Sweet Pea's Mayville WI: Premier Pie Shop, Ice Cream & Dessert Destination in Wisconsin

Sweet Pea's Introduce

Introduction / Overview

For Wisconsinites with a discerning sweet tooth, discovering a local gem like **Sweet Pea's** in **Mayville, WI**, is a genuine treat. Located right on Main Street, this establishment has quickly become a beloved destination that skillfully blends the comfort of a classic bakery with the excitement of a modern dessert parlor. While the business identifies primarily as a **Pie shop**—a fact local customers are already planning to celebrate, especially come fall—Sweet Pea's offers an impressively wide and diverse menu that caters to every craving, from specialty chocolates to gourmet ice cream and refreshing açaí bowls.

More than just a place to grab a quick dessert, Sweet Pea's has cultivated a reputation as a cute little shop with an exceptionally friendly atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for a quick stop or a relaxed outing with friends. It stands out in the **Dodge County** area for its commitment to high-quality, handcrafted items and its welcoming service. Proudly **women-owned**, this local business is a must-visit for anyone in the region looking to satisfy their desire for a truly delicious, authentic, and memorable dessert experience. Whether you’re stopping in for a slice of their famous pie or grabbing a scoop of Wisconsin-favorite ice cream, Sweet Pea's embodies the sweet life in Mayville.

Location and Accessibility

Sweet Pea's is conveniently nestled in the heart of the Mayville community, making it highly accessible for both local residents and those traveling through the area. Their location on Main Street ensures they are easy to find and integrate seamlessly into your daily errands or weekend plans. The specific location is:

4 S Main St, Mayville, WI 53050, USA

Understanding that convenience and comfort are key to a great local business experience, Sweet Pea's has ensured excellent access for all patrons. The property features:

Accessibility and Parking:

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Free street parking

These amenities allow for a stress-free visit, whether you're quickly running in for takeout or planning to **dine-in** and enjoy the free **Wi-Fi**. The ease of finding parking right near the entrance makes this spot an excellent choice for a **quick visit** any time of day.

Services Offered

Sweet Pea's is a dynamic dessert spot offering a comprehensive range of services and options designed to fit every customer's preference, from cozy dine-in to convenient at-home enjoyment. Their versatile service model is a huge benefit to the local Wisconsin clientele:

Flexible Ordering Options:

Dine-in: Enjoy your treats in their charming, welcoming shop.

Takeout: Perfect for grabbing a quick slice or a whole pie to take home.

Curbside pickup: A convenient, no-fuss option for pre-ordered items.

In-store pickup: Easily collect your online or phone orders.

Delivery: Getting your favorite pies and treats brought right to your door.

In-store shopping: Browse the full selection of pies, ice cream, and treats.

Product Categories and Specialties:

Full Pie Sales: Offering both whole pies and slices of their impressive, handcrafted pie selection, which includes everything from classic **Apple Pie** to unique options like **Rhubarb Custard Pie** and **French Silk**.

Coffee and Beverages: Serving freshly prepared **Coffee** and a variety of bottled drinks, including local favorite **Sprecher Root Beer**.

Gourmet Ice Cream & Drinks: Featuring a large selection of premium **Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream** flavors, along with freshly made shakes, malts, floats, and affogato.

Specialty Desserts: Offering a range of other baked goods and treats, such as **Cake Pops**, **Cookies**, **Cream Cheese Brownie Sandwiches**, and mini cakes.

Features / Highlights

The distinctive characteristics and exceptional offerings at Sweet Pea's are what draw people from all over the Mayville and surrounding Wisconsin areas. The following highlights make it a standout destination:

Diverse Pie Menu: Boasting a phenomenal variety of over 15 unique, **handcrafted pie** flavors, including seasonal favorites like **Pumpkin Pie**, perennial classics like **Pecan Pie**, and signature creamy options like **Banana Cream Pie** and **Pistachio Cream Pie**.

