The Milleridge Bakery Introduce
In the heart of Jericho, New York, nestled within the charming Milleridge Village, lies a local treasure that has been a part of community celebrations for decades: The Milleridge Bakery. For generations, this beloved establishment has been the go-to spot for everything from everyday treats to spectacular custom-designed cakes for life's most significant moments. Known for its extensive selection of classic pastries, breads, and cookies, the bakery offers a taste of tradition that keeps locals coming back for more. This article will provide a comprehensive overview of The Milleridge Bakery, highlighting what makes it a staple in the Long Island community.
The history of The Milleridge Inn and its surrounding village is rich with local lore, and the bakery is no exception. Its presence in the community has made it a familiar name for anyone celebrating a birthday, wedding, or holiday. It’s a place where the scent of freshly baked goods fills the air and the display cases are overflowing with delicious confections. While some recent reviews have noted inconsistencies in quality, particularly with items like cannolis, many long-time patrons continue to praise the bakery's consistent classics and the friendly, helpful nature of its staff. The staff's kindness is often a highlight for visitors, making every trip a pleasant experience, even when the shop is busy.
Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through Jericho, The Milleridge Bakery is an experience that’s worth having. The sheer variety of baked goods is a testament to its long-standing commitment to the craft. From simple sugar cookies to elaborate, multi-tiered wedding cakes, the bakery serves a wide range of needs and palates. This detailed guide is designed to help you navigate everything this local gem has to offer, from its convenient location and accessibility to its extensive menu of services and unique features that make it stand out from the crowd.
The Milleridge Bakery is conveniently located at 585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA. Its prime location within the historic Milleridge Village complex makes it easy to find and a memorable destination. The village itself is a charming collection of shops and eateries, providing a lovely atmosphere for a visit. The bakery is situated in a highly accessible area of Jericho, making it a simple trip for residents of the surrounding Long Island towns. For those driving, there is ample parking available within the village grounds, so finding a spot is rarely an issue. This accessibility is a major plus for busy New Yorkers who want to pick up a last-minute cake or a box of their favorite pastries without the stress of navigating tight city streets. The location is also well-connected to major roadways, making it a convenient stop for those traveling through the area. Public transportation options may also be available, but driving is generally the most straightforward way to access this suburban bakery.
The Milleridge Bakery is known for providing a wide variety of services tailored to meet the needs of its diverse clientele. From everyday treats to special occasion masterpieces, the bakery has something for everyone. They specialize in creating memorable baked goods for life’s most important events. Their services go beyond just selling pastries over the counter; they work closely with customers to bring their ideas to life. This dedication to customer service is one of the reasons they have maintained such a loyal following over the years.
Some of their key services include:
- Custom-designed cakes for all occasions, including birthdays, anniversaries, and graduations.
- Expertly crafted wedding cakes, with consultation services to help couples design their dream dessert.
- A wide selection of holiday-themed baked goods, from festive cookies to seasonal pies.
- Catering services for parties and corporate events, offering platters of cookies, pastries, and mini desserts.
- Freshly baked bread and rolls for daily consumption.
- Special orders for specific dietary needs or unique flavor requests, though this may require advance notice.
The Milleridge Bakery is more than just a place to buy baked goods; it's an institution with a variety of features that make it a standout destination. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the display cases are a feast for the eyes. The staff is consistently noted for their friendliness and willingness to help, which enhances the overall customer experience. These highlights are what contribute to the bakery's reputation as a local favorite.
Key features and highlights include:
- A long-standing history in the community, making it a trusted name for quality and tradition.
- A vast selection of baked goods, including an impressive array of cookies, pastries, cakes, and pies.
- The location within the historic Milleridge Village, providing a unique and charming backdrop for a visit.
- A focus on custom orders, allowing customers to get exactly what they envision for their special events.
- Friendly and welcoming staff who are consistently praised for their helpfulness and positive attitudes.
For more information or to place an order, you can contact The Milleridge Bakery directly. Their physical address is 585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA. You can also reach them by phone at (516) 931-2635. The staff is available to answer questions about their products, services, and custom order process. It's always a good idea to call ahead for large or custom orders to ensure they can accommodate your request and to discuss any specific details. Whether you're planning a wedding or just want to pick up some cookies for the weekend, a quick call can save you time and make your experience even smoother. Their commitment to accessibility and open communication is a key part of their service model.
In conclusion, The Milleridge Bakery is more than just a bakery—it's a cherished part of the Jericho community. Its long-standing presence in the area has made it a reliable choice for generations of locals celebrating life's milestones. While the occasional critique regarding product consistency, as seen in some reviews, exists, the bakery's consistent commitment to offering a wide variety of classic baked goods and friendly service keeps its legacy strong. For New Yorkers in the Long Island region, it's a convenient, charming, and reliable place to find delicious treats, custom cakes for any celebration, or just a simple, freshly baked bread. Its location within the Milleridge Village provides a unique and enjoyable experience, making a trip here feel like more than just a quick errand. It’s a place where tradition, flavor, and community converge, making it a perfect spot for locals seeking quality baked goods with a personal touch. The Milleridge Bakery is a testament to the enduring appeal of a classic, local business that continues to serve its community with passion and dedication.
