Katie's Creations custom cookies

Sharon Dr, Sussex, WI 53089, USA