Premium Ice Cream Selection: Proudly serving **Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream**, a highly regarded Wisconsin-based creamery, with indulgent and fun flavors like **This $&@! Just Got Serious Ice Cream**, **Zanzibar® Chocolate**, and **Brandy Old Fashioned**.

Global and Trendy Treats: Featuring unique menu additions such as the viral **Dubai Chocolate Bar** and related desserts like the **Dubai Sundae**, showcasing a modern, trend-aware dessert experience alongside classic baked goods.

Focus on Wellness Options: Providing healthier alternatives like various **Açaí Bowls** (including a **Tropical Sunset Acai Smoothie Bowl**) and non-dairy options such as **Oat Milk Ice Cream** and **Italian Ice**.

Small Business Support and Values: Operating as a **women-owned** business that is committed to exceptional, friendly service and a welcoming, clean shop environment.

Contact Information

Connecting with Sweet Pea's is easy, whether you need to place a large order, check for the daily pie selection, or simply want to inquire about their latest Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream flavor. Please use the following official contact information:

Address:

4 S Main St, Mayville, WI 53050, USA

Phone:

(920) 644-2293

What is worth choosing

For any Wisconsin dessert lover, Sweet Pea's is an essential stop, particularly for their specialization in high-quality pies. What makes this establishment an easy choice is its comprehensive ability to meet almost any dessert need. Whether you are searching for the perfect centerpiece pie for a holiday gathering (like their top-selling **Strawberry Rhubarb Pie** or **Blueberry Pie**), a delightful **Dog Treat** for your four-legged companion, or a fun ice cream treat on a warm summer evening, Sweet Pea's delivers.

The fact that they are a locally owned, **women-owned** business that offers premium brands like **Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream** and features in-demand, trendy items like the **Dubai Chocolate Bar** shows a commitment to both local tradition and modern innovation. This makes Sweet Pea's a dynamic and exciting place to visit repeatedly. Furthermore, their unparalleled convenience—from accepting all modern **NFC mobile payments** and **Credit cards** to offering **Delivery**, **Curbside pickup**, and a pleasant **Dine-in** experience—removes all barriers to enjoying their sweet selection.

In Mayville, Sweet Pea's is more than a bakery; it's a community fixture that promises exceptional value, incredible flavor variety, and genuinely friendly service. If you are anywhere near Dodge County and need to satisfy a craving for something truly sweet and handcrafted, choose Sweet Pea's for an experience that is both quick and memorable.