The Milleridge Bakery Cake
Quiche (4” Round)
- Cheese Quiche US$12.00
- Spinach Quiche US$12.00
- Broccoli Quiche US$12.00
2 days Pre Order Cake
- Pre Order (2 Days) ; Build A Cake- Made To Order US$0.00
In the description please made sure to add when caked is needed by and the inscription for the top of the cake Unless otherwise noted, cakes will be standard decorations (as shown in picture)
Whole Pies (10”)
- Apple Pie US$26.00
- Pumpkin Pie US$26.00
Cookies
- Jumbo Black & White Chip US$6.00
- Sprinkle US$3.95
- Jumbo Two Chip Chocolate Chip US$6.00
- Black & White Cookie US$3.95
- Jumbo Rocky Road US$6.00
- Jumbo Coconut Chocolate Chip US$6.00
- M&M US$3.95
- Jumbo Dark Chocolate Chip US$6.00
- Jumbo Oatmeal Raisin US$6.00
- The Original Chocolate Chewy (Contains Walnuts) US$3.95
- Jumbo Caramel Chocolate Chip US$6.00
Cakes
- Black & White Cake 6” US$34.95
- Seven Layer Cake (Serving Size 8) US$24.95
- Rainbow Cake (Serving Size 8) US$34.95
Soft Drinks
- Pepsi 20oz US$4.00
- Diet Pepsi US$4.00
- Water 20oz US$4.00
- Iced Tea 20oz US$4.00
Cupcakes
- Chocolate Cupcake US$4.50
- Vanilla Cupcake US$4.50
Pastry Squares
- Crumb US$4.50
- Red Velvet US$4.50
- Carrot US$6.95
- Double Chocolate Brownie US$4.50
By the Slice
- Apple Pie By The Slice US$6.95
- Rainbow Cake US$9.95
- Banana Bread US$4.95
- Pumpkin Pie By The Slice US$6.95
- Cheesecake By The Slice US$7.95
- Pumpkin Bread US$4.95
Bread
- Pumpkin Loaf US$14.00
- Banana Loaf US$14.00
- Cinnamon Bread US$7.00
The Milleridge Bakery Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Takeaway
Accessibility
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
The Milleridge Bakery Photos










The Milleridge Bakery Location
The Milleridge Bakery
585 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
The Milleridge Bakery Reviews
cookiespricesvillagechristmascinnamon breadtouristloaflemonmorning
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Quality went down. They look good but it ends there. I have been going here 30 year's, since a child and I bought 4 Cannoli regular and 2 Chocolate covered shell. Hard as a rock and tasteless. Sorry to say could have cracked some nuts with them. They we're loaded with lemon too. Maybe the baker had a bad day, just awful. 👎
January 07 · Sue Ann Mariethe staff are always so nice! the cookies were delicious
July 04 · yourlocalcommonerSo let me get this straight…. A couple of years back the cinnamon bread decreased in size by about 50% but the price stayed the same at $4 which was bad enough.Now, they just raised the price to $7 per loaf!! And even smaller…. Per the staff: “after all the renovations, they changed all the prices”…. So a never ending tax to customers to pay for your renovations…. Keep your bread and keep the inflated prices all over your village. After 10 years, I am using my local bakery for all my business. Truly disgusting.
December 28 · StevenNot very much of a selection today early morning. One staff member that was very slow and couldn’t answer any questions about the pastry. Was there 30 min while she talked on the phone. The cash register paper jammed and she couldn’t really give me prices on certain items! The receipt didn’t itemize the tuff we purchased which was $100.45. Had to bag all our stuff. There was no help there. Very slow. People walking out. Then I decided to get two loafs of bread and asked to slice it, she said the machine was broken. Have been coming there many years. Things got very small and not as good as it use to be. The worker’’ didn’t seem to care about anything at all.
December 23 · Timothy SullivanExceptionally disappointed with my recent purchase. Pecan ring looked excellent but was so dry it definitely wasn’t fresh, although staff said it was. It ended up in the trash. Worst $20 spent. I should have read the reviews first before making a purchase. Wouldn’t recommend you making the trip. Definitely a tourist trap.
October 28 · Dorothy Musca
More Bakery Near Me
Beyond Bagels3.0 (257 reviews)523 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
National Bagel Association0.0 (0 reviews)425 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
Bagel Doctor4.0 (370 reviews)289 N Broadway, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
Auntie Anne's3.0 (37 reviews)358 N Broadway Space # 0883A, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Best Cookies Shop NYC / New York Bakery Cookies/ The Cookie Outlet3.0 (45 reviews)500 W John St, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Duchess Cookies4.0 (213 reviews)331 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA
House of Donuts Inc4.0 (472 reviews)95 Broadway Suite B, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Bread in Oven4.0 (183 reviews)13 W Marie St, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Paris Baguette4.0 (154 reviews)381 S Oyster Bay Rd #33, Plainview, NY 11803, USA
COBS Bread4.0 (10 reviews)353 S Oyster Bay Rd Unit 15, Plainview, NY 11803, USA
Bagel Boss Hicksville4.0 (1177 reviews)432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA
Bagel Boss of Jericho3.0 (358 reviews)10 Jericho Tpke, Jericho, NY 11753, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites
Tous Les Jours4.0 (590 reviews)
Mark's Bake Shoppe4.0 (271 reviews)
Stuff A Bagel4.0 (67 reviews)
House of Bagels4.0 (871 reviews)
Alexandria Pastry Shop4.0 (466 reviews)
EGG LAB Fort Lee3.0 (12 reviews)Top Bakery Searches
Trending Bakery Tales Posts
How to Create a Beautiful Bakery-Style Dessert Spread
How to Bake Delicious Chocolate Chip Muffins: Easy Recipe for Sweet Treats
How to Make the Best Homemade Chocolate Covered Oreos: A Step-by-Step Guide
How to Make Homemade Hot Cross Buns for Easter (Step-by-Step Guide)
Top 10 Most Popular Cookies and How to Make Them at Home
How to Make Homemade Hot Cross Buns for Easter | Delicious Recipe Guide
