Sugar Sweet Treats

For residents of Baiting Hollow and the wider North Fork region of Long Island, there's a certain magic in discovering a local business that consistently exceeds expectations, turning simple treats into unforgettable culinary experiences. Sugar Sweet Treats is precisely that kind of place. While the name itself promises delight, it's the sheer quality and passion infused into every baked good that truly sets this bakery apart. It's quickly become a beloved spot for those in the know, a testament to the idea that a dedication to fresh, high-quality ingredients and a genuine love for baking can create something truly special. For New Yorkers who appreciate authentic flavors and the charm of a family-run establishment, Sugar Sweet Treats offers a delectable escape, proving that some of the best things in life truly are sweet.

The story of Sugar Sweet Treats is one of passion and a commitment to quality that shines through in every bite. As a family-run business that blossomed from a "simple love for cake decorations and creating tasty, hand-made, all-natural treats" back in 2013, they’ve cultivated a reputation for excellence. Their mission is simple yet profound: "to create made-from-scratch-quality treats that are always made fresh from my kitchen to yours." This isn't just a marketing slogan; it's a philosophy deeply embedded in their process, evident in their meticulous ingredient selection, including "local butter from Stony Creek Dairy," "farm-fresh eggs," and "locally milled flour when available." This emphasis on natural, simple, and locally sourced ingredients directly contributes to the exceptional flavor and freshness that customers rave about.

Indeed, customer experiences speak volumes. One delighted patron stumbled upon their "Almond Rasberry cookies" by chance at a deli and was utterly blown away, declaring them "the best almond Rasberry cookies ever!!! I literally ate the whole box!!!" This enthusiastic review highlights the addictive quality of their treats. The pleasant surprise continued when they discovered that Sugar Sweet Treats ships nationwide, allowing them to "order some more Rasberry almond cookies and some other wonderful treats and again, I took one bite and the world was a better place again! Lol!!!" This personal testimony underscores the profound impact their delicious treats have on customers. Another review simply reinforces this sentiment, praising "Excellent Raspberry Almond Cookies and Ricotta Cookies. Delicious and not overly sweet tasting." These firsthand accounts confirm that Sugar Sweet Treats is not just selling baked goods; they're selling moments of pure joy and satisfaction, earning loyal fans one delectable cookie at a time.

Sugar Sweet Treats is conveniently located at 4603 Middle Country Rd, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933, USA. This address places it directly on a significant thoroughfare, Middle Country Road (also known as NY-25), which is a key route traversing Long Island's North Fork. Its position on this main road ensures excellent visibility and easy accessibility for residents of Baiting Hollow and neighboring communities such as Riverhead, Calverton, and Ridge. For those traveling to and from the many farms, wineries, and attractions of the North Fork, Sugar Sweet Treats offers a perfectly situated stop for a delightful treat. The ample roadside presence typically allows for convenient parking, which is a definite plus for quick pick-ups. This strategic location enables Sugar Sweet Treats to serve a wide local customer base, as well as attract visitors exploring the charming East End. Its accessibility firmly establishes it as a go-to spot for those seeking high-quality, freshly baked goods in the region.

Sugar Sweet Treats offers a focused yet delightful range of baked goods, with a strong emphasis on quality, freshness, and often, the ability to ship their popular items. Their core services and products include:

• Gourmet Cookies: This is a standout offering, featuring highly acclaimed varieties like their "best almond Rasberry cookies ever!!!" Other popular options often include Ricotta Cookies and various "Large Gourmet Cookies" and "Sample Cookies." Their cookies are made from scratch with fresh gourmet cookie dough.

• Cinnamon Rolls: They offer both regular and "Jumbo Holiday Cinnamon Rolls," made with their signature commitment to quality ingredients.

• Signature Cupcakes: While specific flavors may vary, they offer their "Signature Cupcakes," suggesting a selection of classic and possibly seasonal cupcake options.

• Gourmet Edible Cookie Dough: For those who love the taste of cookie dough, they offer "Gourmet Edible Cookie Dough," providing a safe and delicious way to indulge.

• Specialty Kits: They occasionally feature unique items like "DIY Pizza Cookie Kits" and "Paint Your Own Easter Egg Kits," adding a fun, interactive element to their offerings, often seasonal.

• Holiday and Premium Cookie Boxes: For gifting or larger gatherings, they offer "Premium Holiday Cookie Box" options in various sizes, perfect for sharing their delicious assortments.

• Nationwide Shipping: A key service highlight is their ability to ship their delicious treats, allowing customers from outside the immediate area to enjoy their products, as enthusiastically noted by a reviewer.

• Custom Orders: While not explicitly detailed, as a specialized bakery focusing on quality, they likely accommodate custom orders for events or specific requests, especially for their popular cookies.

Sugar Sweet Treats distinguishes itself through several compelling features and highlights that contribute to its strong reputation and loyal customer base on Long Island and beyond.

• Exceptional Cookie Quality and Flavor: This is their most celebrated highlight. Reviews consistently praise their cookies, particularly the Almond Raspberry, as "the best ever!!!" and "delicious and not overly sweet tasting." Their commitment to "made-from-scratch-quality treats" is evident in every bite.

• Fresh, Locally Sourced, and Natural Ingredients: A significant feature is their dedication to using high-quality ingredients, including "local butter from Stony Creek Dairy," "farm-fresh eggs," and "locally milled flour when available." They prioritize "natural and simple" ingredients and bake without preservatives, appealing to health-conscious consumers.

• Family-Run Business with Passion: Being a "100% family-run business" that started from a "simple love for cake decorations" fosters a sense of authenticity and personal care in their products and service, which resonates deeply with customers.

• Nationwide Shipping Capability: The ability to ship their treats across the country is a massive highlight, expanding their reach and allowing customers who have moved or received gifts from them to reorder their favorites.

• Perfect for Gifting: As evidenced by customer reviews, their cookies and treats make "a great gift or just for yourself." Their thoughtful packaging and delicious contents ensure they are a well-received present.

• Not Overly Sweet Taste Profile: The specific mention that their cookies are "not overly sweet tasting" is a significant highlight for those who prefer a more balanced flavor profile, allowing the natural ingredients to shine.

• Growing Product Line and Seasonal Offerings: While specialized, their menu includes other popular items like cinnamon rolls and seasonal kits, indicating a dynamic approach to their offerings that keeps customers engaged.

To experience the delectable offerings of Sugar Sweet Treats or to place an order, here is their contact information:

• Address: 4603 Middle Country Rd, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933, USA

• Phone: (631) 766-9470

In conclusion, Sugar Sweet Treats is an exceptional and highly recommended bakery for residents of Baiting Hollow and indeed, anyone in the New York region seeking truly outstanding baked goods. For locals, its suitability is rooted in its unwavering commitment to quality, freshness, and the use of locally sourced, natural ingredients, ensuring that every treat is not only delicious but also responsibly made. Its convenient location on Middle Country Road makes it easily accessible for quick stops or pre-ordered pickups. The consistent rave reviews, particularly for their "best almond Rasberry cookies ever," highlight the sheer delight and satisfaction their products bring. The personal touch of a family-run business and the ability to ship nationwide further solidify its appeal, allowing loyal customers to enjoy their favorites no matter where they are. Whether you're looking for an everyday indulgence, a thoughtful gift, or a delicious addition to your next gathering, Sugar Sweet Treats offers a perfect blend of homemade taste, gourmet quality, and heartfelt service. It's truly a local treasure that brings a little more sweetness into the lives of New Yorkers.

Sugar Sweet Treats

4603 Middle Country Rd, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933, USA