Sweet Pea's Vibe

Handcrafted Pie
Cherry Crumble $20.99
10" flaky vegan pastry is filled with tart cherries and topped with Grandma Betty's brown sugar, butter, and oat crumble recipe. Serves 6 - 10
Rhubarb Custard Pie $23.99
A flaky crust is filled with tart rhubarb and creamy custard then baked until everything is tender and set. This pie is best served cold. Add whipped cream or ice cream if you like.
Banana Cream Pie $24.99
9" graham cracker crust is filled with fresh sliced bananas, homemade vanilla pudding and topped with whipped cream. This pie needs to be refrigerated and eaten within a few days as the bananas start to turn brown right away.
Honey Pie, 10" $21.99
We start with our vegan pastry crust and then add a honey custard made with local honey (when possible), eggs, cream and a little bit of greek yogurt to balance the sweetness. It's smooth, creamy and tastes great warm or cold. Some people like to add a sprinkle of coarse flake salt to the top or some toasted nuts for crunch.
Key Lime Pie $21.99
A sweet graham cracker crust is filled with tangy, smooth baked lime custard then topped with whipped cream dollops.
Berrylicious $20.99
Our vegan 10" pastry is bursting with flavor. The Pie Guy's favorite pie has raspberries, blueberries, blackberries and a hint of ginger.
French Silk $24.99
Graham crust is filled with homemade smooth and silly chocolate then topped with whipped cream and mini chocolate chips. One of our original recipes that is so good we didn't see any reason to change it. Contains: eggs, milk, wheat, soy
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie, 10" $20.99
This pie is the perfect balance of tart and sweet. It's a midwestern favorite! Vegan.
Apple Pie, 10" $20.99
This is Grandma Ardath's original recipe pie. Two vegan pastry crusts surround tart apples, cinnamon, and just enough sugar to make it all say, mmmmh.
Razappleberry Pie, 10" $20.99
Our vegan pastry crust is filled with apples, raspberries, blueberries, and blackberries for a true flavor party.
Cherry Pie, 10" $20.99
Tart cherries, double pastry crust - it's a classic.
Pistachio Cream Pie $21.99
Graham cracker crust layered with fluffy cream cheese, pistachio pudding, and whipped cream and a sprinkle of crushed pistachios.
Lemon Ice Box Pie $21.99
Graham cracker crust filled with tangy, sweet, creamy, fluffy lemon whipped filling and topped with lemon zest. Yeah, you need this in your life!
Strawberry Peach Pie $20.99
Pumpkin Pie, 10" $20.99
Award winning pumpkin custard is baked in a vegan 10" pastry crust.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Creme Pie $21.99
Peanut butter creme and chocolate pudding iare layered n a graham crust and finished off with cream and chocolate and peanut butter drizzle.
Candied Apple $20.99
We start with Grandma Ardath's traditional apple pie recipe - apples, cinnamon and just a little bit of sugar - then we add in Grandma Betty's twist to spice it up. Cinnamon imperial candies get baked right in to give this pie an extra cinnamon kick and beautiful red color.
Smore's $21.99
A 9" graham cracker crust is filled with fluffy, milk chocolate goodness then topped with mini marshmallows. Serves 6-8
Bluebarb Pie (Blueberry And Rhubarb) $20.99
Blueberry Pie, 10" $20.99
We like our blueberries a little sweet with a hint of ginger. We also recommend pairing these blue beauties with a pint of your favorite ice cream. Vegan
Peaches & Cream $22.00
Sweet juicy peaches are baked with a creamy filling - NO need for whipped cream or ice cream on top.
Pecan Pie $24.99
It's a classic, but ours isn't overly sweet and sticky . one of our favorites that's only around september through easter. dig in with two forks.
Caramel Apple Crumble Pie, 10" $20.99
This is one of our top fall favorites. Tart apples get covered in cinnamon and caramel then topped with a butter, brown sugar, and oat crumble.

Dubai Chocolat
Dubai Sundae $9.50
Our award winning vanilla ice cream is layered with chocolate, pistachio kinda sauce and strawberries then topped with whipped cream and more sauce
Dubai Chocolate Bar $14.95
Strawerry Cup $14.95
Fresh Strawberries are sliced and layered with chocolate, pistachio kinda sauce and then topped with pistachios and kinda crumch

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream
Fruit Ice Cream $7.50
Pint. Fruit ice cream is one of our favorites! In the case you might find strawberry, black cherry, blueberry cheesecake, kitty kitty bang bang, or other delicious ice cream with fruit at center stage.
Oat Milk Ice Cream $7.50
Pint. Dairy free, vegetarian, vegan, gluten free ice cream that is smooth and creamy. We can't tell the difference! Varieties vary and might include Blue Moon, Vanilla, chocolate chip, black cherry, oatmeal cookie dough, or mint oreo.
Nut Ice Cream $7.50
Pint. We always have at least one ice cream featuring nuts in our case. We might have rocky road, pistachio, butter pecan, coconut almond bliss, or another nut lovers favorite variety. Please call the store before you order if you need to know what variety will be delivered today.
Peanut Butter Flavor Of The Week $7.50
Pint. Call before ordering if you need to know what variety is available for delivery today. You might get Fat Elvis, Peanut Butter Cookie Dough, Moose Tracks, Yippee Skippy, Peanut Butter Cup, PB Hearts, etc.
Seasonal Favorite $7.50
Pint. Gingerbread Man (Brown sugar gingerbread ice cream swirled with white icing glaze and festive holiday sprinkles) and Raspberry Rhapsody are in the case for February (while supplies last)
Rainbow Sherbet $7.50
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. Orange, lime, and raspberry flavored sherbets classically swirled together.
Graham Cracker - Limited Edition $4.79
Our Graham Cracker ice cream is probably our most popular because it is literally the best version of a graham cracker youre ever going to eat,
Lemon Lavender - Limited Edition $7.50
Sweet and tangy lemon with a hint of lavender is cool and refreshing on its own. Add it to soda or your favorite fun beverage for a little pizzaz.
This $&@! Just Got Serious Ice Cream $7.50
Gluten free. Pint. Award-winning, smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews.
Italian Ice $7.50
Dairy free, nut free, gluten free and bursting with tangy flavor and fruit juices. Pint. We will send whatever variety we have in the case today. Varies between carrot mango, passion fruit, raspberry lemon, strawberry hibiscus, and electric watermelon. If you want to know what is available please call the store before ordering.
Zanzibar® Chocolate Ice Cream $7.50
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. All-natural and award-winning chocolate ice cream made with three kinds of cocoa for a rich, fudge brownie taste.
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream $7.50
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. An award-winning and all-natural classic vanilla ice cream made with Wisconsin cream, cane sugar and pure vanilla.
Coffee Or Espresso Variety $7.50
Pint. Selection varies and might include Exhausted Parent, Iced Latte Dah, Espresso, and Cappuccino Break.
Butter Pecan $6.99
Pint. Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crispy, lightly roasted and salted pecans.
Cotton Candy, Blue Moon, Superman, Or Birthday Cake $7.50
Nut free, gluten free. Pint. We will send whichever of these flavors we have on hand in our case. Call before ordering if you would like to know which flavor we will deliver today.
Cinnamon Stick $4.79
Seasonal flavor. Pint. All-natural, tantalizing spicy-yet-smooth cinnamon flavored ice cream
No Sugar Added Ice Cream $7.50
Gluten free. Flavors based on manufacturer availability. You won't believe it's no sugar! Available varieties vary but include cashew & caramel, pomegranite swirl, and strawberry swirl
Ultimate Oreo Or Cookie Dough $7.50
Nut free. Pint. Scrumptious Oreo ice cream made with boat-loads of whole Oreos or vanilla ice cream with chocolate flakes and chunks of cookie dough. We rotate these super popular flavors.
Brandy Old Fashioned $6.99
Wisconsin’s favorite cocktail shows up as one of the best ice creams you will ever taste. Would we lie to you? It’s amazing. http://www.calliopeicecream.com
Coconut Almond Bliss $6.99
Pint. Tropical coconut-flavored ice cream with tons of melt-in-your-mouth chocolate flakes and crispy almond pieces.
Hot Peanut Butter - Limited Edition $4.79
Pint. Sweet, smooth, a little salty, and a little Sriracha! It's like a Thai dipping sauce, but as an ice cream
Chocolate Variety Ice Cream $7.50
Pint. It could be Malt Amore, Sticks and Stones, Haley's Comet, Raspberry Truffle, or even Peanut Butter Cup, but we always have at least one chocolate based ice cream in our case.
Mint Variety $7.50
Nut free. Pint. We might have Mint Avalanceh, Zanzamint, mint chip, mint oreo or in the holiday season Peppermint Chip - int lover's paradise! Please call the store if you need to know what variety we have available for delivery today.

Beverages
Prime - Available Flavors Vary $2.75
16.9 oz each bottle contains 10% coconut water, zero sugar, BCAA's, antioxidants, electrolytes, and zinc for immunity.
Sparkling Ice Strawberry Citrus $2.25
16 ounces of sparkling water, vitamins, antioxidants, naturally sourced colors, 0 sugar 0 carbs 70 mg caffeine.
Sparkling Ice Caffeine Blue Raspberry $2.25
16 ounces of sparkling water, vitamins, antioxidants, naturally sourced colors, 0 sugar 0 carbs 70 mg caffeine.
Sparkling Ice Caffeine Citrus Twist $2.25
16 ounces of sparkling water, vitamins, antioxidants, naturally sourced colors, 0 sugar 0 carbs 70 mg caffeine.
Sprecher Root Beer (16 Oz Glass Made With Honey) $2.99
Traditional A&W Root Beer in a 12 oz can.

Açaí Bowl
Dubai Strawberry Smoothie Bowl $14.45
Tropical Sunset Acai Smoothie Bowl $11.75
Açaí Bowl With Fruit And Granola $9.45
Dairy free, vegan. Açaí sorbet topped with house made granola, bananas, berries and drizzled with honey or peanut butter.

Bakery Treats
Cereal Treats $2.49
Housemade soft and buttery krispie cereal treats.
4" Mini Cake $13.95
Double layer mini cake stylishly decorated. To share or not to share, that is the only question.
Cream Cheese Brownie Sandwich $4.99
Cream cheese buttercream is sandwich between two homemade cream cheese swirled fudgy brownie slices.
Cake Pops $2.99
Soft confetti cake center coated in white chocolate or chocolate cake covered in dark chocolate.
Cake Parfait $4.65
Cake is layered with cream, pudding, or buttercream in these delicious and adorable cake parfaits.
Dog Treat $2.60
Give your pet a special occassion treat! We bake our treats using human grade ingredients and coat them with yogurt chips so they have minimal sugar.
Cookies $2.49
Selection: chocolate chip, sugar, or coconut macaroons

Ice Cream Drinks and Treats
Shake Or Malt $7.29
Our shakes and malts are made with Chocolate Shoppe Super Premium Ice cream and milk then topped with whipped cream. Simple, delicious. 14 oz.
Root Beer Float $4.25
A&W root beer and vanilla ice cream combine for a classic tasty treat
Affogato $4.49
4 ounces of coffee poured over a scoop of vanilla ice cream and topped with caramel drizzle.
Ice Cream Sandwich $4.99
We start with a housemade sugar or chocolate chip cookie, add a generous amount of our super premium Chocolate Shoppe ice cream. It's finger licking good! Hope you are hungry.

Sweet Pea's Details

From the business
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Curbside pickup
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free street parking

Sweet Pea's Photos

Sweet Pea's Location

Sweet Pea's

Wisconsin Dodge County Mayville South Main Street

4 S Main St, Mayville, WI 53050, USA

Sweet Pea's Reviews

An average rating of ★4.9 from 62 user reviews.

ice creamcherryraspberrycrumblecheesecakeshakepeanut butterareaproject

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Very cute little shop with sweet treats to enjoy onsite or for take away. Great place to pop through for a taste wether you wanna take something home for others or stop in with some pals to satisfy your sweet tooth
August 13 · Amber J.
Exceptionally friendly service and great ice cream. They are actually a pie shop in development. Going back in the Fall for pie.
July 18 · Christine Brettingen
Back in Mayville at Sweet Pea's tonight. I had a spectacular Raspberry/Apple pie. My wife had ice cream. Both were outstanding, I highly recommend Sweet Pea's.
March 14 · Bill
Suggestion-My mother wanted to order a cake and called. She was told all orders have to be submitted online.She's in her 70s and does not order online. I am her online order assistant. Anyone with non tech savvy parents I'm sure can relate.While I can appreciate a single, streamlined system, is there no one that can answer her questions and place the order in your system directly? Does not seem like a good business model to exclude those who cannot use an online system. Not very inclusive. If a customer had vision issues would they need to bring someone to read the menu to them?
December 04 · Tracy M
Got some pie and ice cream last week when the owner opened up outside. Had a slice of cherry crumble and a strawberry and peach pie. So good!
August 21 · Madalyn S